mv-k Red Velvet - Birthday (Music Video)

[Lee]

 

[Iljin Oppa]

Bruh the melody is all over the place idk what to think about it.

[Seunghee's eyebrows]

I love it! Some parts of the song sounds similar to SONAMOO's Cushion, not that it's a bad thing but it reminded me of it.

 

[deliriousness]

37 minutes ago, Iljin Oppa said:

Bruh the melody is all over the place idk what to think about it.

confirmed smash hit

[heart clue]

in some ways it's a very rv track (the chorus especially reminds me of older songs of theirs) but i feel like there was a bit too much talk rapping for my liking, especially on the first verse. tbh i was a bit overwhelmed by the visuals + the melody while watching the mv but the song grew on me when listening on spotify.

[Guest]

i love it!!! the MV is so very visually pleasing and i love the concept of them fighting all the party-goers through party games to get to the end. also the stuffed animal PENTAGRAM, Red Velvet cult girls confirmed the song really calls back to their early days but with the grandiosity of their newer stuff.

[Mrs. Morale]

It's not bad but it's not great either. It's okay. I don't know if it's because I have lost some interest in kpop this year especially after second half of the year. Most of these song ain't hitting...

The MV is great. I love their outfits 

[WujuLike]

i like it but it's far from their best

[Your Biggest Fan]

Yeah... no..I'm not a fan.

I'm hoping that RV sampling classical music is now over because this and FMR are incredibly underwhelming. 

Also them referencing their past songs makes me worried. 

Edited November 28, 2022 by Your Biggest Fan

[vesuvius]

tbh this feels like a grown up ice cream cake. i actually really like it after the 3rd and 4th listens, but i don't see it topping a lot of their title tracks for me

[minniemoo]

i like yeri's rap in this, better than a lot of rv raps

i actually love the talk-singing lol it gives it a cool vibe

[Yeul]

The song is tired as hell. It is very Red Velvet, but it's a weak addition to their discography.  

I feel like they need a new artistic direction, more fresh, more Velvet, more 'Automatic'. 

Edited November 28, 2022 by Yeul

[GetRapper]

All the references make it seem like a disbandment song.

 

Seunghee's Eyebrows comment saying it sounds like Cushion is very accurate. I see comparisons to Dumb Dumb but it's not nearly as good. Overall I like it but will not go out of my way to listen to it and a letdown after the excellent Feel My Rhythm.

[RussianRoulette]

Not my #1 track from them but I like it! I feel like the MV is very red velvet-like and I like Yeri’s rapping! (Not sure if this is an unpopular opinion since RV isn’t known for their rapping but I’ve always love Yeri’s rapping )

[Belkiss]

SM is a mess 

the fuck is this 

[godblessdelulu]

No one with a sane mind would release this and think it’s anything near “good”. This is probably a one in a life time choice to sabotage Red Velvet.

[Elscian]

Whoever is in charge of production... this sounds like something half done or still in the works.  Like something a small or mid size company would release, not one of the biggest girl groups. I've ven noticing their recent releases have an incomplete vibe to them

[JNT-LEGGO]

I've been so busy lately I forgot to acknowledge my girls 

This definitely not their best, but then again I grew to like Zimzalabim and I LOVE RBB. I'll probably end up loving this too.

One thing tho, RV always stay true to themselves, they still gonna make weird music no matter what.