[theqoo] MUSIC BANK'S #1 THIS WEEK

[Mrs. Morale]

[theqoo] MUSIC BANK'S #1 THIS WEEK

(top down score: digital / broadcast points / audience points / physical points / social media points)

Kep1er

 

original post: here

1. But what happened with Nayeon's SNS points? Why does Nayeon only have 1 point...?

2. Both of them appeared in the exact same broadcasts so it's true that this win makes no sense..ㅋㅋㅋ Still, they just give awards to whoever they want every day 

3. How does Nayeon only have 1 point for SNS? She's doing quite well on Youtube though 

4. Mubank should just remove the ranking overall if they're going to do things like that seriously 

5. And Bangtan isn't even nominated?

6. If not for the broadcast points, the #1 would've been Ive and #2 Bangtan, that's why even though you're #1, you'll never receive #1 on Mubank 

7. Kep1er congrats~~~~~~~~~~~~~~❤

8. If we remove broadcast points, neither of them would've won #1 anyways so let's just congratulate them...

9. Huh? But in the end none of them deserved the #1 so why bash ...?

10. I feel like both their scores are low

SOURCE 

[Mrs. Morale]

Tbh, I can see why fans are disappointed. Many ONCEs were expecting her win, lol. Even I woke up with the expectation that she won

This is the 3rd controversy Music Bank has gotten into this year. Music Bank has no limit on the system. I know fans were saying that K1 had a week of tracking & Nayeon had 3 days.  But still don't make sense.

How did she get 1 on social media (Youtube + TikTok) when she has over 1M views on YT & 80k on TT within those 3 days.

Edited July 1, 2022 by Mrs. Morale

[pluto]

1 hour ago, Mrs. Morale said:

Tbh, I can see why fans are disappointed. Many ONCEs were expecting her win, lol. Even I woke up with the expectation that she won

This is the 3rd controversy Music Bank has gotten into this year. Music Bank has no limit on the system. I know fans were saying that K1 had a week of tracking & Nayeon had 3 days.  But still don't make sense.

How did she get 1 on social media (Youtube + TikTok) when she has over 1M views on YT & 80k on TT within those 3 days.

They apparently only count domestic tiktoks and views, which could explain the lower score. 

 

 

 

 

Kep1er just won on their broadcast points imo  

Edited July 1, 2022 by pluto
added link

[Mrs. Morale]

17 minutes ago, pluto said:

They apparently only count domestic tiktoks and views, which could explain the lower score. 

 

 

 

Kep1er just won on their broadcast points imo  

And Nayeon song has more views still in Korea & Music Bank does uses global views. And Nayeon has been promoting on Broadcast.  Music Bank has already been questioned fir their broadcast scores.

And you forgot to add

Nayeon out did them in every category but their Broadcast points. Which is already questionable since they did same to that trot singer.

At end of the day it doesn't really matter.

Edited July 1, 2022 by Mrs. Morale

[pluto]

11 minutes ago, Mrs. Morale said:

And Nayeon song has more views still in Korea & Music Bank does uses global views. And Nayeon has been promoting on Broadcast.  Music Bank has already been questioned fir their broadcast scores.

And you forgot to add

Nayeo out did them in every category but their Broadcast points. Which is already questionable since they did same to that trot singer.

I mean, I'm not disagreeing with you but I was just quoting with what I saw going around. And this is from the same account, they basically confirmed that broadcast points would determine the outcome: 

 

 

[Music Junkie]

why do people still give a shit about music shows lol, we know wins are bought from head to toe. the ""artists"" don't even bother singing live and the cameramen are just good at making full shots on the performers faces. never seen anything more boring.

[Mrs. Morale]

14 minutes ago, Music Junkie said:

why do people still give a shit about music shows lol, we know wins are bought from head to toe. the ""artists"" don't even bother singing live and the cameramen are just good at making full shots on the performers faces. never seen anything more boring.

Nobody is upset. They are just disappointed. I wanted her to have her first win, only for this to be questionable

Even K1 was surprised when they won. NY seem disappointed after they showed her Social Media points.

[Mrs. Morale]

58 minutes ago, pluto said:

I mean, I'm not disagreeing with you but I was just quoting with what I saw going around. And this is from the same account, they basically confirmed that broadcast points would determine the outcome: 

 

 

Even then her Social media points are questionable. Music Bank has no points limit. She literally got 15 times more than K1 in Social Media.

Eben then....based on a random calculation

From the prediction without Broadcast & SM:

NY - 

NY - 5,163 & K1 - 4,456

NY has 600 points more

If we add the broadcast scores from the show:

NY - 9,133 & K1 - 10,463

Now if we add SM points from the show:

NY - 9,134 & K1 - 10,494

 

The question is how Nayeon got 1 points for SM when she has 15 times more than K1. If this was really the case than Nayeon Social media points should around 1,200 or so. K1 is not even in Melon Top 100.

Good for them on their win.

Edited July 1, 2022 by Mrs. Morale

[oden]

The day i saw kepler loss to loona...that the day that i realize seem like domestically....nobody gives a shit about them beside international fan where loona were famous for that....

[headway]

The music shows mean nothing. 

If a company really wants some awards, then they just release at the times no other groups/soloists release.

Edited July 2, 2022 by headway

[thrutkk]

9 hours ago, pluto said:

They apparently only count domestic tiktoks and views, which could explain the lower score. 

 

 

 

 

Kep1er just won on their broadcast points imo  

then you have to check the music bank channel on naver. I know they count youtube views but if they only count Korean usage it's definitely not much different from naver tv.