Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Would Kep1ler's Bahiyyih be popular without her brother?


jeong jaehyuns boyfriend

Recommended Posts

No. Idk why you got clowned, that was actually an interesting take. But ultimately I would think that connection and money plays the biggest role.

What would be interesting is to see Giselle in a SM survival show that allows international voting. It would be easier to test this 'relatability' theory.  Since she isn't a sibling of anyone famous, and it wouldn't be a company support thing if it's a SM only show (like sixteen).

I don't want this to be rude, but for sm standards, objectively she doesn't have a skill that particularly stands out. Her dancing is weak, another contestant Karina can rap like her or better, and there's plenty of vocals. Some of the traditional visual contestants would get a pass for their lack of talent. Now, how much of the international votes would she reel in out of relatability? Would be interesting to find out.

  • Like 1
  • Tea 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, jeong jaehyuns boyfriend said:

I don't know why either, I thought I was being respectful but I guess some people didn't like my theory, which is fine xD

tbh with u, even as an aespa stan i agree re: giselle. for some reason, her dancing didnt stick out to me during black mamba, but i think it was only because they used a lot of backup dancers and she had very little lines & center, so my attention was constantly elsewhere. but in next level and savage, it was just the 4 girls so it became more obvious that her dancing was always lagging behind the other girls. i feel like most groups usually have 1 or 2 members that arent that great at dancing (even a dance-oriented group like itzy has lia) but because aespa has even fewer members, its just really noticeable when u have 3 girls with 4+ years of dance experience and 1 member that learned for less than a year. i was impressed with her rapping from her SYNK teaser when it first came out, but now that we have more material, i also feel that karina's rapping is a little stronger. even though theyre different songs, karina's rapping on "step back" rly impressed me, whereas giselle was underwhelming on "zoo". 

now that u mention it, i wish SM had done some sort of competition show instead of SM rookies - im not a super huge fan of competition shows because they necessitate cruelty (i.e. not everyone can debut), but SM ended up cutting like 90% of their female SM rookies from aespa's debut lineup anyway, so it wouldnt have made a difference in the end. if there had been a show like that, i still think karina would be the frontrunner (shes charismatic af and def center material), and winter and ningning would still have high placements - winter's a good all-rounder and ningning's vocal talent is undeniable. its interesting to speculate where giselle would be due to that relatability factor xD

Lol you got clowned again,  but I agree with the examples you put in here. In black mamba, I also overlooked giselle's dancing. I thought that she was actually better than ningning.  But then in next level,  both of them took turns doing the same steps,  and that's when I began to notice. I'm talking about that step at 0:56, it was similar in the music shows. 

I don't think the difference is that big though.  But after savage and step back,  Karina also impressed me more with rapping, so I think for Giselle it would come down to personality.  I enjoy watching her on aespa's videos,  and if she gets a nice edit, I would think that she would get some votes.  But whether or not it would be enough to make to the finals would be interesting to find out.

At first,  I wasn't impressed by Karina after the sync video and black mamba, but now I think that she would be the all rounder in the show. Maybe not the best in each of the categories (considering the other trainees)  but a charismatic Jack of all trades, which is what could make her a good centre and one of the front runners.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top