is red light-the album a hit?

[dvang]

it's pretty safe to say by now that the title song from the album is doing only okish and not as good as rppp and definitely nowhere as good as their biggest hits like danger,electric shock and hot summer...

The album on the other hand is turning out to be their most successful yet with their physical sales doing even better than pink tape and electric shock and is getting generally good reviews from kpop fans

so do you think the album itself is a hit??

[AdzPower]

Yes.

[Gen_ki]

Yes. 

[Athena]

Yes. Selling better than Pink Tape physically. Musically better than Pink Tape.

 

The album is as solid as it's going to get for an SM release.

[oppaarrr]

The album? obv YES

[Shownu]

I really like Red Light. Its really fresh.

[High Fructose Yoongi Syrup]

Yas

[Someone actually]

YES. Butterfly, Milk, and Dracula are godsend.

[Random_Asian_Guy]

Yes it is I guess. I like it way better than Pink Tape.

[meems]

For me it is, I really liked everything and Red light. I don't get why some say it's really bad/ flop
It might not be doing well digitally but I really like Red light more than rppp. I think everyone has his/ her own opinion. I'd have loved if Knetz felt better about this comeback tho :c

[✴✧SeoulYoon✧✴]

Yes.

[Deumol]

If the album flopped on the charts that means that is not a hit.

For example sistar and 2ne1 has more than 4milions of downloads that means that the general public really liked the album.

Physical sales only mean fandom power.

 

Edit: Why the negs? It's the true tho.

[Jon Snow]

Yes. Selling better than Pink Tape physically. Musically better than Pink Tape.

[HerShe]

I'm not even a big f(x) fan but the album is a solid release. There are great songs there. I like Milk and Dracula.

[harootony]

Yes. 

 

Dracula, Parper Heart, Butterfly, Rainbow, Milk are amazing. I like it better than Pink Tape

[Tuis]

Yes, Red light, Dracula, Rainbow, Spit it out are my favs. then it's MILK all night paper heart and summer lover.

[you-aholic]

no, it's a filler album and i doubt that it will outsell 'pink tape'.

[xiaodery]

I don't like the songs much.

 

They start out bad and then become great and then finish badly.

[taemeans]

Yes. Selling better than Pink Tape physically. Musically better than Pink Tape.

 

The album is as solid as it's going to get for an SM release.

I'd definitely pick Pink Tape over Red Light as an album, but I guess everyone has their own preferences

But yes for it being a hit

[black_pearl]

oh  yeah!!

[ANTI]

it's a 7/10 for me

[Subzero]

Yes

[~ PD Hercule Poirot ~]

Yes

 

Milk >>> 

[klassic♥]

Yes. Selling better than Pink Tape physically. Musically better than Pink Tape.

[skylight]

for me, i love it