[theqoo] Among the debut songs of 2nd generation girl groups, which song has had the most influence?

[love]

1. Girls’ Generation – Into The New World

2. 2NE1 – Fire

3. Miss A – Bad Girl, Good Girl

4. Others

original post: theqoo

1. It’s “Bad Girl, Good Girl”, because that song won Daesang and Miss A got Rookie of the Year, so I have no choice but to choose it

2. Fire, I was shocked when I listened to the song for the first time

3. For me it’s Into The New World

4. At that time, Bad Girl, Good Girl was seriously not a joke

5. I’m a fan of 2NE1, but it’s “Bad Girl, Good Girl”. The song is daebak

6. “Bad Girl, Good Girl”, I was a muggle at the time, but I knew this song

7. Fire, isn’t it a national song? SNSD is more known for Gee

8. “Bad Girl, Good Girl”, I love it, I still listen to these three songsㅋㅋㅋ

9. Honestly, SNSD got a lot of hate when they debutedㅋㅋㅋ

10. I think everyone knows ‘Into The New World’

https://www.knetizen.com/among-the-debut-songs-of-2nd-generation-girl-groups-which-song-has-had-the-most-influence/

[Danee Danee]

Honestly at the moment of debut I would say Bad girl, Good girl.

Nowadays? Into the new world is on different level. 

[seokii]

I fucking love Fire and Bad Girl Good Girl, but I wouldn't have thought of them as being able to compete with ITNW

[balaclavarosy]

Idk why but I never got into Bad Girl Good Girl. Most of Miss A's songs hit so hard, but that one always made me confused with one of EXID's songs just bc they share similar title names.

[rananicolee]

ITNW because it's the song for EVERYTHING. From protests to bring change to Korea to the LGBT community in Korea. 

[Fubbz]

ITNW, for sure. Although ITNW is more of a hit now than it was back then. I never heard people speak much of ITNW from 2010-2015. 

Wonder Girls - Irony was probably more influential in 2007 than ITNW was, though.

Edited November 20, 2021 by Fubbz

[deliriousness]

every time i watch the Bad Girl Good Girl mv, the lyrics kill me. it reads like a Megan Thee Stallion song.

[Thigh-high feminist]

ITNW has become legendary but BGGG sticks in my memory more because they beat Shinee with it and according to everyone around me (i was newish to kpop) that wasnt supposed to happen (rookies beating a popular established by that time group).

But, it did and i couldn't even hate cause the song and point dance  were fire.

But, ITNW is on another level. 

[good_morning]

Tbh Into the new world has the biggest impact and longevity. It’s like a girl group anthem.

[Guest]

idc its ah, everyone and their dad wanted the hot milfs!

 

Edited November 20, 2021 by kouign amann

[love]

5 hours ago, marin karin said:

every time i watch the Bad Girl Good Girl mv, the lyrics kill me. it reads like a Megan Thee Stallion song.

u don’t know me
so shut up boy
so shut up shut up, ah

[Aphrodisiac]

Fire for the most hyped debut.

Bad Girl, Good Girl for the most successful debut.

ITNW for the most impactful debut.

 

[chila]

If the question is most influential, I would maybe say Fire due to them being the first (modern) girl crush concept GG and paving the way for Blackpink and most 4th gen GGs. 

[Angel_Nessa]

Bad Girl Good Girl - they still play this song on gayos and award ceremonies 

I don't know if Wonder Girls is considered to be a 1st or 2nd generation group, but their song "nobody" was really popular baack then.

[Aegyo]

BGGG is such a masterpiece..i was blown away when they first debuted, and I still jam to it, till now, many idols still cover the song. It's unique and its sound is timeless.

ITNW is such a beautiful and powerful song.