Red Light vs. Pink Tape - Track by Track

[Joji.]

Two years in a row, f(deities) have blessed us with near perfect K-Pop albums.. but which is better?

 

I've tried to match each Red Light with the one I feel it sounds the most like on Pink Tape. I left out Snapshot because I couldn't match it to anything and Red Light has 11 tracks.. and it's the weakest song on Pink Tape anyway.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJfuBmzd1tI

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2LwR_D-sio

 

Red Light vs. Rum Pum Pum Pum

Milk vs. Shadow

All Night vs. Signal

Spit It Out vs. Kick

Summer Lover vs. Goodbye Summer

Butterfly vs. Airplane

Paper Heart vs. Ending Page

Rainbow vs. Step

Boom Bang Boom vs. Toy

Vacance vs. No More

Dracula vs. Pretty Girl

 

 

Doing the first 6 tracks because of 1H's weird new poll limit.

[Athena]

Milk vs Shadow and Rainbow vs Step

 

Fuck this is hard already....my two favorite songs on both albums up against each other

[snsdJM]

Airplane and Shadow>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Meth Krystal]

The only song that trumps a track in Pink Tape is Rainbow 

[lilmik11]

Rum Pum Pum Pum

Milk

All Night

Kick

Goodbye Summer

Airplane

Paper Heart

Rainbow

Toy

Vacance

Dracula

 

This was really though :/ Both albums are so good!

[Witch Nose]

wow this is hard

 

how do you expect me to choose from Butterfly and airplane?? shadow and milk?? signal and all night??

 

[taemeans]

Only All Night for me. Pink tape is perfect

[cheese2]

overall i find pink tape better than red light.

[barbiedoll]

Jet>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Airplane/Shadow/Milk>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Joji.]

Wow, surprised to see such high votes for No More..

[oppaarrr]

Both albums are flawless to me. It's hard to choose one. Don't torture me 

[Athena]

If I had to choose:

Red Light

Shadow

Butterfly

Rainbow

All Night

No More

Spit It Out

Summer Lover

Paper Heart

Dracula

Boom Bang Boom

[stargazer]

The only song that trumps a track in Pink Tape is Rainbow

[I Killed Your Neopet]

i actually think all in all Red Light is a better album holy shit. The only weak track imo on Red Light is Summer Love, Vacation is pretty low too but every other track just kills Pink Tape. Surprised Airplane has more votes. 

 

jesus, i hate typing out the albums in the same sentence. Red tape pink light bye. Also can i just say i feel like Paper Heart gets no love but that song is 

[Step]

Rum Pum Pum > Red Light

Milk > Shadow

All Night > Signal

Kick > Spit it out

Goodbye Summer > Summer Lover

Butterfly > Airplane (This one was hard, they both RAWK)

Paper Heart > Ending Page (I wasn't hot on either of these songs =/)

Step > Rainbow (Obv obv)

Boom Bang Boom > Toy

Vacance > No More

Dracula > Pretty Girl

[✽aya]

Red Light

Shadow

Butterfly

Paper Heart

Rainbow

Dracula

 

Didnt like the other songs enough to rank them, really like both milk and shadow but in the end...

[sofi]

This is hard... I need some time

[Candyboojae]

Airplane and Shadow>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[macchatea]

Only All Night for me. Pink tape is perfect

[Mich_]

Red Light vs. Rum Pum Pum Pum

Milk vs. Shadow

All Night vs. Signal (too hard to decide)

Spit It Out vs. Kick

Summer Lover vs. Goodbye Summer

Butterfly vs. Airplane (too hard to decide)

Paper Heart vs. Ending Page (too hard to decide)

Rainbow vs. Step

Boom Bang Boom vs. Toy

Vacance vs. No More

Dracula vs. Pretty Girl (too hard to decide)

[jsa]

Lack of Signal love here is making me cry 

 

I've only listened through Red Light once so far, but Signal and Shadow are without a doubt my favorite f(x) songs, 

I prefer Airplane to Rainbow and RPPP to Red Light..

 

Those are the only ones I have a solid opinion on

[TAKADA KENTA]

I'm surprised that Snapshot was considered the weakest track in Pink Tape. I thought the song was really good, but maybe that's just me.

[GungdiSundi]

Red Light vs. Rum Pum Pum Pum

Milk vs. Shadow

All Night vs. Signal

Spit It Out vs. Kick

Summer Lover vs. Goodbye Summer

Butterfly vs. Airplane (Very tough decision though)

Paper Heart vs. Ending Page

Rainbow vs. Step

Boom Bang Boom vs. Toy

Vacance vs. No More

Dracula vs. Pretty Girl

[dopamine]

Airplane and Shadow>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

 

The only song that trumps a track in Pink Tape is Rainbow 

[XtyX]

Red Light vs. Rum Pum Pum Pum

Milk vs. Shadow

All Night vs. Signal

Spit It Out vs. Kick

Summer Lover vs. Goodbye Summer

Butterfly vs. Airplane

Paper Heart vs. Ending Page

Rainbow vs. Step

Boom Bang Boom vs. Toys

Vacance vs. No More

Dracula vs. Pretty Girl

 

---you're killing me with all these choices.....

Although I think Paper Heart vs. No More could have given me another hard choice....and I will most certainly choose both as well... lol