Do 3rd gen idols look older than 4th gen idols, or is the 5-10 yr age difference not noticeable?

[Corysilk]

 

 

 

 

Edited September 26, 2021 by Corysilk

[Corysilk]

For me, I think 3rd gen look a bit more developed facially so I guess that counts as them looking older.  when I look at 4th gen they literally look like 4th graders photo-shopped onto adult bodies.  Its like their features are under cooked and still need time to form or something.  So while 3rd gen look young, I think they would look out of place next to this new fetus generation.

[starsocks]

I mean they're still mostly in their twenties, it would be weird if they'd aged considerably unless they debuted like mid-way through puberty

If I didn't know Twice for instance, and shuffled their MVs from 2015 to 2021, no way could I put them in chronological order

There's intersection too... like 00s were the cute maknaes in the 3rd gen and now they're leaders in the 4th gen

[Corysilk]

30 minutes ago, starsocks said:

I mean they're still mostly in their twenties, it would be weird if they'd aged considerably unless they debuted like mid-way through puberty

If I didn't know Twice for instance, and shuffled their MVs from 2015 to 2021, no way could I put them in chronological order

There's intersection too... like 00s were the cute maknaes in the 3rd gen and now they're leaders in the 4th gen

This is true, plus 3rd gen doesn't look much younger 4th gen either.  Guess we won't see any real aging till mid 30s?

Edited September 26, 2021 by Corysilk

[seokii]

I mean. The difference between 3rd and 4th gen is the difference between adults and teenagers, no? 3rd gen certainly does not give me auntie/uncle vibes lol they just look like adults compares to teenagers

[Poetry]

Interesting how you used STAYC since there is no official YGNGG yet.

[krystalized]

These 2 girl groups had like an age gap of 8 years among their members but it really never bothered me.
Like, imho, they can pass as of similar age

I dont follow current girlgroups but i guess it would be similar too

Edited September 28, 2021 by krystalized