Who had the best transition comeback among Redvelvet, BlackPink, and Twice

[Corysilk]

All three songs marked a new direction for the ladies.

2017 RedVelvet dived head first in the urban R&B/pop genre and gained the highly coveted approval from black reactors

2018 BlackPink finally filled their big sisters shoes and delivered a hard hitting club track

2019 Twice started feeling their puss and gave the girls a taste of cunt while still maintaining their cutey vibe

 

Edited September 19, 2021 by Corysilk

[starsocks]

Bad Boy is easily my favourite of the three, but I think Fancy really helped Twice set the tone for their future sound

[GetRapper]

The descriptions for each MV

[satoori]

honestly gfriend had the best out of the popular 3rd gen girl groups, in my opinion.

twice.

 

 

[satoori]

adding on:

blackpink and red velvet haven't really transition much. 

blackpink continues to their yg-esque girl crush concepts

and red velvet is still doing their red and velvet dual concept.

both have basically stuck to their working formulas.

[good_morning]

25 minutes ago, satoori said:

honestly gfriend had the best out of the popular 3rd gen girl groups, in my opinion.

twice.

 

 

THIS

[Arceus]

Blackpink never had any kind of transition though, it's always the same Teddyesque song/visual everytime lol

Edited September 19, 2021 by Arceus

[Mrs. Morale]

As much as people hate to admit it. TWICE has the most versatile out of the 3 within the last 2 years.

From sexy cutesy bop (Fancy)

 

To a more upbeat ballad (Feel Special)

 

To tropical beat drop (More & More)

 

To retro (ICSM)

 

To sexy dark R&B (Cry For Me)

 

 To bossa nova/Latin (AF)

 

Edited September 19, 2021 by loveablejoy

[LostChild]

I don’t see any transition for Red Velvet though. They have been doing R&B since debut. Be Natural ? Automatic ? The whole Velvet album ? It’s just that the production and the visuals of Bad Boy were less retro and more trendy so it became their first full Velvet success. As for Blackpink they’ve been doing the same music since debut too, pretty much no evolution in their discography and I say this as someone who liked Lovesick Girls and Love to Hate Me. 

Twice definitely had the most noticeable growth out of the three.

Edited September 19, 2021 by LostChild

[rananicolee]

Twice.

Red Velvet has been making music like Bad Boy. It's their Velvet side.

Blackpink hasn't had a change in their discography. They have their music like Playing With Fire, Lovesick Girls, Stay, Forever Young, etc and then you have Boombayah, DDD and How You Like That. Like RV, they have two sides to their music. 

Twice easily transitioned while keeping their same style.  

[penyair]

bp dddd was revolutionary

[Mehhh]

red velvet aint transitioning ?

its their velvet concept pls

they have red and velvet concepts since its debut

[Corysilk]

6 hours ago, Mehhh said:

red velvet aint transitioning ?

its their velvet concept pls

they have red and velvet concepts since its debut

I thought their velvet songs were all covers and basically b-sides?  This was the first time they gave us a current urban bop that was the main character.

[Mrs. Morale]

1 hour ago, Corysilk said:

I thought their velvet songs were all covers and basically b-sides?  This was the first time they gave us a current urban bop that was the main character.

One Of These Nights? Automatic?? Peek-A-Boo???