[KN] Huening Bahiyyih’s overseas fandoms raise money to buy cheap sim cards to vote on ‘Girl’s Planet 999’

[Youahaen]

‘Girl’s Planet 999’ Huening Bahiyyih’s fandom voting controversy

Summary:
Huening Bahiyyih’s overseas fandoms are collecting funds to buy thousands of cheap SIM
The rules state that one person can give in one vote but these SEA fans are buying so many
It’s been 2 weeks since the voting began so if one person has 1000 SIM cards that equals 14000 votes
They’re even encouraging other fans to buy these SIM cards to vote

 

 

original post: pann

1. [+432, -99] ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ Seriously, all thanks to her brother, it disgusts me. Seriously if she debuts, they will achieve the worst first weeks sales among all Produce groups, and even the viewer ratings are badㅋㅋㅋㅋ

2. [+368, -9] This should become a bigger issue. This is no different than the vote-rigging from Produce and Idol School

3. [+253, -3] They say they will be fair, but they are not taking action against this??

4. [+148, -12] Anyway, I won’t stan them whether she debuts or not;

5. [+125, -20] Honestly, if she didn’t have her brother, she wouldn’t have gotten much attention.. She doesn’t even have an idol vibe at all

 

 

source: knetizen

 

[hynapia]

8 minutes ago, Youahaen said:

1. [+432, -99] ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ Seriously, all thanks to her brother, it disgusts me. Seriously if she debuts, they will achieve the worst first weeks sales among all Produce groups, and even the viewer ratings are badㅋㅋㅋㅋ

"all the produce groups"

It's curious how they consider this show like another produce season with other name, because it's pretty much that (with some changes).

I'm indifferent to her but moas have been really annoying about how she deserves to debut more than the current top 9 and for what reason exactly? I don't see them mentioning her charisma and talent, only that they want to make her brother proud (at least international moas).

If the group doesn't sell well or don't have GP recognition it's not her fault tho. It's true the ratings are lower than any produce season so their GP awareness it's gonna be lower compared to produce groups but I think they'll still have a big fandom, especially c-fans and j-fans.

[Guest]

lmfaoo hopefully they remove those votes

Edited September 5, 2021 by kimchi witch

[Guest]

this will backfire spectacularly, she is already getting ton of hate

[good_morning]

Ot but how is her name pronounced?

also, is she talented? I don’t follow the show but I’ve heard of her (thank you, stan twt), but no mention of her skills, so I’m curious

[AstroBaby]

8 minutes ago, good_morning said:

Ot but how is her name pronounced?

also, is she talented? I don’t follow the show but I’ve heard of her (thank you, stan twt), but no mention of her skills, so I’m curious

She's on the better end of the newer/younger trainees but nothing spectacular that makes her more deserving of debut than the current top 9. If we were to compare to previous produce seasons I'd say she's around the level of Minju. 

[good_morning]

7 minutes ago, AstroBaby said:

She's on the better end of the newer/younger trainees but nothing spectacular that makes her more deserving of debut than the current top 9. If we were to compare to previous produce seasons I'd say she's around the level of Minju. 

Minju from pd48 or Minju the izone member? i mean there’s a drastic difference.

anw, thank you;)

[AstroBaby]

1 minute ago, good_morning said:

Minju from pd48 or Minju the izone member? i mean there’s a drastic difference.

anw, thank you;)

Izone

[good_morning]

8 minutes ago, AstroBaby said:

Izone

Reeeeeaaally? 
 

edit: just watched her fiesta fancam.

1. why tf give trainees such a hard song to perform, i mean the key is pretty high and all the girls were exhausted after 1st verse, it was painful to listen

2. Bahiyyih Was clearly the best vocalist out there, at least the most stable.

3. But nope, not even close to Minju from izone

sorry for font change i had to copy paste the girl’s name from the title

Edited September 5, 2021 by good_morning

[Guest]

2 hours ago, good_morning said:

Ot but how is her name pronounced?

bah hee eh

[KentasGlittery EyeMakeup]

Bahiyyih:

Girl is getting dragged when she's literally done nothing wrong.

edit: why is this clowned and negged? I meant that she herself didn't do anything but the fans did, and I just made a joke. Why am I clowned and negged for harmless posts all the time.

Edited September 6, 2021 by KentasGlittery EyeMakeup

[good_morning]

3 minutes ago, kimchi witch said:

bah hee eh

Thank you!

[GetRapper]

I think the other hapa girl (Guinn Myah) is a bigger standout, but yeah Bahiyyih has the international MOA fanbase on her side. She's solid, but hasn't had a breakout moment yet on the show.

[Revanche]

Kai’s sister is a pretty average dancer with average vocals. She also has a below average visual for someone wanting to be a kpop idol. I wouldn’t vote for her. That said, fans vote for crazier reasons. They just need to do it fairly or they are setting her up for hate. 

[Vikturi]

Her and her brother's looks aren't even that special is the thing that makes me laugh.

[Danee Danee]

16 hours ago, good_morning said:

Reeeeeaaally? 
 

edit: just watched her fiesta fancam.

1. why tf give trainees such a hard song to perform, i mean the key is pretty high and all the girls were exhausted after 1st verse, it was painful to listen

2. Bahiyyih Was clearly the best vocalist out there, at least the most stable.

3. But nope, not even close to Minju from izone

sorry for font change i had to copy paste the girl’s name from the title

Most of the song were hard tbh. Fiesta, How you like that, Fifth season... Bahi didnt even stand out the most in her own group and among other trainees she is basically invisible. Its not that she lacks in terms of talent (she is mediocre though) but her charisma is literally nonexistent. Unlike Minju, who lacked confidence at first but her charisma was always there imho.

 

Their main vocal has issues with throat during the mission. It was implied she strained her voice while practicing the high note nonstop. So that's why they sounded this bad. Also if Im not mistaken these girls were leftovers noone picked so no actually strong contestant was there.

Edited September 6, 2021 by Danee Danee

[Cheeky]

I saw someone commented in another forum/twitter thread that those photos of the sim cards were from I-Land time. 

I mean it's pictures from I-Land period then clearly, those people posting the photos aren't really her fans and are purposefully causing her hate which really quite screwed up though... 

[Usagi.]

I see this girl getting SO much undeserved hate just because ggstans hate the fact her brother is in a boy group... Makes me want to vote for her.

[good_morning]

2 hours ago, Danee Danee said:

Most of the song were hard tbh. Fiesta, How you like that, Fifth season... Bahi didnt even stand out the most in her own group and among other trainees she is basically invisible. Its not that she lacks in terms of talent (she is mediocre though) but her charisma is literally nonexistent. Unlike Minju, who lacked confidence at first but her charisma was always there imho.

 

Their main vocal has issues with throat during the mission. It was implied she strained her voice while practicing the high note nonstop. So that's why they sounded this bad. Also if Im not mistaken these girls were leftovers noone picked so no actually strong contestant was there.

Omg, i feel for bad for them i didn’t check the whole perf, but frankly speaking it was bad, im sorry. To me, idk maybe bc it was her fancam, Bahiyii stood out the most in terms of singing. 

[Danee Danee]

1 hour ago, good_morning said:

Omg, i feel for bad for them i didn’t check the whole perf, but frankly speaking it was bad, im sorry. To me, idk maybe bc it was her fancam, Bahiyii stood out the most in terms of singing. 

In terms of singing maybe, its personal opinion. Because lets be honest all the main vocals was kinda bad here. But she didn't shine that much in her team. Which is something you cannot see on individual fancam tbh. 

 

Watch whole perf to see what I mean. It was honestly hard to watch because with every error they did, the performance fall apart more and more. 

Winning performance for comparision. The girl who got shout out from judges was totally the worst among both teams during practice. She didn't even try back then. 

 

Edited September 6, 2021 by Danee Danee

[doki-doki]

She doesn’t deserve hate at all but it’s a little annoying that more talented contestants don’t have the same support she does due to who her sibling is. 

I’d rather fail than succeed on the back of my brothers fans. It may cause an issue for her if she actually debuts. People already don’t take her seriously because of this shenanigans and it will only get worse

[seokii]

I can't believe ppl are really going after her looks, I love her face she's totally cute

I don't know shit about her family or her talents though

but this seems like a mess lol

[schue]

This is so embarrassing and gonna fuel more unnecessary hate towards her. I mean it's always fans that set their idols up and the latest one is this. Vote for her just to make her brother proud?? How?? I'm sure he's very dissapointed and embarrassed rn especially with how all this will backfire on his sister and him. I swear these stans probably don't have enough maturity to think of the consequences. This is not any different than vote rigging. It's embarrassing and annoying.

The show may crack down on illegal voting or ban international voting which they did so on PD48, not wanting the repeat of PD101 s1 type of results.

[Jejepang]

On 9/6/2021 at 6:27 AM, Revanche said:

Kai’s sister is a pretty average dancer with average vocals. She also has a below average visual for someone wanting to be a kpop idol. I wouldn’t vote for her. That said, fans vote for crazier reasons. They just need to do it fairly or they are setting her up for hate. 

Lol. Like we forgot about kim sohye

1 hour ago, schue said:

This is so embarrassing and gonna fuel more unnecessary hate towards her. I mean it's always fans that set their idols up and the latest one is this. Vote for her just to make her brother proud?? How?? I'm sure he's very dissapointed and embarrassed rn especially with how all this will backfire on his sister and him. I swear these stans probably don't have enough maturity to think of the consequences. This is not any different than vote rigging. It's embarrassing and annoying.

The show may crack down on illegal voting or ban international voting which they did so on PD48, not wanting the repeat of PD101 s1 type of results.

Yes. only insider/pd allowed to do the vote rigging

[Jejepang]

12 hours ago, doki-doki said:

She doesn’t deserve hate at all but it’s a little annoying that more talented contestants don’t have the same support she does due to who her sibling is. 

I’d rather fail than succeed on the back of my brothers fans. It may cause an issue for her if she actually debuts. People already don’t take her seriously because of this shenanigans and it will only get worse

But that's what the show is all about