[Pannchoa] TXT's Taehyun saying that his happiness is proportional to his album sales gets poorly received by fans

[My Everything]

"However our happiness is.. is in proportion to our sales. I want to be happier. I'm sorry (ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ however! if the content is released one by one, you can't help but buy it~!"

 

Taehyun-ah... you must be full because you couldn't see the sales figures of other idols

TXT's sales in thousands of copies

 

Weeekly's sales in thousands of copies

 

post response:

[+475][-283]

original post: here

 

1. [+469, -81]

Don't idols usually say things like "the results are fine, as long as the fans like it/us, it's ok"...?

 

2. [+354, -27]

But it makes me wonder why must he say something like this...? Maybe it's just a bad joke?

 

3. [+271, -322]

Huh? My ex bias used to make capitalist jokes too. Just seeing this, you can tell that it's a jokeㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ people nowadays really get hated for anything

 

4. [+256, -24]

Most of TXT's fans are still at the age of buying their albums using their parents' money. Whether this is a joke or not, he does need to be careful of saying something like this. I've seen a lot of adult fans in this fandom telling student fans that they don't need to stream as hard and that they don't need to feel pressure. But if their artist end up saying something like this, then...

 

5. [+222, -37]

The fans below are shielding him just like ATMs

 

6. [+197, -21]

He's always the only one causing controversies in TXT... seriously, I really hope that he's more careful with his words

 

Source

[himi]

6. [+197, -21]

He's always the only one causing controversies in TXT... seriously, I really hope that he's more careful with his words

 

anyone knows what else he did?

Edited May 10, 2021 by himi

[Guest]

I would need more context to this, like his tone and the words before, but im pretty sure he is joking. Either way it's unhealthy both for the artist and fans. While having good sale figures is good, being so focused on them is bad for the idols too and fans would worry that they need to do more too. I think it's best if your fans like your songs. 

[starsocks]

it was an in-joke with moas re: weverse posts and vlive comments

but also who cares

[Guest]

1 minute ago, choiyujins said:

it was an in-joke with moas re: weverse posts and vlive comments

but also who cares

Ah so they just cut this one comment out and bam pann article i see

[love]

10 minutes ago, choiyujins said:

it was an in-joke with moas re: weverse posts and vlive comments

but also who cares

txt trend on pann every other day and it's 99% positive...but sure, pannchoa just has to translate this one article about a comment taken out of context...right before their comeback...

they ain't slick 

[hynapia]

Pretty sure he's just joking. People truly gets offended by anything nowadays, it's freaking tiring.

Also what with the random comparison with weeekly?

[KentasGlittery EyeMakeup]

17 minutes ago, love said:

txt trend on pann every other day and it's 99% positive...but sure, pannchoa just has to translate this one article about a comment taken out of context...right before their comeback...

they ain't slick 

Pannchoa is so transparent about what they translate and about who.

[schue]

You can tell Pannchoa always likes to translate articles/threads on pann (much like a forums on oh, akp, soompi) that are taken out of context/manipulated and sometimes exaggerated/slandered just to drag a group or idol right before their cb. They couldn't be more obvious with the intention.

[himi]

1 hour ago, himi said:

6. [+197, -21]

He's always the only one causing controversies in TXT... seriously, I really hope that he's more careful with his words

 

anyone knows what else he did?

ok to whoever disliked my comment i wasn't trying to spread hate or smtn i was just genuinely curious lol. i don't stan them but as far as i know they never had any controversies

[Rei sakuma]

1 hour ago, himi said:

6. [+197, -21]

He's always the only one causing controversies in TXT... seriously, I really hope that he's more careful with his words

 

anyone knows what else he did?

TxT in general are quite unproblematic. I think the comment said that because Taehyun is known for being "savage". Meaning that he is quite comfortable with his members and maybe say things that could be considered rude. I won't read too much into it though, people speak like that to their friends all the time. The og commenter could also be biased because to my knowledge, Taehyun is the least popular in TXT (at least in korea but i also think internationally). 

[lighterxx]

41 minutes ago, himi said:

ok to whoever disliked my comment i wasn't trying to spread hate or smtn i was just genuinely curious lol. i don't stan them but as far as i know they never had any controversies

i was curious so i took a look, among int fans there is a singing video that is seen as controversial, and under this comment on pann they are talking about something with music but i didnt get that. 

 

 

 

otherwise, while i dont like idols making capitalistic comments lol, im not his fan, i dont know his behaviour or personality, nor full context, so its not up to me to comment or be uncomfortable about it

[RiseLikeACrowTit]

Maybe their label is pressuring them to sell, it wouldnt be so crazy

[Nev Schulman]

2 hours ago, RiseLikeACrowTit said:

Maybe their label is pressuring them to sell, it wouldnt be so crazy

Reminds me of that Dia situation. One of the members said something that could be taken that the group was disbanding and then she said she meant something else and that the group wouldn't be disbanding lol

 

[felidae]

4 hours ago, My Everything said:

Whether this is a joke or not, he does need to be careful of saying something like this.

 

[satoori]

i guess, perhaps harsh to some fans... but let's be real this is a realistic statement. money matters. overworking, lack of activities and disbanding isn't going to make idols or fans happy.

anyways it seems this was a inside joke among him and his fans. as usual non-fans/haters always doing the most.

[RIPHaldir]

Oh god! How dare an idol make a comment about being happy when their releases sell well - they should just put all their stuff up for free and be happy bankrupt I guess 

[pinkpanda_spirit]

[Youahaen]

I dont see what's wrong. This is an inside fandom joke taken out of context.

[penyair]

i mean epipen who is not a year-old needs 5k to outsell tits' latest album... this is a no-brainer psychological reaction 

[schue]

On 5/13/2021 at 7:16 PM, penyair said:

i mean epipen who is not a year-old needs 5k to outsell tits' latest album... this is a no-brainer psychological reaction 

Damn, you really have to go there, huh?

[My Everything]

On 5/13/2021 at 7:16 AM, penyair said:

i mean epipen who is not a year-old needs 5k to outsell tits' latest album... this is a no-brainer psychological reaction 

Not epipen

[Emsa]

On 5/13/2021 at 5:16 AM, penyair said:

i mean epipen who is not a year-old needs 5k to outsell tits' latest album... this is a no-brainer psychological reaction 

yall rly hate anyone even remotely connected to bts

edit: anyway tq has posts trending all the time about txt and they're all praising them so ig this is just another pann moment from the girls

Edited May 15, 2021 by Emsa

[penyair]

5 hours ago, schue said:

Damn, you really have to go there, huh?

say whaaaat

 

3 hours ago, Emsa said:

yall rly hate anyone even remotely connected to bts

i dont shit on gfriend