Blackpink vs (G)idle vs Itzy vs Everglow? Your Opinion Matters

[windy_dayy]

How would you rank them in different categories? Here's mine:

Vocals: Blackpink > Gidle > Everglow > Itzy (BP has more rounded vocals so I chose them. Jennie is very stable and Rosé voice color is heaven)

Best dancers: Itzy > Everglow > BP > Gidle (not sure about this one though. I suck at judging dance skills)

Choreography: Itzy > Everglow > Gidle > BP (Bon Bon Chocolat has the best choreo but the rest sucks. Itzy overall has more Fun choreo. All their choreo have been amazing to watch)

Visuals : Everglow > Blackpink > Gidle > Itzy (subjective. I find Everglow overall has more appealing visuals)

Now, the most important one, Discography: easily Everglow > Blackpink > Gidle > Itzy. Blackpink has more songs I love, but their music is kinda going downhill since AIIYL. I find Gidle's music doesn't age well. I loved their songs at first but they quickly became boring. For Itzy, Wannabe is just so good that other songs feel inferior. I just hope they release Wannabe-quality songs next time. Meanwhile EG keeps releasing bops of bops and I have no complaint so far. 

I'm curious to read your comments because it's fun to see varied opinions out there. 

Edited December 30, 2020 by windy_dayy

[LoonAespa]

Vocals : Rosé >= Lia > Yuqi = Miyeon > Shiyeon >>> Mia = Minnie >> Jennie = Yeji >> Jisoo

Dance : Lisa = Yeji >= Yuna = Mia = Chaeryong >= Ryujin = E.U = Soojin >>> Soyeon

Rap : Soyeon >> Jennie > Lisa > E.U >> Ryujin > Aisha 

[YooJeong]

Vocals: (G)I-dle > Everglow > Itzy > BlackPink (I prefer BP's vocals but technically I think their technique is weaker)

Spoiler

I think it's something like, Mia > Lia/Miyeon > Soyeon > Yuqi/Yeji/etc. 

Dance: Itzy > BlackPink > Everglow > (G)I-dle 

Spoiler

Lisa > Mia > Chaeryeong > Soojin > Yeji > etc. 

Visuals: BlackPink > Itzy > (G)I-dle > Everglow (Yiren >>>> tho) 

Spoiler

Yiren > Jisoo/Jennie > Yeji > Yuqi > Jennie > etc. 

Rap: (G)I-dle > BlackPink > Everglow >>> Itzy 

Spoiler

Soyeon >>> Jennie/Lisa > E:U/Aisha > etc. 

Music: BlackPink > Everglow > (G)I-dle > Itzy 

Members: Itzy > (G)I-dle > BP/Everglow 

Overall: BlackPink > Everglow > Itzy > (G)I-dle, but that's just me~

Edited December 30, 2020 by YooJeong

[deobizone]

Vocals: everglow i love sihyeon & mia vocals. I like the others too but i just like them more.  Honorable mention to minnie tho. Oberall group vocals i would prefer eg too

Best dancer: soojin and mia are top tier amongst new gg grpup in general tbh and rest of their groups is solid but id put everglow over  idle generally... then itzy then bp

Choreo: everglow > itzy > idle > bp

Visuals > everglow > idle (hard carried by me having a slight crush on soojin) itzy > bp

Disco: everglow > itzy > idle > bp

 

I mean tho im biased cuz i wouldn't say i stan, but am big fan of everglow.fav group after tge 2 grps i do stan (iz & tbz). And i will stan prolly if yena joins bc i plan 2 be fan of all post IZ projects and im alr big fan so yea biased hhh. And i used to be fan of idle but don't pay attn as i used to. Still like them ofc but i just mostly love soojin and minnie i haven't listen to bp or watch their mv since like dddd. Ive heard their songs in passing ofc but yea. I did like their songs before ofc (aiiyl is one my fav kpop songs) but I'm just usually not checking up on new kpop unless I'm a fan. I wanna try to keep up now tho hhhh. & i generally like itzy songs and members etc but not as much as eg ir idle ofc

Edited December 30, 2020 by deobizone

[hee_woo]

Vocals: Dunno

Best dancers: I think Lisa is the best dancer, but ITZY as a whole is more solid. So Itzy > BP > Everglow = Gidle

Choreo: Itzy > Everglow > BP > Gidle

Discography: Gidle > BP > Everglow > Itzy

Edited December 30, 2020 by _universo

[windy_dayy]

16 minutes ago, deobizone said:

Best dancer: soojin and mia are top tier amongst new gg grpup in general tbh and rest of their groups is solid but id put everglow over  idle generally... then itzy then bp

Choreo: everglow > itzy > idle > bp

 

You are the first one ever who ranks EG over Itzy as better dancers (google it and you'll see). And I find that interesting!  I love Everglow (and Izone) too!

Edited December 30, 2020 by windy_dayy

[caffe]

I don't know enough about the individual members so I'll just rank them by my own preference as groups

Vocals: Gidle. They have the most variety and most original sound to them as a whole

Best dancers: idk

Choreography: Itzy, I'm obsessed with their choreographies tbh

Visuals: I guess Gidle

[Mrs. Morale]

Vocals: (G)I > EG > ITZY > BP

Minnie & Miyeon vocals are beautiful + they are techniques are better than the others imo. I love Lia's vocal colour the most out of all the groups listed

 

Dance: Itzy > BP > EG > (G)I

Lisa is the best among all the girls of any of these groups but Itzy overall has better dancers

 

Choreography: Itzy > BP > EG > (G)I

I'm obsessed with Itzy choreography especially DD, WABE & NS. I dance to them even tho I can't dance

 

Visual: Itzy > BP > (G)I > EG

I stated this before but Itzy visual is more shocking for me

 

Discography: BP > ITZY > (G)I > EG

[Elscian]

vocals: eg>bp>gidle>itzy (in terms of main vocals only and live singing in radios etc, because I can't recall everyone's singing.  I've heard minnie and miyeon sing live and they were rather shaky unlike their studio version, specially miyeon was just like jisoo.  But yuqi is my fave voice from here. Mia sounds less screechy than rose. Overall could be bp).

Dance: itzy>bp>eg>gidle (itzy has like 3 main dancer level and bp has 2. Yuna is also pretty good. Soojin has great expressions.)

Choreo: itzy>bp>eg>gidle

Rap: bp>gidle>eg>itzy (soyeon best individually)

Discography: gidle>bp>eg>itzy (I liked most of idles songs except for like 2. Others have a fair share of ups and downs)

Edited December 31, 2020 by StanSatan

[oden]

you dont have best song categorize ?

beside vocal which blackpink win for me, the rest itzy easily take no 1 for me.