At this point by 2022/2023 all the 3rd gen groups would have lost at least one of their members

[Nana686]

Some have the renew of their contacts coming soon so we may see some more departures  

[satoori]

i doubt any members of bts will leave the group

however a few will begin to enlist.

[hynapia]

So far (counting 2012 debuts and onwards)

EXO: c-line (minus Lay, but even that's debatable)

VIXX: Hongbin

BTOB: possibly Ilhoon but he could still stay, who knows

AOA: Choa, Mina and Jimin

Winner: Taehyun

iKON: Hanbin

Monsta X: Wonho

OMG: JinE

DIA: multiple member changes, don't remember

Pentagon: Dawn

Momoland: Daisy, Yeonwoo, Taeha

ONF: Laun

4th gen (2018-present)

Stray Kids: Woojin

AB6IX: Youngmin

Those on the top of my head but I know there must be more. It's usually in boygroups and due to a scandal. But tbh, I don't see groups like BTS or Seventeen losing members because they work well together and (so far) are mostly scandal free.

Edited December 21, 2020 by hynapia

[Nana686]

5 minutes ago, hynapia said:

So far (counting 2012 debuts and onwards)

EXO: c-line (minus Lay, but even that's debatable)

VIXX: Hongbin

BTOB: possibly Ilhoon but he could still stay, who knows

AOA: Choa, Mina and Jimin

Winner: Taehyun

iKON: Hanbin

Monsta X: Wonho

OMG: JinE

DIA: multiple member changes, don't remember

Pentagon: Dawn

Momoland: Daisy, Yeonwoo, Taeha

ONF: Laun

4th gen (2018-present)

Stray Kids: Woojin

AB6IX: Youngmin

Those on the top of my head but I know there must be more. It's usually in boygroups and due to a scandal.

Ravi and recently N also left jellyfish , i think the others will leave after their enlistment too . i don't see how Cube can keep ilhoon and save BTOB image 

Edited December 21, 2020 by Nana686

[hynapia]

8 minutes ago, Nana686 said:

Ravi and recently N also left jellyfish , i think the others will leave after their enlistment too . i don't see how Cube can keep ilhoon and save BTOB image 

But leaving the company doesn't necessarily mean they left the group too (even though in majority of cases they unofficially do, like in SNSD's case).

And same. I think Ilhoon is definitely gonna be removed because BTOB is one of the few boygroups with decent public recognition in Korea and they'll want to save that image.

[Nana686]

4 minutes ago, hynapia said:

But leaving the company doesn't necessarily mean they left the group too (even though in majority of cases they unofficially do, like in SNSD's case).

And same. I think Ilhoon is definitely gonna be removed because BTOB is one of the few boygroups with decent public recognition in Korea and they'll want to save that image.

this only my opinion but i don't think they will be will prompt together in the future  ; we all assume those idols are super close but N leaving made lose all hope in some reunion like it some shit happened between them , some older groups made reunion in the last years like H.O.T and Fin.K.L and i see it happening with SNSD . kinda sad for BTOB 

[juniordud]

12 minutes ago, Nana686 said:

this only my opinion but i don't think they will be will prompt together in the future  ; we all assume those idols are super close but N leaving made lose all hope in some reunion like it some shit happened between them , some older groups made reunion in the last years like H.O.T and Fin.K.L and i see it happening with SNSD . kinda sad for BTOB 

Ravi leaving Jellyfish he explained how he made a deal with them to continue to promote with VIXX, when N left he also assured that he was going to still promote with VIXX even Jellyfish and his new company agreed to it. Now with Hongbin leaving VIXX now this is a problem cause VIXX is the kind of group that is a package, it's everyone or no one.

 

[Ghosty]

right now, i'm a little worried about loona with haseul. i know we don't need updates every single day, but i can't help but think that each comeback, we're getting closer and closer to the news that haseul has officially left. which is fine, because the idol life is incredibly hard and i would want the best for her. this occupation isn't just for anyone. just would suck since we'd lose a gem like her. 

 

51 minutes ago, hynapia said:

So far (counting 2012 debuts and onwards)

EXO: c-line (minus Lay, but even that's debatable)

VIXX: Hongbin

BTOB: possibly Ilhoon but he could still stay, who knows

AOA: Choa, Mina and Jimin

Winner: Taehyun

iKON: Hanbin

Monsta X: Wonho

OMG: JinE

DIA: multiple member changes, don't remember

Pentagon: Dawn

Momoland: Daisy, Yeonwoo, Taeha

ONF: Laun

4th gen (2018-present)

Stray Kids: Woojin

AB6IX: Youngmin

Those on the top of my head but I know there must be more. It's usually in boygroups and due to a scandal. But tbh, I don't see groups like BTS or Seventeen losing members because they work well together and (so far) are mostly scandal free.

the boyz should also be included since hwall departed from the group!

[hynapia]

10 minutes ago, Ghosty said:

right now, i'm a little worried about loona with haseul. i know we don't need updates every single day, but i can't help but think that each comeback, we're getting closer and closer to the news that haseul has officially left. which is fine, because the idol life is incredibly hard and i would want the best for her. this occupation isn't just for anyone. just would suck since we'd lose a gem like her. 

 

the boyz should also be included since hwall departed from the group!

Omg true, how could I forget about him? I'm glad he seems to be doing well debuting as a bl actor though.

[Drama Drama Drama]

1 hour ago, hynapia said:

 

Those on the top of my head but I know there must be more. It's usually in boygroups and due to a scandal. But tbh, I don't see groups like BTS or Seventeen losing members because they work well together and (so far) are mostly scandal free.

Maybe carats will be neg me but sometimes I think Jun or The8 want to try a carreer in China. Maybe they will be stay in SVT at least until 10 years but I can predict a flexible negotiation with Pledis to make more things in China ala Lay style.Jun won awards as child actor so he should reject a lot of love calls bc SVT.

[spopo]

Gfriend is doing just fine though??  Likely to renew next year, exact same lineup from debut.

And I'd be surprised if anyone from Twice or Mamamoo left either.