[PN] WHICH GROUP IS A REAL ARMY DANCE GROUP? COMPUTER PROGRAM CALCULATES AND RANKS MALE IDOLS ARMY DANCE

[lighterxx]

Army dance = synchronized dancing

1. Shinee
 

 

2. TXT

3. BTS

4. GOT7

 

5. Monsta X 

6. NCT Dream

7. WayV

8. EXO

9. NCT127

 10. Stray Kids

11. Seventeen

 

1. Seventeen - 95.77

2. TXT - 93.00

3. Stray Kids - 92.71

4. NCT 127 - 91.98

5. NCT Dream - 91.47

6. MonstaX - 90.36

7. GOT7 - 89.49

8. Shinee - 89.34

9. BTS - 87.77

10. EXO - 86.19

11. WayV - 85.53

 

 

post response:

[+612][-50]

 

original post: here

 

1. [+316, -8]
Isn't Seventeen crazyㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ They're almost 96%, they're  like robots

2. [+289, -9]
Seriously you really can't bash Seventeen for their army dance, people who even bash Seventeen for their performance should sit down and watch their year end performance or choreography daily... They're 13 people and ever since they were rookies until now, they're still popular for their army dance and the reason is in the videos.. If they're 95.77% it means that the error rate is only 4.23%.. They're seriously amazing

3. [+279, -7]
I'm amazed at groups who have that many members and still pull those numbers

4. [+133, -3]
As expected

5. [+97, -3]
Kwon leader clap clap clap

 

--

 

Here is the video. If you are curious about which performances are used, check the description

 

Edited June 25, 2020 by lighterxx

[sakurahanabira]

Where's Infinite? 

[lighterxx]

1 minute ago, melancholic autumn said:

Where's Infinite? 

Video owner did not put them in the list rip, i guess they would get at least 90 tho 

[angy]

Wasn't expecting exo to be so in synch hm interesting

[Guest]

12 minutes ago, lighterxx said:

4. [+133, -3]
As expected

 

this is crazy yooo

[lighterxx]

2 minutes ago, AAAAAAAAAAA said:

this is crazy yooo

I remember that it was so amazing, hoshi drilled even breathing at the same time to them lol

7 minutes ago, Angy said:

Wasn't expecting exo to be so in synch hm interesting

Video said they managed to find so few exo dances bcs most are not shared, if it helps o.o 

[Adlo]

I wonder how the algorithm took number of members into account. If it ran having to match each member to each member by dancing, the fact Seventeen is on top means all 13 have to be in sync, which is just even crazier and more impressive.

[Digiwon]

MX are so overlooked when it comes to dance. That's one of the perks when ur too good in everything, one side always end up ignored

[SJK]

Wish they had done ASTRO, I'm sure they'd be in the 90s too. 

[lighterxx]

14 minutes ago, Adlo said:

I wonder how the algorithm took number of members into account. If it ran having to match each member to each member by dancing, the fact Seventeen is on top means all 13 have to be in sync, which is just even crazier and more impressive.

It does not, it measures everything based on a video on dance practice or stage, it automatically finds the every human in the video, match them with sticksmans, and measures how together there "stickmans" move 

Quite accurate, not the most accurate since it does not note down hand shapes, but ugh i guess asking that level of accuracy is too much

Basically rather than registering members one by one, computer looks at tgeir stage moves,so in fact its actually more impressive since with solo dance combinations members are usually more careful o.o

[satoori]

BTS 'ON' isn't there most synchronize dance, so...

Would of been interesting to see other songs.

[satoori]

be nice to have the actual list of the songs used

it makes a difference

[Jaejoong01]

It is really amazing but I prefer it when idols dance their own style and not stick to keeping the choreography robotic. 

[Digiwon]

4 minutes ago, satoori said:

be nice to have the actual list of the songs used

it makes a difference

Monsta X's:

I think Exo is Call Me Baby, Shinee is Lucifer, SVT is Don't Wanna Cry and GOT7 is If You Do

Edited June 25, 2020 by Digiwon

[satoori]

2 minutes ago, Jaejoong01 said:

It is really amazing but I prefer it when idols dance their own style and not stick to keeping the choreography robotic. 

good point

and bts have gotten a lot more free and relax as they gotten older lol

bil, danger, inu would be fun to see it's results

 

1 minute ago, Digiwon said:

Monsta X's:

I think Exo is Call Me Baby, Shinee is Lucifer and GOT7 is definitely If You Do

since there isn't a clear pattern, it shows this person chose songs for a purpose

[Digiwon]

3 minutes ago, satoori said:

good point

and bts have gotten a lot more free and relax as they gotten older lol

bil, danger, inu would be fun to see it's results

 

since there isn't a clear pattern, it shows this person chose songs for a purpose

Lucifer is one of the most praised Shinee's choreos for it's synch though, so I'm surprised it's not one of the most synched out of the 11 analyzed

Also all these groups have far more synchronized dances than the ones picked. For example, Mansae or Aju Nice >>> DWC

[satoori]

12 minutes ago, Digiwon said:

Lucifer is one of the most praised Shinee's choreos for it's synch though, so I'm surprised it's not one of the most synched out of the 11 analyzed

Also all these groups have far more synchronized dances than the ones picked. For example, Mansae or Aju Nice >>> DWC

exactly. it's not very accurate measurement, in my opinion.

it would of been a lot better if the person would of picked a handful of songs (maybe top 5-7 for each group) and did an average.

also age matters too. many groups are a lot more strict with choreo when they're younger. which is why i find it interesting 'on' was picked as the representative song for bts (literally 7 years of being in the industry)...

Edited June 25, 2020 by satoori

[Digiwon]

6 minutes ago, satoori said:

exactly. it's not very accurate measurement, in my opinion.

it would of been a lot better if the person would of picked a handful of songs (maybe top 5-10 for each group) and did an average.

also age matters too. many groups are a lot more strict with choreo when they're younger. which is why i find it interesting 'on' was picked as the representative song for bts (literally 7 years of being in the industry)...

Is it confirmed they used only one song per group though? These pics could be just to illustrate the post 

[satoori]

Just now, Digiwon said:

Is it confirmed they used only one song per group though? These pics could be just to illustrate the post 

tbh i don't know

there's not much information given here

[lighterxx]

18 minutes ago, satoori said:

good point

and bts have gotten a lot more free and relax as they gotten older lol

bil, danger, inu would be fun to see it's results

 

since there isn't a clear pattern, it shows this person chose songs for a purpose

 

24 minutes ago, Digiwon said:

Monsta X's:

I think Exo is Call Me Baby, Shinee is Lucifer, SVT is Don't Wanna Cry and GOT7 is If You Do

No, video is already shared in a other thread, video maker even used bside dances of svt, i dont remember other groups ,but svt had crazy in love and good to me if im not mistaken

[satoori]

1 minute ago, lighterxx said:

 

No, video is already shared in a other thread, video maker even used bside dances of svt, i dont remember other groups ,but svt had crazy in love and good to me if im not mistaken

can you link that thread? i'm interested!

 

[lighterxx]

29 minutes ago, satoori said:

be nice to have the actual list of the songs used

it makes a difference

 

2 minutes ago, Digiwon said:

Is it confirmed they used only one song per group though? These pics could be just to illustrate the post 

Please guys. Im sad your groups didnt win, but video owner used minimum 3 videos per group to measure this

Its in the description. 

[lighterxx]

1 minute ago, satoori said:

can you link that thread? i'm interested!

 

 

[Guest]

1 hour ago, Adlo said:

I wonder how the algorithm took number of members into account. If it ran having to match each member to each member by dancing, the fact Seventeen is on top means all 13 have to be in sync, which is just even crazier and more impressive.

 

this is exactly what I was saying in a certain thread 14 days ago and I got 9 downvotes and 8 clowns.

Edited June 25, 2020 by SVT TBZ

[satoori]

Just now, lighterxx said:

 

Please guys. Im sad your groups didnt win, but video owner used minimum 3 videos per group to measure this

Its in the description. 

thanks for the video!

why are you sad tho? lol...being perfect in synchronization isn't worth being upset over. there's more to dancing and showmanship then it. as long as everyone enjoy their favs performances that's all that matters