[Douban] Quit arguing, just vote. Youth With You vs Produce Camp 2020: which show has better mentors?

[5201314]

The three most popular and trendy stars:
-Cai Xukun
-Lu Han
-Huang Zitao

Dance:
-Lisa
-Song Qian

Vocal:
-Ella
-Mao Buyi

Rap:
-Jony J
-Da Zhangwei 

https://www.douban.com/group/topic/174040440/?dt_dapp=1

https://douban-er.blogspot.com/2020/05/quit-arguing-just-vote-youth-with-you.html?m=1

 

[278 replies] [5 likes] [9 shares] [91 saves]

 

 

1. [+2024] I’ve seen for myself how the fans of that nobody Lu Han will try to salvage his pride in 10000 different ways...

2. [+1829] You compared Jony and DZW, do we still need to go on?

3. [+921] At least PC2020 doesn’t have any mentor that is pro Taiwan independence 

4. [+810] At least the lecturers of PC2020 all know Chinese, and their interactions are interesting

5. [+788] PC2020 has yet to put out any solo stages of the mentors, and it’s only the first episode. I’ve watched, and think that only Lu Han is okay. Why don’t you make comparisons after watching a few more episodes

Edited May 7, 2020 by 5201314

[spopo]

1 hour ago, 5201314 said:

3. [+921] At least PC2020 doesn’t have any mentor that is pro Taiwan independence 

who on Idol Producer is pro-Taiwan?  I'll stan.

[5201314]

19 minutes ago, spopo said:

who on Idol Producer is pro-Taiwan?  I'll stan.

Ella is from the province of Taiwan

[spopo]

Just now, 5201314 said:

Ella is from the province of Taiwan

Has she actually said she's pro-Taiwan independence though?  She can be from the ROC but still say she's Chinese.  Like Jackson is from Hong Kong but he's as much of a PRC bootlicker as it gets at this point.  Has Ella actually made a statement, or is it just bigots going after her because she's Taiwanese, without her having made a political statement?  I'd be surprised if the former because normally the CCP cracks down on that sort of thing.

[EXOSUS]

LuKris got famous for their visual so what are they going to teach these girls?

Idk why Tao became mentor at the first place.

Victoria learnt traditional Chinese dance but she was never famous for her dancing as an idol.

In conclusion, these mentors are incredibly mediocre to be teaching the girls.

[Drama Drama Drama]

As foreigner I liked both but YWY had better stages

But the chinese style of giving too much attention to the judges steal the time to know the trainees who are the real stars of survival

The cnetz opinion are more focused in PC2020 and the 4th opinion is shading Lisa.

The interactions of PC judges are possible bc all judges are not moving from PC studio meanwhile all YWY judges are in different places.

4. [+810] At least the lecturers of PC2020 all know Chinese, and their interactions are interesting

 

Edited May 7, 2020 by Drama Drama Drama