[Discussion/Poll] Queens of Girl Crush Battle!

[satoori]

two queens

 

[Wade-kun]

i was expecting mamamoo to be there in this poll.

[Siobhan Halo]

I'm a Neverland and a Blink and I have to admit that (G)I-DLE wins all categories apart from outfits. A lot of that is due to the lack of content from BlackPink and that (G)I-DLE is prepared to go out there in concepts and songs.

[oden]

i was expecting, gidle, blackpink, everglow, loona, dreamcatcher, itzy 

[satoori]

3 hours ago, Wade-kun said:

i was expecting mamamoo to be there in this poll.

While Mamamoo might could be consider it too, BP and Gidle are the "stereotype" for Kpop this generation, let's be real.  Image and style is the most widespread. Even other companies when "attempting" girl crush have this stereotype.

In general I only picked two groups for this topicT^T

 

2 hours ago, cyra laelia said:

i was expecting, gidle, blackpink, everglow, loona, dreamcatcher, itzy 

Everglow is still young. They're not queens yet. Princesses

Loona, Dreamcatcher and Itzy  are not purely girl crush, in my opinion. (tho Itzy maybe could be consider it...still if I had to pick the top two it would be BP and Gidle)

Edited April 25, 2020 by satoori

[Marinette]

I voted on (G)I-DLE in all of the categories except the stage outfits, I think. Discography wise I do love (G)I-DLE's music a lot better. There is not a song that I have not liked so far. And, concept wise they are a lot more unique/like they always try to bring something new to their sound.

I think I only had a bigger trouble deciding who to vote for on MV category,  both groups have some wonderful MVs, but still ended up choosing (G)I-DLE.

[Wade-kun]

On 4/25/2020 at 6:24 PM, satoori said:

While Mamamoo might could be consider it too, BP and Gidle are the "stereotype" for Kpop this generation, let's be real.  Image and style is the most widespread. Even other companies when "attempting" girl crush have this stereotype.

In general I only picked two groups for this topic T^T

Well yeah, no worries. Lets go with these two groups - I picked (G)i-dle for almost all categories. Soyeon alone is enough to carry her entire group and the concept well. Whereas for BP,  I nvr find Jisoo and Rosé suited for that girl crush concept. They are rather more soft-natured. 

[Acer]

1. Gidle
2. BP
3. BP
4. BP
5. Gidle (I prefer BP vocals) 
6. Gidle
7. Gidle