OFFICIAL GFRIEND ✦ DYNAMIC VISION ✦ VOTING THREAD

[love]

start submitting wild card suggestions now, just in case i guess 

[Jibang]

A few more, if not submitted already..

Spoiler

Spoiler

-> larger version

Spoiler

-> larger version

 

Edited March 24, 2020 by Jibang

[love]

On 3/24/2020 at 1:15 PM, Jibang said:

A few more, if not submitted already..

  Reveal hidden contents

  Reveal hidden contents

-> larger version

  Reveal hidden contents

-> larger version

 

0_0 they’re all super cute 

[love]

alright y'all, voting closes in a few hours, make sure to vote if you haven't... @sergel @Midnight Circus @Memoria~ (and anyone else who isn't showing up in my voting results)

[Memoria~]

1 hour ago, love said:

alright y'all, voting closes in a few hours, make sure to vote if you haven't... @sergel @Midnight Circus @Memoria~ (and anyone else who isn't showing up in my voting results)

Done, sorry i don't frequent this forum , I'm on another forum

[love]

ANDDDD OUR WINNER WAS...

Spoiler

WILD CARD ROUND IS UP!

VOTING FOR THIS ROUND WILL CLOSE AT 11:59 PM MARCH 29TH CST...TWO DAYS

(all choices are in the second post of the first page)

@Pyron @spopo @tuut @eternal glow @eunheart @Rainism @Sofs @WenSuelRene @Memoria~ @UMJI MOODS @Chuan @Jibang @Midnight Circus

[spopo]

ooh 3 is really cute.  But I like the winner because it's so recent.  Can someone sway me please?

[love]

16 minutes ago, spopo said:

ooh 3 is really cute.  But I like the winner because it's so recent.  Can someone sway me please?

 i'm indecisive af so...maybe i'm the least helpful person to do that 

[Lee]

Naver (same image that Jibang provided):

I rotated the original image 3.5° to the right, also scaled it down to 2100px.

For comparison with the original banner provided in OP:

At the moment, I am tempted to pick #1. I'm curious, however, to see option #4 with a different background colour.

Edited March 27, 2020 by Chuan
For some reason my scaling made the image bigger.

[eternal glow]

#4 

I am feeling it 

[Memoria~]

1 hour ago, love said:

ANDDDD OUR WINNER WAS...

  Reveal hidden contents

WILD CARD ROUND IS UP!

VOTING FOR THIS ROUND WILL CLOSE AT 11:59 PM MARCH 29TH CST...TWO DAYS

(all choices are in the second post of the first page)

@Pyron @spopo @tuut @eternal glow @eunheart @Rainism @Sofs @WenSuelRene @Memoria~ @UMJI MOODS @Chuan @Jibang @Midnight Circus

Done thanks for the hardwork

[eunheart]

Pardon my opinions but,

#2 - I love how this proportionally balance be it their position nor the background.
But sadly Eunha's eye patched is a no-no for me (you will want to see them at their flawlessness visual time).

#3 - I like the bright red color become major attraction to the photo.
Though, I'll like it better if their positioning as close as the rest of the photos.

#4 - I LOVE THE SMILES!! The strongest wild card contenders!

 

But in conclusion, I'm still hesitating between the current and the wild card one 

 

[WenSuelRene]

Thank goodness the initial winner was good. 

9 hours ago, love said:

ANDDDD OUR WINNER WAS...

  Reveal hidden contents

WILD CARD ROUND IS UP!

VOTING FOR THIS ROUND WILL CLOSE AT 11:59 PM MARCH 29TH CST...TWO DAYS

(all choices are in the second post of the first page)

@Pyron @spopo @tuut @eternal glow @eunheart @Rainism @Sofs @WenSuelRene @Memoria~ @UMJI MOODS @Chuan @Jibang @Midnight Circus

Is this the only wildcard round, because I only see 3 other options? What happened to all of those other really nice wildcard suggestions that were made?

[love]

1 hour ago, WenSuelRene said:

Thank goodness the initial winner was good. 

Is this the only wildcard round, because I only see 3 other options? What happened to all of those other really nice wildcard suggestions that were made?

what other suggestions? i only see three by jibang 

[Lee]

9 minutes ago, love said:

what other suggestions? i only see three by jibang 

  

On 3/21/2020 at 11:01 AM, Chuan said:

I believe that additional images should almost always be considered if it can provide additional value that may not already be available from what is already there (i.e., our selection of images).

Initially, I was apprehensive about having a wild card round because I was unable to locate a few images that met the overall dimensions. I was also considering editing but the material for the image was not available either. But, fortunately, I have two suggestions that could be considered if we do choose to have it. I recently found these images. None of them were mentioned during suggestions.

I also liked the 'Falling Light' image that was suggested but not considered.

 

On 3/21/2020 at 11:29 AM, Chuan said:

@love Someone online apparently got a hold of a larger image that you suggested. Don't ask me how.

 

[love]

5 minutes ago, Chuan said:

  

 

 

ah, i was going by what was posted after i told people to submit for wild card...well, we could do another wild card round on the 30th to 31st, although that's a hell of a lot of voting...or you can just tag users here to let them give their thoughts on those choices in the thread.  

personally, the sunny summer one looks too washed out in the back and the crossroads one doesn't give the uniform size of members that was advocated for...

the sunrise one is nice.  hmmm. i'm worried that if i edit the poll it'll glitch out again.

[Lee]

1 hour ago, love said:

ah, i was going by what was posted after i told people to submit for wild card...well, we could do another wild card round on the 30th to 31st, although that's a hell of a lot of voting...or you can just tag users here to let them give their thoughts on those choices in the thread.  

personally, the sunny summer one looks too washed out in the back and the crossroads one doesn't give the uniform size of members that was advocated for...

the sunrise one is nice.  hmmm. i'm worried that if i edit the poll it'll glitch out again.

I provided these images initially to support my case in wanting to have the round, so I automatically assumed that they had been considered. This was a mistake from my end. Unless there is substantial interest for any of my suggested images, I would be satisfied with these current options.

@Pyron @spopo @tuut @eternal glow @eunheart @Rainism @Sofs @WenSuelRene @Memoria~ @UMJI MOODS @Jibang @Midnight Circus

From reading previous posts, I already received some of your feedback. You are welcome to remain silent. Otherwise, you can share your thoughts of the images (see post above) and/or the image/s you would like to see considered in the poll.

Edited March 27, 2020 by Chuan

[eunheart]

38 minutes ago, Chuan said:

I provided these images initially to support my case in wanting to have the round, so I automatically assumed that they had been considered. This was a mistake from my end. Unless there is substantial interest for any of my suggested images, I would be satisfied with these current options.

Honestly, I don't mind get them altogether in this wild card round and maybe extend a little bit of the deadline. Though, on personal opinion, I think Sunny Summer one shouldn't be included due to being a bit older and also a couple of technical preferences;

Spoiler

one is due to the perspective view of the photo which fall deep in the middle (putting Yerin and Eunha being too close to the banners); and two, is that the backlight behind them two is too bright to the point that all the navigation at the top is not visible.

As for Sunshine, technical wise I feel it's way better than Sunny Summer. Also, I think those pastel colors setting help to make the photoshoot stay relevant across the whole year.

So yeah, my personal opinion is to include Sunshine to wild card round and extend the deadline a little bit 

[love]

6 minutes ago, eunheart said:

Honestly, I don't mind get them altogether in this wild card round and maybe extend a little bit of the deadline. Though, on personal opinion, I think Sunny Summer one shouldn't be included due to being a bit older and also a couple of technical preferences;

  Reveal hidden contents

one is due to the perspective view of the photo which fall deep in the middle (putting Yerin and Eunha being too close to the banners); and two, is that the backlight behind them two is too bright to the point that all the navigation at the top is not visible.

As for Sunshine, technical wise I feel it's way better than Sunny Summer. Also, I think those pastel colors setting help to make the photoshoot stay relevant across the whole year.

So yeah, my personal opinion is to include Sunshine to wild card round and extend the deadline a little bit 

extend the deadline by how much? final deadline is April 2nd...

[WenSuelRene]

3 hours ago, love said:

what other suggestions? i only see three by jibang 

I was referring to those 2 Chuan posted, which she re-posted above. I think those should be included. They all look really nice, and I personally think they should be added with the current wildcard options.

[Lee]

15 minutes ago, love said:

extend the deadline by how much? final deadline is April 2nd...

My recommendation is that we don't extend the deadline. Rather, I think integrating a fifth option (even if the poll gets a bit buggy) is probably the best course of action. But, if an extension is necessary, I'd suggest at least one more day, so we have ample time to finalise our decisions.

Everyone who has been mentioned has already been given the notification. If they wish to change their preference, they can do so.

[Lee]

26 minutes ago, eunheart said:

As for Sunshine, technical wise I feel it's way better than Sunny Summer. Also, I think those pastel colors setting help to make the photoshoot stay relevant across the whole year.

So yeah, my personal opinion is to include Sunshine to wild card round and extend the deadline a little bit 

15 minutes ago, WenSuelRene said:

I was referring to those 2 Chuan posted, which she re-posted above. I think those should be included. They all look really nice, and I personally think they should be added with the current wildcard options.

Thank you for your input.

[love]

new options added.  check the 2nd post ^^

[Lee]

Just now, love said:

new options added.  check the 2nd post ^^

Thank you!

[Sofs]

I love #3. I love the colors, the smiles, the fresh and youth outfit style. I love their head position, specially Umji and Eunha. Umji is looking so good with this hairstyle. They look young, fresh and beautiful. The red really pops out so nicely.