oden 481 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 i found this tier and feel like want to share it.....DO YOU AGREE WITH THIS LIST!!!???? for those who dont know ,what are the group name? here you go... S-twice, blackpink, redvelvet, snsd A-itzy, mamamoo, gfriend, gidle, apink, aoa, exid, momoland, izone B-oh my girl, loona, dreamcatcher, everglow, cosmic girl, clc, loverlyz, brown eyes girl, rainbow C-weki meki ,fromis 9 , DIA, gugudan, april, gwsn, hanapia, rocket punch, bandit, cherry bullet D-laboum, sonamoo,ladies code, berry good, sunny hills, brave girls, buster, elris, dreamnote, hub, khan, nature, saturday, pink fantasy, uhsn, z girls, honey popcorn. F- fanatics, favorite ,3ye, hot place, purplebeck, neonpunch, limesoda, wish girl, lalary, geegu, ans, ariaz, hashtag, midnight, pink lady, wegirl, girl crush, cherry on top. i kinda 70% agreee with this list and here is the reason why.. twice....is twice....as predicted...next.. i think if BP produce an album, they can swipe no 1 for sure...they famous internationally...but in korea...questionable....and its all because of that not having an album and yg scandal ....this remind me when wonder girl got famous globally and they leave korea, go on tour and performed at the US leaving the korea market alone leaving snsd the opportunity to conquer it all....thus we got to see GEE...back then 2007 2008 korea pretty much under wonder girl. when they comeback to korea ...its already to late with sistar come alone ,2ne1, t-ara and kara become bigger and bigger....jyp know they mess up. i dont like red velvet red version starting when they go for russian roulette....red flavour was ok for me, seem like it was a disney song targeting kid from age 9 to 15 but the velvet side thou WTF!! masterpiece!!!!! deep down i wish red velvet would just stick with the valvet side...and stop with the red side...this already dead since russian roulette ,to me at least. SNSD, i think this list is for active girl group 2018/2019 and i think snsd deserve to be on this list for what they have achieve within this decade. i think itzy in 2020 can easily climb to S tier list 2019 is mamamoo years!!! they rise and rise after queendom they rise again releasing bop after bop this year...and you can even feel that previously they really big in korea but kinda not that big compare to black pink or twice when come to international fame...BUT THIS YEAR GURL!!! they finally getting big on international level. i feel like gfriend didn't give the impact this year ,i even forgot if they release a song or not this year until i look up on youtube. so kinda understandable why mamamoo or itzy can already above them. gidle : LION !QUEENDOM! enough say! climbing and climbing ....kinda in slow rate compare to itzy ....BUT they consistence climbing for that top spot! nonstop! apink! 2018/2019 apink constantly show us they more then just a cute girl concept and they succeed ! they transformation was flawless!!! I thought AOA was going to disband....then queendom happen!!! like a freaking phoenix!! they rise back to the kpop industry!!! congratz AOA!! i heard that this year is the last year for EXID hopefully this rumor was not true!! this is the part where i dont agree much, to me momoland just a one hit wonder and should not be on A tier just because Philippine love them. should be at least on B tier. izone , i can understand why the creator of this tier list making izone on the last place in A tier list ...they probably will get disband....still no official news from them , lets see if 2020 we got any latest update from them. ok B tier ...i think loona or dreamcatcher should be in front but then again oh my girl finally become realllyy big in korea after queendom...soo...yeah dreamcatcher also freaking huge when come to international fandom, they nonstop releasing song after song this year and they GOT A WORLD TOUR! ...and loona finally win something in award show showing that korean general public/company /kpop industry finally acknowledge loona as the force that need to be watch out!.. so 3 group can be shuffle at the front of B tier... everglow....woooooooowww.....if they keep up constantly release bop after bop...me not going to surprise if everglow ,itzy loona and gidle on S tier in the future. CLC should be infront cosmic girl. they finally getting famous in korea and gain a big fandom on international level....after they do girl crush concept and fighting for ferminism right ,they getting bigger and bigger and good for them....but then sorn do some stupid shit....and you know the rest...for cosmic girl this group and loverlyz are the most stable strong and balance when come to popularity ,fandom size , album sale and award winning ,you know they are not a nugu or flop group , you know they winning something and have a stable kinda big fandom but you also know they not on the twice, bp, rv level or even itzy level. and Brown eyes girl and rainbow...to me they should not be on B tier ,i think this tier maker list just put them on this tier because this group are the second gen group that make a comeback after for so long...rainbow who happen to be disband ,join up again and making a comeback! the only group in this list that not having any change member for second generation group....brown eyes girl comeback....sorry gurl ...not getting that vibe.....just meh. C tier - weki meki YES !!!!YES!!! they finally got international fan attention!!! releasing 2 song this year and international finally love what they release! i can see 2020 they going to soar up in the tier list sky! seem like the mnet scandal not only affect izone but also fromis 9 ...after mnet got expose....they work so hard to get recognition after love bomb ,ppl finally notice them and have some interest in them ,but then mnet scandal happen ........lets see if we can get and info about them this 2020. i freaking love DIA song this year!! sadly WHY~~~WHY not much people love it!!???? dont know what happen to gugudan and april ,i heard they do alot of event concert .....that all.....GWSN have a huge international fandom!! they sound like fx and not in a bad way ,they able to pull of!! which is great!! not many gg do fx concept! i love them! PHOENIX! BACK FROM THE DEAD!! hanapia!!!!!aka pristin to me although only 3 member from pristin...and i hope nayeon, pinky and xiyeon join hanapia......GODAMMIT WHY GOD WHY!!?? JUST PUT THIS 3 IN HANAPIA FOR GODSAKE! Rocket punch ,i love their debut song!! the question is ....will they put izone member in the group after this?? same goes with yena in everglow??? bandit is a younger sister of chunha group! cherrybullet ....where they go?? next thing i know some member leaving???? not a good start... the rest of the tier i to tired to give an opinion , D tier i still know all the group BUT F TIER!!??? NUGU!!!??? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 30, 2019 Author Share Posted December 30, 2019 to me, most kpop fan know group from S tier to C tier...old timer maybe to the D tier BUT HARDCORE KPOP FAN probably know until F tier or youtube recomd just when in a nutshell and recommend you those F tier group mv... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bronx. 2,763 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 what is this shit Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
satoori 45,814 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 (edited) Base on total physical album sales, Fromis is probably with in the top 10 this year. And that's with just a single album (3 tracks) They sell better then some of the other groups listed in tier A and B. They have a fandom willing to buy. They probably could be bumped up to Tier B. Maybe 2020 they'll be able to prove themselves Edited December 30, 2019 by satoori Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
seokii 3,424 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 I'm not going to comment on the ranking lol but you should add BVNDIT to D(?) tier, they had a comback recently. Also Wekimeki is gone, Hinapia is new Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vayafish 12,108 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 Wow i realize i know none from the F parts must be so many of them went mia after debut Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spopo 2,003 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 54 minutes ago, vay26 said: Wow i realize i know none from the F parts must be so many of them went mia after debut Actually, all of those groups are still active (just came back or preparing a comeback) and promoting on music shows except Wish Girls (which hasn't actually debuted yet), Lalary (which is a co-ed project group), Midnight, Pink Lady (another project group), and Cherry on Top. The other 12 groups have all promoted music this year on music shows, and 9 of those 12 were promoting comebacks, not debuts. The really really nugu groups (and even some of those I'd say are on par with D or F) weren't even included in this list. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 30, 2019 Author Share Posted December 30, 2019 fact and data!! emotion and feeling gtf off!!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spopo 2,003 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 No, not really? There are some placements I think everyone can agree with, but others that don't really make any sense (like they included project groups?? That aren't active anymore??). I'd guess there's some bias going on here based on how much they liked these groups' music. I'd like to know what they're basing this on. Album sales? Digital score? YT views? Melon views? Brand ranking? How frequently they promote on music shows? It seems poorly or too rashly put together. There are groups on here that haven't even debuted yet and groups that were left off here that are actively promoting. It's messy. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 30, 2019 Author Share Posted December 30, 2019 31 minutes ago, spopo said: No, not really? There are some placements I think everyone can agree with, but others that don't really make any sense (like they included project groups?? That aren't active anymore??). I'd guess there's some bias going on here based on how much they liked these groups' music. I'd like to know what they're basing this on. Album sales? Digital score? YT views? Melon views? Brand ranking? How frequently they promote on music shows? It seems poorly or too rashly put together. There are groups on here that haven't even debuted yet and groups that were left off here that are actively promoting. It's messy. i dont know, the person who create this tier list never mention it, the only clue that i got is from the title, the maker mention active gg in 2018/2019 ,maybe this explain why snsd also in this list. i know this person not a korean person , so i go with my first theory ,maybe this solely on youtube view ....so i search all this group mv one by one,but then the i saw some of the F tier group have more view then group in D tier....so...maybe not just from youtube view? maybe from public recognition?? but if public recognition, this person need to consider international or general public of korea....and we get that data constantly , ppl keep posting it in this website nonstop. for international we can view data from all social media ,alot youtuber do video about that , you can search it from this point of view still didnt add up with this tier list..example rainbow....even rainbow is their prime are not suitable to be put on B tier is tier maker exist back in 2007 to 2013 , and since he add up all the second generation group that active releasing song in 2018/2019 even if the song view are not that high or the sale are not that high ...so i assume this person just respect/adore/have bias toward second gen group.... so lastly i assume this is just base on this person bias and preference ,if sorely base on album sale, black pink should not be S tier so obviously this is not sorely on album sale... there even UHSN which everybody know its just a project group,yes its got hype for 3 month , have 3m view but that it...its cannot be consider a gg because it was never mean to permanent gg but then again ...then we shouldn't not include izone,ioi wanna one x1 as well right cuz we all know they gonna disband in the future? i also see there KHAN and i thought ,isn't this group already disband? or HUB? loona and dreamcatcher reallly big internationally ...the fandom keep making buzz but i dont know about korea ,dont have korea social media data to measure loona and dreamcatcher popularity and lastly how to measure a fandom size??? if in one hallyu its kinda easy if you have this group badge and so on...but on other social media platform??? so in conclusion , this list created base on this person perception and biasness only but there some tier were back up by data not only through sale but public recognition and some group in particular tier are just base on this person biasness ,that all what i assume to be....the only answer we can get is by asking this person ,i take this pics from twitter 3 hours ago, satoori said: Base on total physical album sales, Fromis is probably with in the top 10 this year. And that's with just a single album (3 tracks) They sell better then some of the other groups listed in tier A and B. They have a fandom willing to buy. They probably could be bumped up to Tier B. Maybe 2020 they'll be able to prove themselves for surely i can confirm that this probably not base sorely on album sale Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 30, 2019 Author Share Posted December 30, 2019 2 hours ago, seokii said: I'm not going to comment on the ranking lol but you should add BVNDIT to D(?) tier, they had a comback recently. Also Wekimeki is gone, Hinapia is new i post this so that you can search all this gg and see which one that you might like that all i just put same extra word to spice thing up ...you know ppl in onehallyu ... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 30, 2019 Author Share Posted December 30, 2019 3 hours ago, Yelena said: what is this shit its your Christmas present Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
satoori 45,814 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 3 minutes ago, cyra laelia said: for surely i can confirm that this probably not base sorely on album sale yea i know it's not base on just physical sales i was just mentioning that fromis seem to have a growing loyal fandom, and might rise next year Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vayafish 12,108 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 1 hour ago, spopo said: Actually, all of those groups are still active (just came back or preparing a comeback) and promoting on music shows except Wish Girls (which hasn't actually debuted yet), Lalary (which is a co-ed project group), Midnight, Pink Lady (another project group), and Cherry on Top. The other 12 groups have all promoted music this year on music shows, and 9 of those 12 were promoting comebacks, not debuts. The really really nugu groups (and even some of those I'd say are on par with D or F) weren't even included in this list. Thank you, this is my first time hearing about their names, barely knew most of D rank too Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spopo 2,003 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 37 minutes ago, cyra laelia said: i dont know, the person who create this tier list never mention it, the only clue that i got is from the title, the maker mention active gg in 2018/2019 ,maybe this explain why snsd also in this list. i know this person not a korean person , so i go with my first theory ,maybe this solely on youtube view ....so i search all this group mv one by one,but then the i saw some of the F tier group have more view then group in D tier....so...maybe not just from youtube view? maybe from public recognition?? but if public recognition, this person need to consider international or general public of korea....and we get that data constantly , ppl keep posting it in this website nonstop. for international we can view data from all social media ,alot youtuber do video about that , you can search it from this point of view still didnt add up with this tier list..example rainbow....even rainbow is their prime are not suitable to be put on B tier is tier maker exist back in 2007 to 2013 , and since he add up all the second generation group that active releasing song in 2018/2019 even if the song view are not that high or the sale are not that high ...so i assume this person just respect/adore/have bias toward second gen group.... so lastly i assume this is just base on this person bias and preference ,if sorely base on album sale, black pink should not be S tier so obviously this is not sorely on album sale... there even UHSN which everybody know its just a project group,yes its got hype for 3 month , have 3m view but that it...its cannot be consider a gg because it was never mean to permanent gg but then again ...then we shouldn't not include izone,ioi wanna one x1 as well right cuz we all know they gonna disband in the future? i also see there KHAN and i thought ,isn't this group already disband? or HUB? loona and dreamcatcher reallly big internationally ...the fandom keep making buzz but i dont know about korea ,dont have korea social media data to measure loona and dreamcatcher popularity and lastly how to measure a fandom size??? if in one hallyu its kinda easy if you have this group badge and so on...but on other social media platform??? so in conclusion , this list created base on this person perception and biasness only but there some tier were back up by data not only through sale but public recognition and some group in particular tier are just base on this person biasness ,that all what i assume to be....the only answer we can get is by asking this person ,i take this pics from twitter tbh I could make a better tier list than this lmao Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SonesLoveSoshi 418 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 The fact that I stan all girl groups on S tier list , I have good taste Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hynapia 3,977 Posted December 30, 2019 Share Posted December 30, 2019 If it's "active girl groups in 2019" SNSD as a group wasn't really active. I'm confused. I'd personally put Mamamoo in S tier. They're basically only behind Twice/Blackpink/RV in public recognition, charting, fandom power etc. I wouldn't put OMG in the same category as Dreamcatcher or Loona either. They can chart pretty well and have good public recognition. Same with Fromis, I don't see how they're in the same tier than Cherry Bullet, Rocket Punch, etc when they sell +60k already and they can chart decently. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 31, 2019 Author Share Posted December 31, 2019 18 hours ago, spopo said: tbh I could make a better tier list than this lmao here you go, this is the only one that i found , that have latest gg and didnt not put lot disband second gen gg enjoy and plss post it at here your tier list https://tiermaker.com/create/active-kpop-girlgroup-in-2019-233882 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 31, 2019 Author Share Posted December 31, 2019 17 hours ago, AbdulQayyumKamil said: The fact that I stan all girl groups on S tier list , I have good taste do you stan them the time they debut ?? or after they were famous ? 14 hours ago, hynapia said: If it's "active girl groups in 2019" SNSD as a group wasn't really active. I'm confused. I'd personally put Mamamoo in S tier. They're basically only behind Twice/Blackpink/RV in public recognition, charting, fandom power etc. I wouldn't put OMG in the same category as Dreamcatcher or Loona either. They can chart pretty well and have good public recognition. Same with Fromis, I don't see how they're in the same tier than Cherry Bullet, Rocket Punch, etc when they sell +60k already and they can chart decently. hey why dont you make your own list base your own info and knowledge? https://tiermaker.com/create/active-kpop-girlgroup-in-2019-233882 plsss post it here plsss Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spopo 2,003 Posted December 31, 2019 Share Posted December 31, 2019 50 minutes ago, cyra laelia said: here you go, this is the only one that i found , that have latest gg and didnt not put lot disband second gen gg enjoy and plss post it at here your tier list https://tiermaker.com/create/active-kpop-girlgroup-in-2019-233882 tbh because there are way too many groups missing from that list, as well as groups that are not currently active (and a couple of groups that I don't even think are kpop) I don't really think it's a good base. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
oden 481 Posted December 31, 2019 Author Share Posted December 31, 2019 3 hours ago, spopo said: tbh because there are way too many groups missing from that list, as well as groups that are not currently active (and a couple of groups that I don't even think are kpop) I don't really think it's a good base. i think its better make your own then i can use it Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spopo 2,003 Posted December 31, 2019 Share Posted December 31, 2019 26 minutes ago, cyra laelia said: i think its better make your own then i can use it When I have more time maybe. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SonesLoveSoshi 418 Posted January 2, 2020 Share Posted January 2, 2020 On 12/31/2019 at 12:47 PM, cyra laelia said: do you stan them the time they debut ?? or after they were famous ? hey why dont you make your own list base your own info and knowledge? https://tiermaker.com/create/active-kpop-girlgroup-in-2019-233882 plsss post it here plsss I stan : SNSD (2010) - Oh! era TWICE (2015) - LOA era Red Velvet (2015) - Ice Cream Cake era BLACKPINK (2016) - Boombayah and Whistle era Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now