Your opinion about a Season 2 of Queendom...

[satoori]

If there is a second season, who all would make a good addition to the show?

Season 1 - Contestants
Park Bom
AOA
Mamamoo
Lovelyz
Oh My Girl
(G)I-DLE

 

 

Edited September 30, 2019 by satoori

[satoori]

Anda - Seungri scandal sort of ruined her rebirth into the idol scene.
EXID - in need of a re-boost
Girls Day - in need of a re-boost
Apink or Gfriend - stable groups
CLC - In desperate need of attention
Fromis_9 or WJSN - both groups have relatively high sales. Need more momentum and attention.

Personally I feel groups like RV, Twice and BP do not need the show. Plus it could make the playing field very unbalance, since these groups have powerful fandoms. Let's give a chance to others.

[satoori]

Others I would consider...

Ailee or Chungha (or Somi, if she's up for another survival show)
Laboum
GWSN
Weki Meki
ITZY
Dreamcatcher
Momoland

Edited September 30, 2019 by satoori

[fictive]

clc fromis wjsn wekimeki dreamcatcher and momoland are good choices

not too new (2019~) not too old (b2015) and in the mid tier spectrum

+ loona gugudan

[dwejitokki]

I don't know why, but when I think in a second season, i think they'll try a "kingdom" (maybe because produce 1/produce 2 was like this)...

 

But i'd like to see:

DreamCatcher
GWSN
Apink
Gugudan
 

[Kyrie]

My opinion is "no thanks." 

I like the idea behind Queendom, but if they want to do it, make it:

1) Not an elimination show.
2) Upvote only.
3) Mnet has to pay for stages to create an even playing field.

Upvote only would mean that the groups that don't get voted up stay at the bottom, so you don't have to worry about there not being a ranking. The audience voting at the performance venue is also fine, since it's not the groups ranking each other. If nobody is in danger of getting eliminated, people won't worry about vote manipulation anymore, and the groups in last place can have a penalty placed on them or something that will make it even more interesting for them to battle their way back up. (Imagine "you have only one day to practice" or "you can't practice with a mirror so you have to tell each other how you're doing," real Cutthroat Kitchen kind of stuff.) And then of course if Mnet pays, you won't have to worry about groups from smaller companies competing against companies with more money, or companies who won't shell out the money for their idols. (Hi, Woollim, we're talking about you.)

[satoori]

7 minutes ago, Kyrie said:

My opinion is "no thanks." 

I like the idea behind Queendom, but if they want to do it, make it:

1) Not an elimination show.
2) Upvote only.
3) Mnet has to pay for stages to create an even playing field.

Upvote only would mean that the groups that don't get voted up stay at the bottom, so you don't have to worry about there not being a ranking. The audience voting at the performance venue is also fine, since it's not the groups ranking each other. If nobody is in danger of getting eliminated, people won't worry about vote manipulation anymore, and the groups in last place can have a penalty placed on them or something that will make it even more interesting for them to battle their way back up. (Imagine "you have only one day to practice" or "you can't practice with a mirror so you have to tell each other how you're doing," real Cutthroat Kitchen kind of stuff.) And then of course if Mnet pays, you won't have to worry about groups from smaller companies competing against companies with more money, or companies who won't shell out the money for their idols. (Hi, Woollim, we're talking about you.)

many good points!

but if you were given the opportunity,.who would it be?

9 minutes ago, dwejitokki said:

I don't know why, but when I think in a second season, i think they'll try a "kingdom" (maybe because produce 1/produce 2 was like this)...
 

a boy group version would be interesting

Edited September 30, 2019 by satoori

[Kyrie]

If I had to choose...........

GWSN
Gugudan
Weki Meki
Laboum
CLC

I love Dreamcatcher but if we have to see them in one more elimination show I might cry.  

[Pyron]

First of all I'd make it more consistent. Having 5 GG+Bom is a bit jarring for me. I'd have liked to see Park Bom performing with other soloists for consistency. Secondly, give each competitor a budget and add some challenges like making a MV with a set budget. No elimination as well. Maybe have different scores from audience, the competitors, a panel of specialists, etcetera and have them have a balanced weight.

Maybe alternate between GG and BG? I don't care about BG, but I may watch BG in an amicable competitive setting. They could do just soloists as well.

[tide]

1 hour ago, dwejitokki said:

I don't know why, but when I think in a second season, i think they'll try a "kingdom" (maybe because produce 1/produce 2 was like this)...

 

 

well you're right since even before the show aired, the producer said that if queendom did well, the next season would be "kingdom".

[SonesLoveSoshi]

I know this is wrong but I just want SNSD/Oh!GG to join .. ok sorry

[Elscian]

I want Kingdom lol

[Dove]

Definitely agree with CLC.