which song do you think did better?,gsd's something or a-pink's mr chu?

[dvang]

a-pink and gsd are two of my fav girl groups and they have been on a fast rise since last year with each getting their breakout hits and this year they got even higher with their most successful comebacks yet.Both songs have won a lot of trophies and have shown amazing longevity on charts and it's really difficult to tell whose comeback did better so from your own point of view whose comeback got them more popular??

[abra]

something

[eyeballs]

I like Something better. I also like APink and Mr. Chu, but Mr. Chu is pretty basic. I think Mr. Chu brought more hate from i-fans.

[MoonCakes]

Something by a milestone

[High Fructose Yoongi Syrup]

Something will always be better

[Juvenile]

mr chu has no build to it. the song is pretty flat and stays flat throughout

therefore, i'd have to give it to something

[핵!]

Something appealed more towards the male fans, while Mr. Chu hit it big with both the female and male demographic... also with all ages. I personally think Mr. Chu was bigger than Something... but not by much.

[KayKay]

Something. They're pretty different though you can't really compare them...

[Gabriel Celeste]

isnt apink doing well both digital and physical

[baetics]

None

[adelightfulsong]

Something

 

I'm not a dirty old salaryman.

[Seulo]

Mr.Chu

 

Mess @ GsD winning the poll

[Syupeo Seuta]

GsD > A-basic

[핵!]

Mr.Chu

 

Mess @ GsD winning the poll

I don't... think people even read The OP...

[Seulo]

I don't... think people even read The OP...

Same. I think they misread it as asking which song they personally prefer.

[bright]

None

[StrifeRaider]

I like Something better. I also like APink and Mr. Chu, but Mr. Chu is pretty basic. I think Mr. Chu brought more hate from i-fans.

The only reason why Apink got more hate from I-fans was because it wasn't sexy

[StanHyorin2015]

Even though Something is the only good song from SsD, and MrChu is a basic song, i liked Mr.Chu more.

[Lurker in the Abyss]

Well, even though Something has been stuck in my head for a while. I can see that Mr.Chu made Apink more popular than GsD. Mr.Chu is a public friendly song compared to Something.

[natroja]

Girl's Day Something

[Paper Ice Cream]

The OP is asking which song did better.

 

But oh well, Mr. Chu got some music show wins, currently doing good at physical and digital.

Currently no.11 on melon despite the tough competition, and would sometimes climb back to top 10.

[fourdayz]

Both songs are awesome as they suit the time when they were released.

I'll give it to Something as Mr.Chu is slightly flatter.

[Eunji_panda]

Something appealed more towards the male fans, while Mr. Chu hit it big with both the female and male demographic... also with all ages. I personally think Mr. Chu was bigger than Something... but not by much.

[The Nice User]

Well I checked their wiki pages (possibly inaccurate, I know) and Something has 1.1Mil downloads vs Mr. Chu's 800K downloads

 

if Mr. Chu can fill in the gap by the end of the year, I'd say A Pink but right now I'd still say Girl's Day

[abra]

Mr.Chu

 

Mess @ GsD winning the poll

 

 

I don't... think people even read The OP...

 

 

Both songs are big. Something stayed in the top 10 for like 2 months and has had amazing longevity. Mr Chu looks destined to have a lot of longevity too, but we'll have to wait a bit more. 

Something is currently the second best-selling song of the year, and had higher 8-week sales, albeit not by much. Come the end of the year, I'd expect them high up the final chart, close to eachother.