Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Shaun and iKON are, as of today, the longest charting at #1 on daily chart on Melon since 2016 with 40 days


Mees Madds

Recommended Posts

Posted · Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given
Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given

Is it for consecutive n.1? You never know with ULs. Shaun has had stable ULs for a pretty long time meanwhile Sunmi just released her song so we don't know if she's gonna continue holding that n.1

 

The top3 melon have low ULs, Shaun ULs is 500+K.

Link to comment
Posted · Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given
Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given

The top3 melon have low ULs, Shaun ULs is 500+K.

10cm got almost 1M UL during the first day and debuted and n.1 but fell at n.3 the next day.

Soulmate as well got many ULs at first but dropped pretty quickly. That's why I'm saying that with ULs nothing can be predicted.

Link to comment
Posted · Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given
Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given

10cm got almost 1M UL during the first day and debuted and n.1 but fell at n.3 the next day.

Soulmate as well got many ULs at first but dropped pretty quickly. That's why I'm saying that with ULs nothing can be predicted.

 

Ofc in the end chart is about longevity unless you have big fandoms like W1,EXO,BTS.

Link to comment
Posted · Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given
Hidden by polygon, September 10, 2018 - No reason given

Ofc in the end chart is about longevity unless you have big fandoms like W1,EXO,BTS.

Shaun only needs 5 more days anyways.

 

 

As for longevity yeah fandoms do push the song especially in the real time chart but it's much more difficult in the daily chart where ULs are counted. It's basically "we need public to stream the song" so that it gains more ULs.

There are a few songs like Spring Day and Energetic released by groups with big fandoms that are higher than some of the recent comebacks of the group.

With Energetic being higher than Light.

And SD being higher than DNA despite being 7 months older.

So yeah fandoms will give a group longevity of 40-50 weeks but not 70-90 weeks.

 

Btw sorry for derailing the thread. I'm putting this in spoilers just in case. Also it's just my opinion and what I've come up with after some researches lol

 

Link to comment

The huge difference is that Love Scenario had very high ULs for a long period of time. Which is why LS's digital score is insurmountable.

 

Simply being #1 isn't enough.

 

Dl0PzbeX0AERqGQ?format=jpg

It's been like 2 months for Shaun and he still has almost 600k ULs. He's doing fine in that aspect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

while ikon competition is almost 0, if shaun didn't win anything at year end award , he should sue someone

  

Shaun did it with so much competition ,it's crazy

You guys really know nothing. His ULs while he’s number 1 are at 520 to 570k... that’s so low, truly the definition of zero competition.

 

iKON dropped out of the #3 position while their UL was at 600k+.. they dropped out of #1 with a UL of 690k...

 

iKON last day at #1 : UL at 650-690k

Shaun last day at #1: UL at 550k

 

That should tell you who had more competition lmao

 

—

 

Anyways it’s pretty obvious the sad Sorry people who want so badly for iKON not to get soty But sucks for you it’s not just about #s but also impact. LS is 8 months old and till this day still spoken about everyone and is now considered one of the biggest songs this decade by the news and GP.

 

Shaun won’t be winning soty, not only does his song seems average impact wise, he has aaejagi accusations surrounding him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You guys really know nothing. His ULs while he’s number 1 are at 520 to 570k... that’s so low, truly the definition of zero competition.

iKON dropped out of the #3 position while their UL was at 600k+.. they dropped out of #1 with a UL of 690k...

iKON last day at #1 : UL at 650-690k

Shaun last day at #1: UL at 550k

That should tell you who had more competition lmao

—

Anyways it’s pretty obvious the sad Sorry people who want so badly for iKON not to get soty But sucks for you it’s not just about #s but also impact. LS is 8 months old and till this day still spoken about everyone and is now considered one of the biggest songs this decade by the news and GP.

Shaun won’t be winning soty, not only does his song seems average impact wise, he has aaejagi accusations surrounding him.

Well so far he has same digital index as LS afaik ,I am not saying that he will win soty or anything but a nugu pulling these numbers is definitely crazy
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You guys really know nothing. His ULs while he’s number 1 are at 520 to 570k... that’s so low, truly the definition of zero competition.

 

iKON dropped out of the #3 position while their UL was at 600k+.. they dropped out of #1 with a UL of 690k...

 

iKON last day at #1 : UL at 650-690k

Shaun last day at #1: UL at 550k

 

That should tell you who had more competition lmao

 

—

 

Anyways it’s pretty obvious the sad Sorry people who want so badly for iKON not to get soty But sucks for you it’s not just about #s but also impact. LS is 8 months old and till this day still spoken about everyone and is now considered one of the biggest songs this decade by the news and GP.

 

Shaun won’t be winning soty, not only does his song seems average impact wise, he has aaejagi accusations surrounding him.

Sis Shaun is above BlackPink who had +800k UL for weeks. And he literally defeated Twice, BlackPink, MAMAMOO, ZICO and more.

 

I don't agree with people who are saying iKON didn't had competition tho. Because they had Big Bang, Winner, MAMAMOO and more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well so far he has same digital index as LS afaik ,I am not saying that he will win soty or anything but a nugu pulling these numbers is definitely crazy

I hate that people are using shaun just to downgrade iKON. Seems to be a recurring theme.

Ofcourse shaun is doing good, no denying that, but wish people actually critically think and not salivate at the potential of him beating iKON when iKON’s ULs at the same position were superior.

 

I can already sense the faux anger when LS wins by these people, crying that Shaun oopa should have won, just to spite us and rain on our happiness. Meh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I hate that people are using shaun just to downgrade iKON. Seems to be a recurring theme.

Ofcourse shaun is doing good, no denying that, but wish people actually critically think and not salivate at the potential of him beating iKON when iKON’s ULs at the same position were superior.

I can already sense the faux anger when LS wins by these people, crying that Shaun oopa should have won, just to spite us and rain on our happiness. Meh

I don't see how my comment downgrades ikon
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see how my comment downgrades ikon

If you had no negative intentions then sorry. I’ve seen people saying that and implying iKON had no competition like wtf

 

Sis Shaun is above BlackPink who had +800k UL for weeks. And he literally defeated Twice, BlackPink, MAMAMOO, ZICO and more.

I don't agree with people who are saying iKON didn't had competition tho. Because they had Big Bang, Winner, MAMAMOO and more.

Yup, obviously he’s doing really well. Top10 at end of year Gaon chart for sure. He had competition, iKON also had competition even if people pretend they didn’t.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top