is it safe to call hyosung the winner of the duble sidekick's triple threat battle?

[dvang]

her song 'goodnight kiss' is doing reasonably well on melon charts and has maintained a stronghold at #16 for almost two weeks now despite heavy competition,personally i think both jiyeon and hyosung released really good mini-albums(let's not just talk about g.na here) but jiyeon's 1min1sec obviously did not do well because of how derivative it sounds whereas hysong's goodnight kiss has more edge to it and more upbeat plus the mv is a treat for secret's fanboys :D :D

[dinolover]

I almost wished Jiyeon had Goodnight kiss instead, I really liked that song.

[Chaegzbb]

For me it's Hyosung's song>Jiyeon's song>>>>>>>>>>>>G.Na's song

[Ethnic Pop]

Jiyeon > Hyosung > G.Na

[SchoolNote]

Hyosung's song is the most catchy I barely can remember the other two.

[Get The Job Done]

Hyosung powns the other chicks

[cyclops]

[Gabriel Celeste]

never ever >>>>

[Meth Krystal]

jiyeon's chorus > hyosung's trap drop > the rest 

[footballfina]

~kiss on my, kiss on my, kiss on my, LIPS~ that song is catchy as SHIT, the other two are forgettable tbh

[huong_2503]

I like G.NA the best maybe cuz she has strongest vocal among those 3 ( & her song is really really catchy T^T ) but seem like it's true that Hyosung's result turn out to be the best

( & in my opinion all 3 flop anyway @@ )

[lovesgoku]

I love Hyosung's song. It's catchy, fun, and she sells that shit so well on stage. She's doing well digitally and physically as you said. Here's hoping she finds more success 

[s4a]

Jiyeon's song didn't do well because Jiyeon is in T-ara

G.NA's songs haven't been doing well in a while

Hyosung is part of SECRET who is one of the more successful digital groups + her song slays so ofc she wins.

[blazeaire]

Proof that sex sells tbh, no matter what netz might say LOL

[EunB's Angel]

I love Hyosung's Goodnight Kiss, been replaying the hell out of it since it was released and its constantly in my head, well her whole mini album is. To me the song was the whole package, the beat, the appeal and who catchy it was.

 

To be honest I don't like Jiyeon's song at all (sorry Jiyeon fans), the song was forgettable. <And this is coming from a QUEEN.

 

As for G.NA's song, I actually like that one a lot. Except for the music video the dude watching her try on things was creepy and awkward as hell.

 

So in my opinion: Hyosung>>>G.NA>>>Jiyeon

[acclaim]

HYOSUNG >> JIYEON >>>>>> RAT.NA

[kangbaekh]

Hyosung > G.NA >>>>>>>> Jiyeon.

[Mako Yagami]

For me it's Hyosung's song>Jiyeon's song>>>>>>>>>>>>G.Na's song

[lepidoptery]

Yes, but it's kind of inevitable... Jiyeon was doomed in the absence of some miracle, G.Na's not that big a deal, I guess.  Secret at least had one great year in 2011, even if Hyosung kind of bombed it in 2013, but I still would have picked her to succeed out of the three in spite of my reservations considering Jieun's solo last year.

 

Need to go listen to Jiyeon's album~

[kyuripls]

It's too early. Although jiyeon could easily fall off the chart she could rise (like a phoenix). When sunmi released full moon it dropped off the charts and slowly rose to top 3 so who knows hopefully they all do well

[Onehallyu#1NiceOppaKW]

iChart tell you everything.

[MoshiMoshi]

Hyosung's song is the catchiest. I liked Jiyeon's too but it's not as repeatable for me. Didn't hear the other one.

 

Hyosung's mini on the whole was better than Jiyeon's so Hyosung definitely wins imo