Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Love Knot Tops No.1 as Web Drama (Starring Johnny Huang JingYu and Victoria Song Qian)


Recommended Posts

song qian @#1 :ahmagah:

Is drama good? I want to start but I'm afraid it won't reach any expectations I'd have.

it is very enjoyable to watch. side characters are also entertaining too. I binged watched to episode 7.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vic has been N.1 for days too...

I don't remember the last time both lead actors of a web drama topping Vlingage chart.

The WOM and response for Moonshine and Valentine is really good. 


song qian @#1 ahmagahplz.png
Is drama good? I want to start but I'm afraid it won't reach any expectations I'd have.

 

Have you tried it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just started watching it. It's off to a good start plus just having 25 episodes makes the story more compact. 

 

They actually cut a lot from the novel...

Initially the director only wanted 13-15 episodes because he is a movie director.

But because of the investors we have 24 plus one extra of for fun

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They actually cut a lot from the novel...

Initially the director only wanted 13-15 episodes because he is a movie director.

But because of the investors we have 24 plus one extra of for fun

I wonder if that's why the show is so good. better cinematography and more succinct scenes

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if that's why the show is so good. better cinematography and more succinct scenes

They changed a lot actually.

The real story has much darker and sexier vibe. Helan was more cold/hot/arrogant. He became gentle, innocent, understanding and clumsy guy in the drama.  Pipi basically had to deal with more troubles and it was all by herself, unlike in the drama where she has her Xiao Ju sharing and asking for opinions. Xiao Ju didn't meet foxes until  book 2. Pipi is also a lot more headstrong and resists Helan longer too.

 

The drama is much brighter. A lot comedy is added, which imo, helps a lot. A lot supporting characters are changed. 2 Helan's minions are lovers in the novel and they don't always follow Helan like that...  They made Helan more swoon worthy and Pipi is easier to deal with in the drama... 

 

 

So it's not only cutting short the story. I would say they only loosely base on the novel at this point for the romance, everything else is different, including Pipi and Helan's personalities.

Hence I believe the ending will be different too. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I get the feeling that there will be part 2 because the drama is a success and the novel is still ongoing with 3 books out so far.....

 

They changed a lot actually.

The real story has much darker and sexier vibe. Helan was more cold/hot/arrogant. He became gentle, innocent and clumsy guy in the drama.  Pipi basically had to deal with more troubles and it was all by herself, unlike in the drama where she has her Xiao Ju. Xiao Ju didn't meet Helan and the fox until  book 2. She also a lot more headstrong and resist Helan longer too.

The drama is much brighter. A lot comedy is added, which imo, helps a lot. A lot supporting characters are changed. They made Helan more swoon worthy and Pipi is easier to deal with... 

 

It's not only cutting short the story. They only loosely base on the novel at this point for the romance. 

Hence I believe the ending will be different too. 

 

lol yes, Helan is super arrogant and cold in the novel. Pipi is different too--she's a lot more snarky and pushy in the novel. 

 

 

the breakup scene for example, she almost beat the shit out of Jia Lin.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I get the feeling that there will be part 2 because the drama is a success and the novel is still ongoing with 3 books out so far.....

 

 

lol yes, Helan is super arrogant and cold in the novel. Pipi is different too--she's a lot more snarky and pushy in the novel. 

 

 

the breakup scene for example, she almost beat the shit out of Jia Lin.

 

 

I don't know because so far there is no talk for season 2.

 

Plus there is a beef between Vic and Johnny fandoms... 

 

Not to mention season 2  would be a total different setup than season 1, which is much wild and crazy in comparison LOL. Drama fans would be shocked. I don't think Leste Chen is interested in that unless the investment is big enough to temp him.

Because no doubt Moonshine and Valentine is unexpected hitting big. Both Vic and Johnny surpassed all the TV drama leads and leading Vlinkage list. The drama also has highest rating in douban among all the current airing dramas. 

 

And yeah, that's why I said they made Pipi is much easier to deal with and making her falling in love with Helan much easier too... And all the sudden Helan is so cute in the drama LOL. I guess that's why people loving it because they can't stop swooning over him.

 

I feel a bit offended for Pipi ... when reading people saying she is a doormat and has no personality on twitter. I'm like you have no idea... especially in season 2 and 3.... 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vic has been N.1 for days too...

I don't remember the last time both lead actors of a web drama topping Vlingage chart.

The WOM and response for Moonshine and Valentine is really good.

 

 

Have you tried it?

Just did

I'm not really interested with romance drama etc but I'm willing to watch the next episodes, and not only bc its Song Qian's.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just did

I'm not really interested with romance drama etc but I'm willing to watch the next episodes, and not only bc its Song Qian's.

 

They made all supporting characters fun, interesting and have their own stories... so even if you aren't even interested in the romance, the drama can still keep you entertained. I laughed so hard in ep 14. Vic sacrificed a lot for this role

 

Seeing how there are a lot positive comments abt the drama, I guess i'll give it a try ahmagahplz.png

 

i was planning tp skip this drama at the beginning actually

 

You are not alone. A lot people planned to skip it but ended up loving it. 

It's a dark horse and unexpected hit by word of mouth because they didn't have any promotion, not only with popularity but is also highest rating among current drama on Douban.

DeQ8KADVwAIyGq7.jpg

If you aren't familiar to Douban, even Sun Li's critical acclaimed Nothing Gold Can Stay is only 7.2 but of course TV drama rating might be a bit stricter.

 

 

I have read so many article analyzing why it's a success and even calling it the best romance drama is first half of 2018

 

I just started watching it and I can see why people are getting into this drama. Victoria scored another good one with this

 

It's more like finally she worked in a drama with a good director.

Her role isn't great but how her acting improved a lot here, especially she has more room to showcase her acting... 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You are not alone. A lot people planned to skip it but ended up loving it.

It's a dark horse and unexpected hit by word of mouth because they didn't have any promotion, not only with popularity but is also highest rating among current drama on Douban.

DeQ8KADVwAIyGq7.jpg

If you aren't familiar to Douban, even Sun Li's critical acclaimed Nothing Gold Can Stay is only 7.2 but of course TV drama rating might be a bit stricter.

 

 

I have read so many article analyzing why it's a success and even calling it the best romance drama is first half of 2018

 

 

Yeah, i had heard of Douban before but not that familiarize with it :lol: Beside, i dont care much abt the rating as long as the drama got what it's should have, the plot, the acting and the casts.

 

Now, i really curious abt this drama but I'll probably start watching the drama once it ended (and completely subbed) as I don't like waiting for the next ep, the wait is a torture :lol: :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow congrats!

 

I just binge watched all of the episodes lol and I'm loving it so far! It's such a nice, light watch. Had no idea that they changed so much of the original story from the novels, but I'm glad they did. Tired of those super arrogant, cold male leads tbh. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They changed a lot actually.

The real story has much darker and sexier vibe. Helan was more cold/hot/arrogant. He became gentle, innocent, understanding and clumsy guy in the drama.  Pipi basically had to deal with more troubles and it was all by herself, unlike in the drama where she has her Xiao Ju sharing and asking for opinions. Xiao Ju didn't meet foxes until  book 2. Pipi is also a lot more headstrong and resists Helan longer too.

 

The drama is much brighter. A lot comedy is added, which imo, helps a lot. A lot supporting characters are changed. 2 Helan's minions are lovers in the novel and they don't always follow Helan like that...  They made Helan more swoon worthy and Pipi is easier to deal with in the drama... 

 

 

So it's not only cutting short the story. I would say they only loosely base on the novel at this point for the romance, everything else is different, including Pipi and Helan's personalities.

Hence I believe the ending will be different too. 

 

Really that sound interesting maybe I will start to read the books too, is it a happy ending novel?

too bad that they changed pip's character, I like helan as he is, pipi need more girlpower. other than that I think the director did a good job with the changing so far  

wait a minute.... the 2 comic duo are lovers??? no wonder they act with a hint of BL in the drama  

 

I get the feeling that there will be part 2 because the drama is a success and the novel is still ongoing with 3 books out so far.....

 

 

lol yes, Helan is super arrogant and cold in the novel. Pipi is different too--she's a lot more snarky and pushy in the novel. 

 

 

the breakup scene for example, she almost beat the shit out of Jia Lin.

 

 

really want to see that, that breakup scene was not enough for me, I was not satisfied

but again it was a smart move to make him suffer like that

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't know because so far there is no talk for season 2.

 

Plus there is a beef between Vic and Johnny fandoms... 

 

Not to mention season 2  would be a total different setup than season 1, which is much wild and crazy in comparison LOL. Drama fans would be shocked. I don't think Leste Chen is interested in that unless the investment is big enough to temp him.

Because no doubt Moonshine and Valentine is unexpected hitting big. Both Vic and Johnny surpassed all the TV drama leads and leading Vlinkage list. The drama also has highest rating in douban among all the current airing dramas. 

 

And yeah, that's why I said they made Pipi is much easier to deal with and making her falling in love with Helan much easier too... And all the sudden Helan is so cute in the drama LOL. I guess that's why people loving it because they can't stop swooning over him.

 

I feel a bit offended for Pipi ... when reading people saying she is a doormat and has no personality on twitter. I'm like you have no idea... especially in season 2 and 3.... 

 

Honestly I don't want season 2. I think 25 episodes is good enough for this story but every hit drama seems to get a sequel so I'm wary.

 

There are a lot of changes from the novel, especially the main characters, but the essence of the story is still the same so I hope they'll keep the ending because that's Pipi's shining moment. 

 

 

The way she took down ZS and saved HL was amazing!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly I don't want season 2. I think 25 episodes is good enough for this story but every hit drama seems to get a sequel so I'm wary.

 

There are a lot of changes from the novel, especially the main characters, but the essence of the story is still the same so I hope they'll keep the ending because that's Pipi's shining moment. 

 

 

The way she took down ZS and saved HL was amazing!

 

 

What ep are you on?

Having watching up to ep 16 and seeing the previews up to ep 20... I feel like they will change that ending and make Pipi the doormat until the end, which I'm going to be so bitter.

They created a love line for Zhao Song and make him better person.... pairing him with Qian Hua will definitely change the ending in book 1 

 

Because we know in reality, 

 she is the one that save Helan and break her own curse. She isn't a weak doormat waiting for people to save her like most dramas fans think  

 

 

There are total of 24 ep and 1 spinoff episode which I'm curious about.

Really that sound interesting maybe I will start to read the books too, is it a happy ending novel?

too bad that they changed pip's character, I like helan as he is, pipi need more girlpower. other than that I think the director did a good job with the changing so far  

wait a minute.... the 2 comic duo are lovers??? no wonder they act with a hint of BL in the drama  

 

 

really want to see that, that breakup scene was not enough for me, I was not satisfied

but again it was a smart move to make him suffer like that

 

Both Book 1 and 2 are open ending for the next parts.

If they keep Pipi the same Helan won't be as swoonie as he is right now in the drama.. LOL. They sacrificed her character to make the hero look good. I'm going so bitter if they are going to change the ending... in the book. Because it's a big character development for Pipi after realizing she loves him. 

 

In the book Pipi's ex suffered more than that actually.

 

Wow congrats!

 

I just binge watched all of the episodes lol and I'm loving it so far! It's such a nice, light watch. Had no idea that they changed so much of the original story from the novels, but I'm glad they did. Tired of those super arrogant, cold male leads tbh. 

 

That's why they changed. Hot arrogant male lead is not longer the trend.

The novel was written in 2010 when it was a trend...

 

Yeah, i had heard of Douban before but not that familiarize with it laugh.png Beside, i dont care much abt the rating as long as the drama got what it's should have, the plot, the acting and the casts.

 

Now, i really curious abt this drama but I'll probably start watching the drama once it ended (and completely subbed) as I don't like waiting for the next ep, the wait is a torture laugh.pnglaugh.png

Douban is like IMBD with a lot of discussion, reviews and comments.

It's used to measure how good a drama, movie, book in China and it's quite... accurate except that domestics products are judged much harder than oversea's for many reasons.

For example TMOPB was only 6.2 and Princess Agent was 4.9, King's woman is 4.4 But Korean dramas like My mister is 9.4 and Secret Forest is 9.2 la.gif la.gif la.gif

It's important for productions in China though because they use it as a measurement of what quality the drama/movie/book etc has 

 

Yeah I hate waiting too lol

And the drama is short so it will be completed in 2 weeks. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What ep are you on?

Having watching up to ep 16 and seeing the previews up to ep 20... I feel like they will change that ending and make Pipi the doormat until the end, which I'm going to be so bitter.

They created a love line for Zhao Song and make him better person.... pairing him with Qian Hua will definitely change the ending in book 1 

 

Because we know in reality, 

 she is the one that save Helan and break her own curse. She isn't a weak doormat waiting for people to save her like most dramas fans think  

 

 

 

I was on weibo and saw a video spoiler where he raped QH so I'm fairly confident he is still the villain

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I was on weibo and saw a video spoiler where he raped QH so I'm fairly confident he is still the villain

 

 

 

I saw that too but there was not love line between them in the book or did I forget?

His orb shined on her neck once in the drama too... which lead me to believe somehow they would be together at the end... 

But I pray with you that they keep the ending in the book. Because it's a big development for Pipi in book 1

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What ep are you on?

Having watching up to ep 16 and seeing the previews up to ep 20... I feel like they will change that ending and make Pipi the doormat until the end, which I'm going to be so bitter.

They created a love line for Zhao Song and make him better person.... pairing him with Qian Hua will definitely change the ending in book 1

 

Because we know in reality,

she is the one that save Helan and break her own curse. She isn't a weak doormat waiting for people to save her like most dramas fans think

 

 

There are total of 24 ep and 1 spinoff episode which I'm curious about.

 

Both Book 1 and 2 are open ending for the next parts.

If they keep Pipi the same Helan won't be as swoonie as he is right now in the drama.. LOL. They sacrificed her character to make the hero look good. I'm going so bitter if they are going to change the ending... in the book. Because it's a big character development for Pipi after realizing she loves him.

 

In the book Pipi's ex suffered more than that actually.

 

 

That's why they changed. Hot arrogant male lead is not longer the trend.

The novel was written in 2010 when it was a trend...

 

Douban is like IMBD with a lot of discussion, reviews and comments.

It's used to measure how good a drama, movie, book in China and it's quite... accurate except that domestics products are judged much harder than oversea's for many reasons.

For example TMOPB was only 6.2 and Princess Agent was 4.9, King's woman is 4.4 But Korean dramas like My mister is 9.4 and Secret Forest is 9.2 la.gifla.gifla.gif

It's important for productions in China though because they use it as a measurement of what quality the drama/movie/book etc has

 

Yeah I hate waiting too lol

And the drama is short so it will be completed in 2 weeks.

Ahh i see, thanks for the explanation.... I guess I can wait a little bit more before I started watching the drama lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I saw that too but there was not love line between them in the book or did I forget?

His orb shined on her neck once in the drama too... which lead me to believe somehow they would be together at the end... 

But I pray with you that they keep the ending in the book. Because it's a big development for Pipi in book 1

 

 

 

No, I'm pretty sure he didn't have a love line, much less with her.

 

If she ends up with her rapist, then I'm gonna flip a table. I'm gonna flip alll the tables. Seriously, I hope they will not do that to her, she deserves so much better.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

No, I'm pretty sure he didn't have a love line, much less with her.

 

If she ends up with her rapist, then I'm gonna flip a table. I'm gonna flip alll the tables. Seriously, I hope they will not do that to her, she deserves so much better.

 

 

 

This is Chinese dramas.They really romanticize rape/rapers... , even in many novels I read... 

And there is rumor we will have happy ending for the main couple - Look at their wedding!

But in the novel, QH will take Helan away... I feel like they will give her "her own happy ending" in the drama... Even in the drama last week, she said she understand him the most because she was in the same position with Helan in previous episode....

I don't know but I feel they will go there.

 

 

Ahh i see, thanks for the explanation.... I guess I can wait a little bit more before I started watching the drama lol

No problem. Enjoy!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top