[poll] which one looks better?

[Auri]

I'm an architect student, in my third semester. We have to make a parklet for our landscape (not sure that's how you call it in english) class. If you don't know, a parklet "is a sidewalk extension that provides more space and amenities for people using the street" (wikipedia).

 

Here's a picture of one for reference.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I've made a few layouts and it's been very frustrating because the space is so small and it's my first landscape project. I've shown them to my group partners and it was decided that we would do this one (ignore the ugly green lady and the extremely poor render quality):

 

1.

 

Now, even though I made it, I wasn't satisfied with it. It looks way to generic to me. And I hate that table. It wasn't my idea to add it and I don't think there's enough space for it.

 

So after trying to remodel this layout many times, I decided to start all over and came up with this:

 

2.

 

Which I like waaaaaaaay better. I'm actually kinda proud of myself.

 

Anyways, some of our teachers will judge our projects and the best one might be executed. I haven't shown the second layout to my group partners yet, because I wasn't supposed to making a new one, I was supposed to be working on the chosen one so they can finish the project. But, as I said, I wasn't satisfied. And before I show it them, I want to know which one you guys like the best. Please vote <3 

[binsbins]

i personally think the second one is the prettiest, but i'd recommend going for the second one either way!

if it's the one you like better and the one you're most confident about, it definitely should be the one you submit

in any case, best of luck! i'll be rooting for you

[Grape Soda]

2nd

[Auri]

i personally think the second one is the prettiest, but i'd recommend going for the second one either way!

if it's the one you like better and the one you're most confident about, it definitely should be the one you submit

in any case, best of luck! i'll be rooting for you

Awwww, that's so nice of you!!  Thank you so much, I really appreciate this! 

[T A I G A]

I really like the second one

[Auri]

2nd

Thanks!

 

I really like the second one

Awwwn, thank youuuuu <3 

[i'm not your anti]

I personally find the second one the prettiest.

[OnCloud9]

Hmm I actually like the first one better. The second one seems to have a bit too much going on for my taste. Do agree with that random table in the first one though. You could do without it.

[byeol]

tbh I like the first one better, it's simple and more pleasing to look at imo

[paopufruit]

i love the second one!!

[boomimo]

The 2nd pic is like you divide in two one place without taking to much space, i like it.

The 1st pic is nice and simple the only thing it's bothers me is that table in the right corner.

[Auri]

I personally find the second one the prettiest.

Thank you!! 

 

Hmm I actually like the first one better. The second one seems to have a bit too much going on for my taste. Do agree with that random table in the first one though. You could do without it.

Right? I definitely like the first one more without the table. Thanks for your input! 

 

tbh I like the first one better, it's simple and more pleasing to look at imo

Yeah, my mom said the same. That's what made me doubtful. Thank you for replying!  

 

i love the second one!!

Thank you so much! <33 

[gudetama]

Personally I like the first one better. It's nice and simple whereas there's a lot going on in the second one. I didn't notice the table though, that should definitely be removed. 

[iJungwha]

Second one looks good.