Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Vocal Battle/Showcase : Solji vs Taeyeon vs Uji vs Solar


Avatarkyungsoo

  

56 members have voted

  1. 1. Who was your favorite?

    • Solji
      16
    • Taeyeon
      31
    • Uji
      4
    • Solar
      5


Recommended Posts

It's a bit long but I wanted to showcase the 4 of them as much as I could

 

A vocal showdown between 4 amazing and talented ladies, EXID's Solji, SNSD's Taeyeon, BESTie's Uji (formerly) and MAMAMOO's Solar. They will blow you away in this video showcasing their vocals. Nothing but love for their 4 women that work hard to show their best selves.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Solji besides being a singer she is a vocal teacher. It is awesome. Is btw her and Tae

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lolol at anyone thinking Taeyeon is below Solji or Solar. I dont know Uji so I can't speak for her, but Taeyeon is a wall compared to Solar or Solji.

 

Love both solar and solji, but seriously guys. Be more objective.

 

Also just because Solji was a vocal teacher doesn't mean she's the best vocalist

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lolol at anyone thinking Taeyeon is below Solji or Solar. I dont know Uji so I can't speak for her, but Taeyeon is a wall compared to Solar or Solji.

 

Love both solar and solji, but seriously guys. Be more objective.

 

Also just because Solji was a vocal teacher doesn't mean she's the best vocalist

 

What? You can't tell people to be more objective and then provide no objective reasoning for your own choice other than "she's a wall."

 

I'm sure people would be more than happy to listen to any explanation you have other than a dismissal of their opinions.

 

EDIT: Just saw people downvoting others for having an opinion. Classic OH 0u0plz.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What? You can't tell people to be more objective and then provide no objective reasoning for your own choice other than "she's a wall."

 

I'm sure people would be more than happy to listen to any explanation you have other than a dismissal of their opinions.

 

EDIT: Just saw people downvoting others for having an opinion. Classic OH :derp:

Well I meant vocally, she's a wall compared to those two. I didn't think that was really my opinion but rather more a fact? I don't think my comment was so different from yours about uji. Maybe it came off ruder? My bad

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well I meant vocally, she's a wall compared to those two. I didn't think that was really my opinion but rather more a fact? I don't think my comment was so different from yours about uji. Maybe it came off ruder? My bad

 

I'm not saying it was rude. I was just waiting for the presentation of those facts more than anything. I know the kpop vocal blog has done away with its ranking, but I remember Uji being the highest ranked vocalist of any name listed here, with plenty of objective reasoning to support her placement.

 

It's just my nature to want to see the reasons behind someone's opinion when it's presented so strongly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not saying it was rude. I was just waiting for the presentation of those facts more than anything. I know the kpop vocal blog has done away with its ranking, but I remember Uji being the highest ranked vocalist of any name listed here, with plenty of objective reasoning to support her placement.

 

It's just my nature to want to see the reasons behind someone's opinion when it's presented so strongly.

Fair. I didn't think I was coming off that strongly. I understand if I was all "those other two suck and taeyeon rules", but if anything I like Solar best and am a proud radish, and I never fell for Taeyeon the same way after 9/30.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not saying it was rude. I was just waiting for the presentation of those facts more than anything. I know the kpop vocal blog has done away with its ranking, but I remember Uji being the highest ranked vocalist of any name listed here, with plenty of objective reasoning to support her placement.

 

It's just my nature to want to see the reasons behind someone's opinion when it's presented so strongly.

On an unrelated note:

 

 

wasn't Luna really high on that list? I remember learning her true talent from that site

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On an unrelated note:

 

 

wasn't Luna really high on that list? I remember learning her true talent from that site

 

 

YamaChan is right, about the kpop vocal blog. When they were still using rankings, Uji was technically the best of these 4, closely followed by Taeyeon and then a small gap to Solar and Solji (who were about even ranked).

 

Luna ranked higher than Uji. Ailee was the highest ranked on their female kpop vocalists.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On an unrelated note:

 

 

wasn't Luna really high on that list? I remember learning her true talent from that site

 

 

Whelp, somebody already answered it, but Luna was ranked higher than the four vocalists compared in this thread.

 

I love all the vocalists mentioned in this thread though. They each have their unique styles and can capture the emotion of a song with their own personal touch. 

 

Luna is another vastly underrated vocalist though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Whelp, somebody already answered it, but Luna was ranked higher than the four vocalists compared in this thread.

 

I love all the vocalists mentioned in this thread though. They each have their unique styles and can capture the emotion of a song with their own personal touch. 

 

Luna is another vastly underrated vocalist though.

 

 

With the exception of Uji (because I don't know her), I do also appreciate all of them.  The only thing I hate is when people equate belting = AMAZING/AWESOME/ERMYGODLOOK vocalist.  (Btw, not saying you, just in general).   Solar is the powerhouse of MAMAMOO for example, but Wheein is looked over because she doesn't belt in their songs, but is just as good as Solar (or even better, according to that list).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the exception of Uji (because I don't know her), I do also appreciate all of them.  The only thing I hate is when people equate belting = AMAZING/AWESOME/ERMYGODLOOK vocalist.  (Btw, not saying you, just in general).   Solar is the powerhouse of MAMAMOO for example, but Wheein is looked over because she doesn't belt in their songs, but is just as good as Solar (or even better, according to that list).

 

 

I also think it doesn't matter that much ultimately. So Hyang is an absolute wall when it comes to vocal competence. Yet, I find myself not enjoying her belts that much. There's something about her tone that I don't like when she starts belting. Even though from a vocal skill point of view it's super impressive (and second to none), I find it occasionally very grating to listen to.

 

Solar's belts sometimes have that effect on me. For example, in Paint Me, I find her belts floating over a thin line between belting nicely and sounding like she's screaming at me aggressively. In Solar's case, I think it's because she's straining it at those belts, making it sound more "raw" (and to me unpleasant). So Hyang's case it's not because she sounds like she's straining, but maybe I just don't like the tones when they belt them that high, as impressive as it is.

 

I don't have this problem with Uji though. So even if it wasn't for that ranking, she's the #1 for me both objectively and subjectively as a vocalist of these 4.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m not connoisseur when it comes to vocal abilities so I’ll just stick to my personal preference and say I prefer Solji’s voice overall, her tone is beautiful ,soothing and I can’t detect anything annoying in the way she sings , no screeching, no nasality , it just flows smoothly. She also delivers a special feel when she hits those high notes, she sounds powerful and bright.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using OneHallyu

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top