Which male idols do you think are gay?

[RMPA]

 

What u guys think about Hendery? He seems so whipped up for Ten sometimes, maybe it's his personality when he is with someone that he admires?

[MJr]

5 hours ago, Gerimolda said:

 

uhm... I think that RW is gay but he also sounds like an asexual/aromantic person... Or maybe he doesn't like relationships and he prefers casual hook-ups

Yeah that's not something you usually hear from straight men.

Maybe ace, although he could just be gay... the whole "oh I just don't want to date" can be rooted in anxiety over your own sexuality, internalised homophobia, and all that stuff.

[Unfair_]

2 hours ago, RMPA said:

 

What u guys think about Hendery? He seems so whipped up for Ten sometimes, maybe it's his personality when he is with someone that he admires?

idk but he was serving here.

 

[irlpadam]

 

 

[taeweishin]

any thought about THE BOYZ?

[Tixy]

On the topic of Ryeowook, he always seemed obviously gay to me. The whole "haha I just love being single, y'all should try it too" shtick is in my opinion just an answer for the straights so they'll leave him alone. Noah fence to anyone, but labeling Ryeowook as potentially asexual makes me quite uncomfortable, since there's a long history of desexualization of gay people by straight people. They cannot agree with the fact that a person is gay, so it's preferable to them that the person is at least asexual if they cannot actually be straight.

[Thatoneuser]

1 hour ago, Tixy said:

On the topic of Ryeowook, he always seemed obviously gay to me. The whole "haha I just love being single, y'all should try it too" shtick is in my opinion just an answer for the straights so they'll leave him alone. Noah fence to anyone, but labeling Ryeowook as potentially asexual makes me quite uncomfortable, since there's a long history of desexualization of gay people by straight people. They cannot agree with the fact that a person is gay, so it's preferable to them that the person is at least asexual if they cannot actually be straight.

I agree completely with all of this. He never appeared asexual to me because when he sings love ballads he can connect with the meaning deeply and that suggests he's felt romantic feelings for someone and etc.

Edited October 25, 2019 by Thatoneuser
Spelling

[winnercircle]

Quote

 

Taemin

[Gerimolda]

1 hour ago, Tixy said:

On the topic of Ryeowook, he always seemed obviously gay to me. The whole "haha I just love being single, y'all should try it too" shtick is in my opinion just an answer for the straights so they'll leave him alone. Noah fence to anyone, but labeling Ryeowook as potentially asexual makes me quite uncomfortable, since there's a long history of desexualization of gay people by straight people. They cannot agree with the fact that a person is gay, so it's preferable to them that the person is at least asexual if they cannot actually be straight.

Yeah I know that and I hate it too that's why I was hesitant to suggest it in my post. 

[shineestan]

15 hours ago, taeweishin said:

any thought about THE BOYZ?

Sangyeon: straight 

Jacob: gay

Younghoon: gay

Hyunjae: straight 

Juyeon: straight or bi

Kevin: gay

New: gay

Q: gay or bi

Haknyeon: bi

Hwall (cryyy) : bi

sunwoo: straight 

Eric: gay 

Edited October 25, 2019 by shineestan

[Josaline]

 

 

 

[Binney]

any thought about CIX, AB6IX?

[taeyong's panicked scream]

i'm sorry guys i know taeyong is not being welcomed on this thread these days but hmm

 

[Sookai]

54 minutes ago, Irinaa said:

any thought about CIX, AB6IX?

Well for AB6IX the answer is kinda obvious isn't it 

[jjongjjong]

Posting because of Ten

https://twitter.com/taetenstuff/status/1187751473834266625 

NSFW he's highkey moaning/grunting in this clip

[xicondi]

5 hours ago, Irinaa said:

any thought about CIX, AB6IX?

AB6IX: Daehwi's the most obvious and Woong is suspicious. I can write an essay about those two but I think they've already been covered in this thread.

CIX: They don't have much content and they're all still getting to know each other so there's some natural awkwardness between the members. Jinyoung has had plenty of suspicious moments with AB6IX Daehwi and Park Jihoon. There's also a video going lowkey viral right now on twitter of him falling in love with Jimin.

There's also Seunghun who has a weird obsession with Jinyoung's butt. A once in a while ass slap is one thing, but every morning? But honestly it could mean nothing.

BX seems very affectionate to people he's close to like AB6IX Woong, Treasure13 Hyunsuk, and D1CE Woo Jinyoung, but nothing that comes off as suspicious. There's not a lot of content on the group so I really don't know. 

[irlpadam]

4 hours ago, jjongjjong said:

Posting because of Ten

https://twitter.com/taetenstuff/status/1187751473834266625 

NSFW he's highkey moaning/grunting in this clip

the way i screamed

[seashells]

Also, in SuperM the Beginning Capitol Records talks about how they reached out to SM to make this new group. They even say that they researched a lot of companies and decided they had to go with SM. The part I found most interesting was they talked about their artist and they chose to name 6 of them--Katy Perry, The Beatles being two but the they proceeded to talk about Troy Sivan, Sam Smith and Halsey. I do wonder if this is some how related to Ten saying he never felt more free. Capitol Records wanted this group and LSM put these specific members in it. Food for thought.

Edited October 26, 2019 by seashells

[seashells]

Here's the link if anyone is interested. Capitol Records starts talking around the 7 minute mark. 

[ribbonribbon]

One thing I observed -some idols' receipts changes significantly before/around/after military enlisting/discharged.

Tony Ahn - appears to be a womanizer both before military. Settle down a domestic life with Jaeduk after. But the whole dating news is Hyeri is confusing - if they are doing media play to divert attention -why choose someone with such large age gap?

Junsu: he s off the radar a bit after discharged. But dating Hani for a few months then break up right before enlisting . Before that, I always think he is gay/bi.

Donghae has abundant gay moments before military (even if you dont count the eunhae ones). Went full no-homo right before enlisting. He is still a bit no-homo now. 

Eunhyuk - thought of him as straight/bi before. After military, influx receipts of gay/bi. I dont agree with the speculation about his close friend being the lover though. They just seem to be two close friends joking around - plus he has intimate pics with ALL his male friends in that same circle.

I am actually curious how things change for some EXO members who are about to enlist in the next 2 years Baekhyun - Suho- Sehun ... Couldnt find anything on Kyungsoo prior to his enlistment though.

 

[Gerimolda]

2 hours ago, ribbonribbon said:

why choose someone with such large age gap?

I wonder that too.

 

2 hours ago, ribbonribbon said:

Before that, I always think he is gay/bi.

He sill could be bi and date Hani. I think he is bi, same with Hani.

 

2 hours ago, ribbonribbon said:

Donghae has abundant gay moments before military (even if you dont count the eunhae ones)

I'm curious because I think that DH is straight. Can you show me some of them? For me his relationship with Sehun is not suspicious btw

 

2 hours ago, ribbonribbon said:

They just seem to be two close friends joking around

The things they have said seem really cheesy and heartfelt...

 

2 hours ago, ribbonribbon said:

plus he has intimate pics with ALL his male friends in that same circle.

I'm curious about that too. Do you have any examples?

[ribbonribbon]

2 hours ago, Gerimolda said:

He sill could be bi and date Hani. I think he is bi, same with Hani

probably. In an extreme biased view, I always feel weird whenever a relationship pop out of suspicious cases. This one involves BOTH parties being in the rumour of gay/lesbian/bi. It does feel like a cover up tbh - I also think Hani is into girls.

For Tony Ahn and Hyeri, it feels legit. It doesnt make sense to use that relationship to media play or cover up - they both received a lot of backlash back then.  This one is forever a myth because I think anyone who follows Tony would just agree that he and Jaeduk are practically partner.

2 hours ago, Gerimolda said:

 

I'm curious because I think that DH is straight. Can you show me some of them? For me his relationship with Sehun is not suspicious btw

I think topless pic lying together is pretty suspicious tbh. But DH has always give me the KJK vibe (who I think is totally gay).  Always act uninterested towards women and claim it was because of shyness. At the same time, being extremely touchy and clingy to man. Plus his whole infatuation with EH in the very beginning is weird. (there are many complication earlier).

Still, I dont think DH is involved with EH/Sehun/e.t.c - I just think there were attraction/tensions. For some reasons, I do group him and SW under the same category - Church guy who are in the closet and has been in denial at least at one point.

 

2 hours ago, Gerimolda said:

I'm curious about that too. Do you have any examples?

Naejongsuk is one example. He did have a lot of cheesy things with shinjihoo amd other friends (whose acc has made private) as well. And west2side had plenty of those cheesy captions with both boys and girls on his IG so I wont read too much into it.

My point is - if EH did indeed date any of the non celeb guy friend, bet nothing would ever make public. Korea is still a scary place for actual homo relationship (and strangely a welcoming space for same sex shipping). This is why I usually refrain from assuming a relationship based on public receipts, especially for long term friendships.

_-----_--------------------_

On an unrelated note on SuperM - except for Mark, when I first see each of them I thought they are all bi. This one is purely biased view,without any receipts. Just thought it is an interesting group composition.

Edited October 26, 2019 by ribbonribbon

[Melany]

8 hours ago, xicondi said:

AB6IX: Daehwi's the most obvious and Woong is suspicious. I can write an essay about those two but I think they've already been covered in this thread.

CIX: They don't have much content and they're all still getting to know each other so there's some natural awkwardness between the members. Jinyoung has had plenty of suspicious moments with AB6IX Daehwi and Park Jihoon. There's also a video going lowkey viral right now on twitter of him falling in love with Jimin.

There's also Seunghun who has a weird obsession with Jinyoung's butt. A once in a while ass slap is one thing, but every morning? But honestly it could mean nothing.

BX seems very affectionate to people he's close to like AB6IX Woong, Treasure13 Hyunsuk, and D1CE Woo Jinyoung, but nothing that comes off as suspicious. There's not a lot of content on the group so I really don't know. 

oh hi! I remember you making interesting post about park jihoon, do you still think he is not straight? I would love to know your opinion on wanna one. 

Im a bit confused about jinyoung, i could see him being bi though

[Gerimolda]

59 minutes ago, ribbonribbon said:

This one involves BOTH parties being in the rumour of gay/lesbian/bi. It does feel like a cover up tbh - I also think Hani is into girls.

I think it was genuine . I think they're both bi and liked each other.

 

1 hour ago, ribbonribbon said:

My point is - if EH did indeed date any of the non celeb guy friend, bet nothing would ever make public. Korea is still a scary place for actual homo relationship (and strangely a welcoming space for same sex shipping). This is why I usually refrain from assuming a relationship based on public receipts, especially for long term friendships.

I don't agree with this. Of course the relationship wouldn't be public but they still send hints. The picture of Eunhyuk and west2side holding hands reminds me so much of the picture of Heechul and Gunhee under the umbrella in Japan. They still want to express themselves, even if it's subtle. References are there for people that want to understand them. I don't think they were joking... And you don't like to base your opinions on public receipts but do you think that Sehun would have posted that shirtless pic with Donghae if there were something between them?

[ribbonribbon]

4 hours ago, Gerimolda said:

I think it was genuine . I think they're both bi and liked each other.

 

I don't agree with this. Of course the relationship wouldn't be public but they still send hints. The picture of Eunhyuk and west2side holding hands reminds me so much of the picture of Heechul and Gunhee under the umbrella in Japan. They still want to express themselves, even if it's subtle. References are there for people that want to understand them. I don't think they were joking... And you don't like to base your opinions on public receipts but do you think that Sehun would have posted that shirtless pic with Donghae if there were something between them?

The thing is, I have been EH's fan for 10 years - I have seen many more intimate pictures with both male and female. As I said, I do think he has his bi side. At the same time, I just don't think posting his picture with a friend, on a group trip, is constituted as "a couple". If one holding hand pic means dating, it would mean EH has been dating all of his friends. He took like several trips a year if Nae and other friends. That feel like just a bunch of actual friends having fun to me.  Therefore, it was a bit surprised to see you insisting these two specific are dating.  

Gunhee and Heenim have plenty of moments together, just the two of them. And they have plenty of other receipts for so many years (live stream from the same bed etc). I do believe in Gunhee and Heenim are/were a thing, but it is from a lot of receipts, just not from one or two pictures. 

For Sehun's case, I already mentioned I did not think DH and he are together. But the picture does seriously look like a drunk post - that was when I raised my doubt. I mentioned him in addition to many things I have doubt about DH, as an explanation why I thought he was gay in the past.

Of course, we are all projecting our opinions on them. I could be 10000 miles wrong.

 

Edited October 26, 2019 by ribbonribbon