The thing is, Melanie gave us her side of the story, that it happened and that Timothy never said no. So why are all these people picking apart the timeline of their friendship to try and disprove it even happened? People are actually inventing their own narrative here and it happens time and time again when rape victims come forward.
Melanie haven't though if she wanted to get away with it she could have not mentioned or admitted of having had sexual intercourse. There are many things that don't add up in this whole story. They are not inventing there some evidence just read the whole thread.
and also read this