[SUBUNIT] The Official S.H.Y Girls' Generation Thread / SHYGeneration Fan Project / #SHY2016

[hyotmess]

have you guys seen how many people requested the badge already?

 

seriously, they would slay as a sub unit

only if the hype for them to be a subunit was the same between korean fans :/

[Jadepop]

only if the hype for them to be a subunit was the same between korean fans :/

 How do you guys feel about having projects for a given period to get SHY's name out there?

We already have the K-con project.

We could try for one to get K-fans aware?

Nothing ventured, nothing gained.

Edited June 16, 2014 by Jampop

[____shawnee]

 

 

Verse 1 - Hyoyeon

Verse 2 - Yuri "Bitches hatin' on me cos I'm thick"

Verse 3 - Sooyoung

[pretty_angel92]

i just realized Sooyoung would be a main vocal...for once
 
i think it would be something like this
 
Hyoyeon- main dancer, main rapper, sub vocal
Yuri- visual, main dancer, lead vocal, rapper
Sooyoung- maknae(lol), main vocal, lead dancer, lead rapper

 

as for the leader, idk. it seems that SM always gives that title to the oldest member but we all know Sooyoung has the best leadership skills

[Sooyoung's Wife]

 

 How do you guys feel about having projects for a given period to get SHY's name out there?

We already have the K-con project.

We could try for one to get K-fans aware?

Nothing ventured, nothing gained.

 

I was going to do that project to get their name out there but I'm not going to Kcon anymore otl

 

i just realized Sooyoung would be a main vocal...for once

 

i think it would be something like this

 

Hyoyeon- main dancer, main rapper, sub vocal

Yuri- visual, main dancer, lead vocal, rapper

Sooyoung- maknae(lol), main vocal, lead dancer, lead rapper

 

as for the leader, idk. it seems that SM always gives that title to the oldest member but we all know Sooyoung has the best leadership skills

I was thinking the same thing, Sooyoung is a potential main vocal for this unit. I don't think Hyoyeon would be a subvocal tho, it'd suck to still have 2 seconds of singing time when you're in a group with only two other people. With the right kind of song, Hyoyeon's vocals could be strong. Her vocals in Goodbye were    I think combining their vocals for a sexy song would work best with their voices. Also I don't think any of them would be rappers or rap. As for the leader, tbh I don't think SM would give anyone that position lol. 

[Jadepop]

I was going to do that project to get their name out there but I'm not going to Kcon anymore otl

 

I was thinking the same thing, Sooyoung is a potential main vocal for this unit. I don't think Hyoyeon would be a subvocal tho, it'd suck to still have 2 seconds of singing time when you're in a group with only two other people. With the right kind of song, Hyoyeon's vocals could be strong. Her vocals in Goodbye were    I think combining their vocals for a sexy song would work best with their voices. Also I don't think any of them would be rappers or rap. As for the leader, tbh I don't think SM would give anyone that position lol. 

 

 

i just realized Sooyoung would be a main vocal...for once

 

i think it would be something like this

 

Hyoyeon- main dancer, main rapper, sub vocal

Yuri- visual, main dancer, lead vocal, rapper

Sooyoung- maknae(lol), main vocal, lead dancer, lead rapper

 

as for the leader, idk. it seems that SM always gives that title to the oldest member but we all know Sooyoung has the best leadership skills

 

I don't agree with positions and labels for S.H.Y. It's one of the prominent causes of friction within fandom. 

In due time, certain expectations will be placed on given roles and when said expectations are not met, or met too much, irritation, anger and resentment will surface among fans.

 

There are no specific roles for the members of TTS. They are all simply vocalists, as SHY are simply dancers. I've only seen fans complain about crazy Locksmiths sidelining Seohyun, never about her misuse, with concern to the groups music.

We will need all our energy to fend off naysayers, not our ilk.

[Sooyoung's Wife]

 

I don't agree with positions and labels for S.H.Y. It's one of the prominent causes of friction within fandom. 

In due time, certain expectations will be placed on given roles and when said expectations are not met, or met too much, irritation, anger and resentment will surface among fans.

 

There are no specific roles for the members of TTS. They are all simply vocalists, as SHY are simply dancers. I've only seen fans complain about crazy Locksmiths sidelining Seohyun, never about her misuse, with concern to the groups music.

We will need all our energy to fend off naysayers, not our ilk.

 

That's true. I think the difference with TTS is that since they're all vocals they don't have to have specific roles. The unit was put together to show off all of their vocals so it's not like Seohyun was still the lead vocal, whereas Tiff and Taeyeon (main vo.) got more lines and adlibs still. But with SHY, since they're all subvocals, I think fans want to see how SM would arrange their positions in vocals. You couldn't just give them any song to work with and know their vocals would be 100% perfect for them like TTS, but you'd have to take a more careful approach for SHY. Honestly, if this subunit were to even be formed I don't think they'd be a singing unit, but primarily a dance one. 

[MoshiMoshi]

I don't think they would give them specific positions either, it's not necessary. There are three members, so even as a dance unit, they would all dance and they would all sing. Look at Orange Caramel, afaik they don't have specific positions but they all carry their own weight and everything is divided pretty equally. I don't see a reason why SHY wouldn't be like that.

 

I see their concepts being more R&B/hip-hop concepts anyway. Look at all the dance stages they did back in the day, Rhythm Nation, the T.O.P performance (not the Japanese T.O.P lol), even Hyo and Yuri's stage with Henry. The songs don't need to be that vocally challenging so really who sings what wouldn't make much of a difference except for the way their voices sound to the producers.

 

Most of that main vocal/lead vocal is made up stuff anyway. Onion even said on his blog recently that there's no difference between main and lead singers/dancers, companies just do that stuff to give all of the members something to make them seem special. There might be one main singer and one main dancer (like Taeyeon and Hyoyeon in ITNW) but that's about it, the rest are just dance line/vocal line members. Honestly, trying to divide it up seems kind of petty. There are only three members so in the event that they actually did get a unit, there's no reason everything shouldn't be divided pretty fairly. Look at TTS.

Edited June 17, 2014 by MoshiMoshi

[pretty_angel92]

I was going to do that project to get their name out there but I'm not going to Kcon anymore otl

 

I was thinking the same thing, Sooyoung is a potential main vocal for this unit. I don't think Hyoyeon would be a subvocal tho, it'd suck to still have 2 seconds of singing time when you're in a group with only two other people. With the right kind of song, Hyoyeon's vocals could be strong. Her vocals in Goodbye were    I think combining their vocals for a sexy song would work best with their voices. Also I don't think any of them would be rappers or rap. As for the leader, tbh I don't think SM would give anyone that position lol.

i wrote sub vocal for Hyo, because i can't imagine her being a lead vocal like Yuri

 

 

I don't agree with positions and labels for S.H.Y. It's one of the prominent causes of friction within fandom. 

In due time, certain expectations will be placed on given roles and when said expectations are not met, or met too much, irritation, anger and resentment will surface among fans.

 

There are no specific roles for the members of TTS. They are all simply vocalists, as SHY are simply dancers. I've only seen fans complain about crazy Locksmiths sidelining Seohyun, never about her misuse, with concern to the groups music.

We will need all our energy to fend off naysayers, not our ilk.

 

sorry, my purpose wasn't to make SHY fans feel that way, i know SM wouldn't give them positions, i was just sort of joking

 

we all know who would get the most lines, though. true, TTS were all singers but Taeyeon obviously sang the most.

in SHY, i think Sooyoung would sing the most, since she's the best singer of the dance line

 

I don't think they would give them specific positions either, it's not necessary. There are three members, so even as a dance unit, they would all dance and they would all sing. Look at Orange Caramel, afaik they don't have specific positions but they all carry their own weight and everything is divided pretty equally. I don't see a reason why SHY wouldn't be like that.

 

I see their concepts being more R&B/hip-hop concepts anyway. Look at all the dance stages they did back in the day, Rhythm Nation, the T.O.P performance (not the Japanese T.O.P lol), even Hyo and Yuri's stage with Henry. The songs don't need to be that vocally challenging so really who sings what wouldn't make much of a difference except for the way their voices sound to the producers.

 

Most of that main vocal/lead vocal is made up stuff anyway. Onion even said on his blog recently that there's no difference between main and lead singers/dancers, companies just do that stuff to give all of the members something to make them seem special. There might be one main singer and one main dancer (like Taeyeon and Hyoyeon in ITNW) but that's about it, the rest are just dance line/vocal line members. Honestly, trying to divide it up seems kind of petty. There are only three members so in the event that they actually did get a unit, there's no reason everything shouldn't be divided pretty fairly. Look at TTS.

agree about the concept

 

however, i have to disagree when people say there's no difference between main and lead, because there definitely is.

Edited June 17, 2014 by pretty_angel92

[Sooyoung's Wife]

i wrote sub vocal for Hyo, because i can't imagine her being a lead vocal like Yurisorry, my purpose wasn't to make SHY fans feel that way, i know SM wouldn't give them positions, i was just sort of jokingwe all know who would get the most lines, though. true, TTS were all singers but Taeyeon obviously sang the most.in SHY, i think Sooyoung would sing the most, since she's the best singer of the dance lineagree about the concepthowever, i have to disagree when people say there's no difference between main and lead, because there definitely is.

I agree on that last sentence. I would explain/give examples but I don't want to get off topic.

How much you wanna bet if this unit was formed they'd have a stage featuring Yoona? lol

[pretty_angel92]

I agree on that last sentence. I would explain/give examples but I don't want to get off topic.

How much you wanna bet if this unit was formed they'd have a stage featuring Yoona? lol

that would be...disrespectful??

 

if they want to add Yoona to the subunit, then fine, but drag her to a special stage? i don't think that's fair. TTS didn't have any special stage featuring Sica or Sun...

[hyotmess]

I agree on that last sentence. I would explain/give examples but I don't want to get off topic.

How much you wanna bet if this unit was formed they'd have a stage featuring Yoona? lol

I think SM would find a way of throwing Tiffany in it

[pretty_angel92]

I think SM would find a way of throwing Tiffany in it

lol you guys are so mean. Tiffany is working really hard, it's not her fault that SM is giving her so many spotlight since last year. they're doing the same with Sooyoung and both girls are getting all the hate for no reason at all

[Tom.]

Honestly, all those titles and positions or whatever are just dumb. They all sing, they all dance, nobody in SNSD can actually rap really. Anything else just leads to arguments; I remember reading a lot of hate thrown around re: "lead/main vocalist" in terms of Jessica and Tiffany getting more or less lines than the other. Let's not bring that mess in here, this is a place of purity and impeccable taste.

 

Besides, SHY will be the new Orange Caramel: no titles, all members treated equally, and the sub-unit will be far more popular than their main group and will sell more records while being more entertaining performers.

 

[Sooyoung's Wife]

Besides, SHY will be the new Orange Caramel: no titles, all members treated equally, and the sub-unit will be far more popular than their main group and will sell more records while being more entertaining performers.

hoping this happens in 2k15

[Jadepop]

Do you guys think it would be ok to post the ladies' sns activities in here?

 

Also im spamming Taeyeon/Bacon threads with SHY.

You guys are welcome to join.

[Jadepop]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpkYKFrwzGs

 

Tell me Sooyoung wasn't KILLING this performance

[____shawnee]

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpkYKFrwzGs

 

Tell me Sooyoung wasn't KILLING this performance

 

 

One of my favorite performances from Sooyoung.

[Jadepop]

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpkYKFrwzGs

 

 

 

Tell me SHY wasn't KILLING this performance, Soo especially

 

LOL i quoted maself

Edited June 21, 2014 by Jampop

[Sooyoung's Wife]

 

Do you guys think it would be ok to post the ladies' sns activities in here?

 

 

 

Also im spamming Taeyeon/Bacon threads with SHY.

 

You guys are welcome to join.

It's probably preferred if their activities are posted in their own threads but you can do it if you want. The only SNSD thread I go in is this one so I'd probably check the thread more often lol.

[hyotmess]

lol you guys are so mean. Tiffany is working really hard, it's not her fault that SM is giving her so many spotlight since last year. they're doing the same with Sooyoung and both girls are getting all the hate for no reason at all

i'm not hating on tiffany i'm just saying thats what SM would do lol

[pretty_angel92]

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpkYKFrwzGs

 

Tell me Sooyoung wasn't KILLING this performance

 

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES

[Jadepop]

 

Fetus SooYul

[myangelhyo]

SHY

[TaeyeonHK]

 

 

Fetus SooYul

Aw they look cute, and Yuri looks shy...