Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

why did herin and Natty dropped?


Mami3chan

Recommended Posts

Natty has a lot of screen time so we can't blame Mnet for her dropping. I said it before but she's not standing out in the show

 

both herin & natty are more talented than the majority of the untalented kids on that show,.

 

if this is about standing out and personality then shit is fucked up imstupid.png

i don't want them to debut and get bashed for being talentless visuals with personality but whatever lol imstupid.png imstupid.png imstupid.png imstupid.png imstupid.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If talent mattered, Tasha wouldn't be at 26

And Bae Eunyeong shouldn't keep dropping.

 

Natty has a lot of screen time so we can't blame Mnet for her dropping. I said it before but she's not standing out in the show. 

Hmm. Her screen time has been sacrificed for Jina's after ep1. You may watch a Natty cut on Youtube.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And Bae Eunyeong shouldn't keep dropping.

 

Hmm. Her screen time has been sacrificed for Jina's after ep1. You may watch a Natty cut on Youtube.

Her screen time compared to Herin is pennies. So we shouldn't blame Mnet for Natty dropping fans are just not into her but again it's only ep 4. Anything can happen.

 

 

both herin & natty are more talented than the majority of the untalented kids on that show,.

 

if this is about standing out and personality then shit is fucked up imstupid.png

i don't want them to debut and get bashed for being talentless visuals with personality but whatever lol imstupid.png imstupid.png imstupid.png imstupid.png imstupid.png

- Ah, no offense Natty isn't "that" talented... Good dancer yeah but in that Me Gustas Tu perf all I notice was Herin lack of wait non-existent vocal lines when she's a better singer than Natty. And Dahee who is the main vocal got only 9 points. Do you understand imstupid.png

 

- Welp, it kinda is. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

- Ah, no offense Natty isn't "that" talented... Good dancer yeah but in that Me Gustas Tu perf all I notice was Herin lack of wait non-existent vocal lines when she's a better singer than Natty. And Dahee who is the main vocal got only 9 points. Do you understand imstupid.png

 

what you don't understand is they are more talented than the majority of the kids on that show.. imstupid.png

 

are you lowkey telling me that baek jiheon from the Rookie team is more talented and that how she got the 1st spot? imstupid.png

 

 

you do know that people are not voting for talent lol! do you understand? lets be real here..

putin2c.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Herin I don't know much about her

Her screen time is too bad

 

and Mnet and K-net indeed did dirty to Natty as they did to Tasha now

Both are TOP1 and TOP2 at skill evaluation

Both are from South East Asian (Thai and Singaporean)

Both are dropping 3 ranks this week

and Mnet and K-netz play really dirty to both of them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Her screen time compared to Herin is pennies. So we shouldn't blame Mnet for Natty dropping fans are just not into her but again it's only ep 4. Anything can happen.

 

 

- Ah, no offense Natty isn't "that" talented... Good dancer yeah but in that Me Gustas Tu perf all I notice was Herin lack of wait non-existent vocal lines when she's a better singer than Natty. And Dahee who is the main vocal got only 9 points. Do you understand imstupid.png

Yes, her screen time is far greater than Herin's which is almost non-existence yet, it's not that much. Some contestants have far more quality screen times than her, who can barely be heard outside of the performance and class greeting now.

 

All teachers in the show agreed she was in top class, great dancer and good singer. Who are you to argue professionals? Are you another idiot playing down dance as a talent? You can praise Herin all you want but, to do so by talking down on Natty is ugly.

 

For the lack of the line, she could blame no one but herself for being unable to grab the lead vocalist position. To be fair,  everyone's parts but Dahee's were not significantly different. Natty's part was more noticeable only because of her high pitched voice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, her screen time is far greater than Herin's which is almost non-existence yet, it's not that much. Some contestants have far more quality screen times than her, who can barely be heard outside of the performance and class greeting now.

 

All teachers in the show agreed she was in top class, great dancer and good singer. Who are you to argue professionals? Are you another idiot playing down dance as a talent? You can praise Herin all you want but, to do so by talking down on Natty is ugly.

 

For the lack of the line, she could blame no one but herself for being unable to grab the lead vocalist position. To be fair,  everyone's parts but Dahee's were not significantly different. Natty's part was more noticeable only because of her high pitched voice.

I wasn't even praising herin tho.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

more cute girls getting known by Koreans. Visual game is still a strong power in reality show no matter how talented you are. 

 

I think Natty and Herin are pretty on their own but their visuals does not suit Korea's standards. Plus their vocals are not that outstanding to make them more noticeable. I barely heard Herin during their group performance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For Herin, I think it's mainly screentime. Since people knew she was an SM ex-trainee, and she was promoted a lot by SM, they were probably voting for her right away, but they might have stopped voting for her because of her lack of screentime. Her screentime is really lacking, her vocals haven't been truly showcased, I only know she's a really good singer because of her Mickey Mouse Club performances before the show.  

 

As for Natty, her screen time has been okay, but it dropped a lot as the episodes went on. MNet aren't evil editing Natty or robbing her of screen time, but they have been focusing on playing up other trainees a lot more. I've loved Natty since Sixteen and she's talented and has strong visuals so I genuinely can't think of reasons for her to be dropping.

 

I'll keep supporting them both until the end~ ^^

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top