Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Official Vocals thread (READ OP FIRST)


VISION

Recommended Posts

Idk it varies. As far as Ik, he's sorta there and has resonated but I've never heard it lol 

There. Better. lol

 

Everyone always says this and I know where they claim it to be, but I really cannot for the life of me hear it...

In Say Yes with Krystal and Kris, right, during one of her ad libs around the 1:10 mark?

 

I honestly couldn't hear a G5. I LOVE Jessica and I REALLY WANT HER to make that step over to G5, trust me, but I really couldn't hear it.

At the time people claimed she hit a G5, I just heard her start at D5 and then eventually make her way down to C4 or so in that run.

Because the audio was ripped from a video recording, I DID hear a high scream or exclamation before Jessica's D5, which I don't think was her and was someone in the vicinity of the uploader / camera person.

 

If someone can help me it would be appreciated D:

She goes "OOOOOhhhhh". She sustains a C and then jumps up the scale rapidly upto G5. And then goes down again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jaejoong has resonated, we thought he had, but a Cassie pointed out that it was actually Junsu who was resonant not Jaejoong.

It was a solo perf... You mean Changmin not Jaejoong. The Changmin resonance was Junsu, The JJ resonant video was a solo perf.

 

 

... I think I'm going to wait for the studio version. XDDD

Alright lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you mean what.. I mean I listened back to Kyuhyun's and Junsu's resonant G#4's, and Rocky's G#4's sound very similar in terms of placement.. 

I don't hear G#4s in Want U Back...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Are we talking about the same song cuz I'm not sure that's the one I listened to and heard resonance then LOL OH WAIT NO I heard resonance in the G#4's from Bad Boy, I haven't listened to Want U Back. LOL

Pshh you should read LOL I talked about "Want U Back" in my comment not Bad Boy. I didn't even watch the Bad Boy video posted. lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you guys think of CSJH?

I know they're praised a lot by Shapleys (like me) but I also do know that most of them are probably mediocre individually.

However, you do have to admit that the overall average of vocal talent within the group is higher than 90% or so of all girl groups today.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aAkfHaAUgyE

Whoever told you that,  lied to you. CSJH are a good vocal group. They are one of the best, if not the best vocal gg in Kpop. Lina's good, Dana's  decent, Sunday's okay, and Stephanie's like Minkyung-ok.

 

I think most of the time we could say E5

I just didnt pay attention to what the song I listened to was called LOL

 

Dear. Don't be fooled. CSJH is the best female vocal group overall. Stephanie is as good as Seohyun and she's the weakest, then you have Sunday's who's like in between BoA and Narsha, then Dana who's like right bottom top 10 and Linda who's like 4th best. 

LOL Alright.

 

It's Lina.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OH LOOOORDDDDD

 

Thank God I thought you guys would SLAY them for some reason.

 

I guess I was just paranoid because CSJH was the very first kpop group I listened to back in 07/08 and I loved them to death and thought so highly of them. So I was just trying to cushion any criticism my poor Shapley heart had to take. 

 

YESSS I ALWAYS BELIEVED IN MY HOME GIRLS

UGH

 

so happy rn XDDDDD

I made a mistake there btw, Sunday's Minkyung-okay-ish level whereas Stephanie's SeoSic level.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Amanda Brown from the Voice? The girl's just bad. She's so shrill. No contestants from that season (Casadee winning season) are even remotely decent. All are just bad bad bad. Casadee, the winner, is just so bad, so no wonder other contestants are bad.

Edited by Shinagawa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've seen a lot of whitney's performances actually (possibly all of her performances on youtube for certain songs) and it's very easy to tell she doesn't lipsync because her creativity > 9000. Beyonce... tbh she lipsyncs fairly often too, but she has her moments (like when she performed irreplaceable and halo to a hospital audience with her raw vocals). ive never had any interest in patti ._. 

 

But real talk i honestly feel like bada is lipsyncing, no hate or butthurt intended at all.

 

IS2, I'm sure you are not allowed to lip sync there. It's not hard to get it btw one can sing good and perform well. Just because people you like can't doesn't mean it's not possible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mhmm vocal technique alone won't save you. If you really do watch Mariah, she barely moves when she's singing, she does minimal...she's not a dancer afterall, but Beyonce. is like....wow. LOL

Watch her live for Make it Happen at Madison Square Garden, she moves around and ducks a lot. Still maintains tonality and resonance. And her Honey perfs too.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

but it's not a choreography. I know that, but it's still not do with technique. SPEAKING OF WHICH MAKE IT HAPPEN IS GONNA BE A WEEK 9 SONG IN A LIVE PERFORMANCE WORKSHOP AT SCHOOL. OMG SHUD DO IT.

Dear Matty, the Honey perfs are all choreographed.

 

Do it, I wanna listen to it. Be sure to be resonant on those E4s LOL

Edited by Shinagawa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is it like cute choreo or is like Ciara/Beyonce choreo?

 

LOL Where are the E4's? I thought it was C#'s...the MAKE IT HAPPEEEEEEEEN C# lol But yeah I just downloaded the song so I can get familiar with it and try to do it well

Go and watch a perf on YT.

She hits many E5s, go and check. And yes it's C#s in Make it HAPPPEEEENNNNNN part. Try to play it up though.... D Major's the key, try to sing an A or G? F# will work too.

 

 

I don't know/care about their vocals enough to say anything, I just said that about the C5 because that's what Chung told me =/ I believe Minzy is not worse than her overall tho

Yep, the C5 not overall. Minzy still is a lot, I mean a lot better than Hyuna.

Edited by Shinagawa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh wait no there is no C#5, not in the album version at least, the key is a step higher so It's a D5, she hits a lot of F5's and a few G5's in that song..

 

BTW GUYS I SAW KAI LIKE 10 FEET AWAY FROM ME OMFG HE WAS WALKING TO THE STAGE AND I WAS LIKE CHARGING MY PHONE AND NOBODY ELSE RECOGNIZED HIM CUZ THEY WERENT LOOKING BUT OMFG.

You are right she hits C#5s and E5s in the Madison Square live not the studio one. And F5s? What? That'd be offkey... I do hear many F#5s though.

 

LOL Not a Kai fan, so IDC hehe :hurr: :hurr:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really? I really just hear a bunch of Fs, Gs, Es and Ds lol no Cs.. lol

The song's written in D Major, LOL IDK how there can be Fs.

 

Edit: Oh wait, it's D Minor. You are right. There are F5s in the studio ones. In the lives the key's changed.

Edited by Shinagawa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The key is probably C# minor in lives

 

Well if they were a girl I'd understand the range being chest only because some girls have weak voices that turn into head voice around F4 ~ A4 area, also F3 is waaaaay too high for a guy whose highest note is F4...but yknow. lol 

Prolly.

 

F3 is a little too high for a low point for a guy of any voice type. I don't believe his lowest is F3.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  I tried with Tiffany, RITD at least was more stable (except the C5), most of her transitions between notes were better. I didn't have many options for Tiffany so I chose the one I thought was her best since it show she had some improvement in her stability. You didn't pick one for the Sunny Bunny.

 

The Fany duet with KWill. It's better than RITD.

 

For Sica, Heaven or Wish You Upon a Star. Sunny... her perf from her musical. For Taeyeon, All that Jazz for a solo perf. Seo, Jack or Stuff like that there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you guys think of this ranking?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWNCqfoH1Tk

 

The maker needs to get slapped, so they can wake up from their dream and realise Christina shouldn't be there.

 

On the sidenote, some people on that list can be easily replaced. So it's a BS list.

Edited by Shinagawa
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   1 member

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top