Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

WINNER & PSY join the TOP 10 Artists Nominees @ 2017 Melon Music Awards


miranda

Recommended Posts

So is YG going to rig this year too?

Some of you guys are being so freaking annoying, at least be logical if you wanna hate. This is Melon awards, MELON. Now I invite you to open up melon website and check out the chart. You will probably get why Psy and Winner deserve to join their nominees and why talking about rigging it is just dumb as fuck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wait they are already announcing stuff? wthplz.png

I visited the site and i dont get it lol

 

it's ongoing XD

the nominees are artists with great perf on chart: collecting points (600) (votes from melon's weekly popularity award + points from melon's weekly chart rank) or 5 times being the 1st for melon's weekly popularity award.

 

 

Is this for artist of the year?

 

iirc, this is more like bonsang. but the winners will have the biggest chance for artist of the year (daesang)~

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some of you guys are being so freaking annoying, at least be logical if you wanna hate. This is Melon awards, MELON. Now I invite you to open up melon website and check out the chart. You will probably get why Psy and Winner deserve to join their nominees and why talking about rigging it is just dumb as fuck.

 

YG rigged last year's rookie of the year. YG is not beyond rigging.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

YG rigged last year's rookie of the year. YG is not beyond rigging.

You don't get the point at all and I'm going to rephrase maybe you will finally get it: whatever happened last year has nothing to do with this year nominees considering stats and numbers don't lie. Are you gonna use the BP x IOI situation to discredit Winner and PSY? I repeat check melon website and dare talk about rigging when both of them slayed (and are still slaying) the charts. You don't make any sense at all hating on all YG artists just because you're salty about what happened between IOI and BP last year. Get over it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted · Hidden by twinky, June 21, 2017 - No reason given
Hidden by twinky, June 21, 2017 - No reason given

You don't get the point at all I'm going to rephrase maybe you will finally get it: whatever happened last year gas nothing to do with this year nominees considering stats and numbers don't lie. Are you gonna use the BP x IOI situation to discredit Winner and PSY. I repeat check melon website and dare talk about rigging when both of them slayed (and are still slaying) the charts. You don't make any sense at all hating on all YG artists just because you're salty about what happened between IOI and BP last year. Get over it.

 

I just asked if YG is going to rig this year too. It's in the realm of possibilities. We won't know until the awards are given out, but it's a legit concern given what happened last year. Now stop being so offended. You should be against rigging too, it makes YG and hence their artists look bad.

Link to comment

YG rigged last year's rookie of the year. YG is not beyond rigging.

"It is known for only calculating digital sales and online votes to judge winners, Points distribution are from 70% from digital score and 30% of online voting"

"Whistle" (휘파람)[A]                

  "Boombayah" (ë¶ë°”야)              

                  "Dream Girls"      

  • KOR: 652,321+ (Digital)[12]

"Crush"

       

  • KOR: 387,588+ (Digital)[11]

         

 

           

I'm assuming they used debut songs for this? idk how the online voting went, but it's not like BP was so far off from winning that it had to be rigged

 

cr.Wikipedia so sorry if anything is wrong

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted · Hidden by twinky, June 21, 2017 - No reason given
Hidden by twinky, June 21, 2017 - No reason given

I just asked if YG is going to rig this year too. It's in the realm of possibilities. We won't know until the awards are given out, but it's a legit concern given what happened last year. Now stop being so offended. You should be against rigging too, it makes YG and hence their artists look bad.

Why would you ask about rigging when both of these artists are fully capable of winning without any interference from YG? That's whats dumb and I know you're still salty over IOI but you will really have to move on lol it's not "we won't know until the awards are given out" Winner and Psy are currently slaying the charts, I would be more concerned if they don't win anything lmao

Link to comment

"It is known for only calculating digital sales and online votes to judge winners, Points distribution are from 70% from digital score and 30% of online voting"

"Whistle" (휘파람)[A]                  "Boombayah" (ë¶ë°”야)                                "Dream Girls"      
  • KOR: 652,321+ (Digital)[12]

"Crush"

       
  • KOR: 387,588+ (Digital)[11]
         

 

           

I'm assuming they used debut songs for this? idk how the online voting went, but it's not like BP was so far off from winning that it had to be rigged

 

cr.Wikipedia so sorry if anything is wrong

 

The controversy was that before the awards show the criteria was all digital songs would be counted. This was backed up by previous Melon roty winners calculations as well as evidence from a fan asking before the awards show for clarification on the criteria and Melon saying that it was all songs. After BP won Melon changed the criteria to fit the winner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted · Hidden by twinky, June 21, 2017 - No reason given
Hidden by twinky, June 21, 2017 - No reason given

Why would you ask about rigging when both of these artists are fully capable of winning without any interference from YG? That's whats dumb and I know you're still salty over IOI but you will really have to move on lol it's not "we won't know until the awards are given out" Winner and Psy are currently slaying the charts, I would be more concerned if they don't win anything lmao

 

As I said before, due to YG's actions last year it makes them and all their artists look bad, so they must be scrutinized. I'll move on from when YG apologizes. I know you love Mino, and I have nothing against Winner, but we must expect things to be fair.

Link to comment

The controversy was that before the awards show the criteria was all digital songs would be counted. This was backed up by previous Melon roty winners calculations as well as evidence from a fan asking before the awards show for clarification on the criteria and Melon saying that it was all songs. After BP won Melon changed the criteria to fit the winner.

Ahh ok that makes sense.....

~lol idk much about this stuff~ za5g21G.png

 

but still, i don't think it was so far off that the only possible way they could win was if it was rigged 

 

I won't argue tho since it was in the past, and again, I don't know much about this stuff

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ahh ok that makes sense.....

~lol idk much about this stuff~ za5g21G.png

 

but still, i don't think it was so far off that the only possible way they could win was if it was rigged 

 

The story got huge upvotes on k-websites because everyone was confused by the outcome. IOI was leading by a large margin for the 30% fan votes and in total songs. BBG4 was actually second place with the original criteria. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top