The highest rated albums for boy groups on Melon

[GirlBye]

Big Bang

 

 

1. Always (Lies) - 4.8

2. Hot Issue (Last Farewell) - 4.8

3. Stand Up (Haru Haru) - 4.7

 4. Big Bang Vol. 1 (Dirty Cash) - 4.7

 5. Remember (Sunset Glow) - 4.6

 6. Big Bang Vol. 4 (Tonight) - 4.6

 7. ALIVE (Fantastic Baby) - 4.4

8. MADE - 4.2

 

Average Rating: 4.6

 

BTOB

 

 

1. The Winter's Tale (You Can't Cry) - 4.8

2. Born To Beat (Insane) - 4.8

3. Thriller - 4.7

4. Move (You're So Fly) - 4.7

5. Press Play (Wow) - 4.7

6. Remember That - 4.6

7. I Mean (Way Back Home) - 4.5

8. Feel'eM (Movie) - 4.4

9. New Men (Pray) - 4.4

10. Beep Beep - 4.4

 

Average Rating: 4.6

 

 

Shinee

 

 

1. Romeo (Juliette) - 4.8

2. 2009, Year of Us (Ring Ding Dong) - 4.7

3. Shinee World (Love Like Oxygen) - 4.7

4. Lucifer - 4.6

5. Sherlock - 4.5

6. Why So Serious (The Misconceptions of Me Pt. 2) - 4.5

7. Odd (View) - 4.4

8. Dream Girl (The Misconceptions of Me Pt. 1) - 4.4

9. Everybody - 4.4

10. 1 of 1 - 4.4

 

Average Rating: 4.5

 

Beast/Highlight

 

 

1. Fiction and Fact (Fiction) - 4.7

2. Shock Of The New Era (Shock) - 4.7 

3. Mastermind (Breath) - 4.7 

4. Lights Go On Again (Beautiful) - 4.7 

5. Highlight (Ribbon) - 4.5

6. Good Luck - 4.4

7. TIME (12:30) - 4.4

8. Hard To Love, How To Love (Shadow) - 4.2

9. Midnight Sun (Beautiful Night) - 4.2

10. Ordinary (YEY) - 4.1

 

Average Rating: 4.4

 

Infinite 

 

 

1. Over The Top (Be Mine) - 4.8

2. First Invasion (Come Back Again) - 4.8

3. Evolution (BTD) - 4.8

4. Infinitize (Chaser) - 4.5

5. Season 2 (Last Romeo) - 4.4

6. New Challenge (Man In Love) - 4.4

7. Infinite Only (The Eye) - 4.3

8. Be Back (Back) - 4.1

9. Destiny (Single Album) - 4.0

10. Reality (Bad) - 3.9

 

Average Rating: 4.4

 

Block B

 

 

1. Very Good - 4.5

2. Blockbuster (Niliri Mambo) - 4.4

3. Blooming Period (Toy) - 4.4

4. Welcome to the BLOCK (NalinA) 4.3

5. HER - 3.9

 

Average Rating: 4.3

 

Super Junior

 

 

1. It's You (Single Album) - 4.7

2. Sorry Sorry - 4.6

3. U - 4.6

4. Don't Don - 4.5

5. Bonamana - 4.4

6. Super Junior05 (Twins) - 4.3

7. Mr. Simple 4.2

8. Mamacita - 4.1

9. Devil - 4.0

10. Sexy, Free & Single - 3.5

 

Average Rating: 4.2

 

BTS

 

 

1. Dark & Wild (Danger) - 4.6

2. O!RUL8,2? (N.O) - 4.6

3. Skool Luv Affair (Boy In Luv) - 4.5

4. TMBMIL Pt. 1 (I Need You) - 4.3

5. TMBMIL Pt. 2 (Run) - 4.2

6. TMBMIL, Young Forever (Fire) - 3.8

7. WINGS (Blood Sweat Tears) - 3.6

 

Average Rating: 4.2

 

Seventeen

 

 

1. BOYS BE (Mansae) - 4.5

2. 17 Carat (Adore U) - 4.5

3. Going Seventeen (Boom Boom) - 4.2

4. LOVE&LETTER (Pretty U) - 4.1

5. AI1 (Don't Wanna Cry) - 3.9

 

Average Rating: 4.2

 

GOT7

 

 

1. Mad (If You Do) - 4.4

2. Identify (Stop Stop It) - 4.4

3. Flight Log: Departure (Fly) 4.4

4. Flight Log: Arrival (Never Ever) - 4.3

5. Got Love (A) - 4.3

6. Flight Log :Turbulence (Hard Carry) - 4.3

7. Got It? (Girls Girls Girls) - 3.9

8. Just Right - 3.6

 

Average Rating: 4.2

 

Winner

 

 

1. Fate Number For (Really Really/Single Album) - 4.2

2. 2014 S/S (Empty) - 4.1

3. EXIT: E (Sentimental) - 4.0

 

Average Rating: 4.1

 

NCT (127, U, Dream)

 

 

1. The First (My First and Last/Single Album) - 4.3

2. Limitless - 4.0

3. NCT #127 1st Mini Album (Firetruck) - 3.7

4. NCT U (Seventh Sense 3.1/Without You 3.8) - 3.4

 

Average Rating: 3.8

 

Exo

 

 

 

1. MAMA - 4.4

2. XOXO (Wolf) - 4.0

3. Miracles in December (Winter Album) - 3.9

4. EXODUS (Call Me Baby) - 3.7

5. Sing For You (Winter Album) - 3.7

6. EX'ACT (Monster/Lucky One) - 3.5

7. Overdose - 3.5

 

Average Rating: 3.8

 

 

IKON

 

 

1. New Kids: Begin (Bling Bling/Single Album) - 3.9

2. Welcome Back (What's Wrong?/Full Album) 3.8

3. Welcome Back (My Type/Half Album) - 3.7

 

Average Rating: 3.8

 

 

*Did not include repackage albums*

 

- Noticed that on average boy groups had much higher ratings than girl groups (fandom v. public?)

- EXO on average had the highest amount of ratings, with most albums nearing 50k

 

Sorry if I made any mistakes...let me know and I'll correct

 

 

New Gen Girl Groups:

 

https://onehallyu.com/topic/522635-the-highest-rated-albums-for-new-generation-girl-groups-on-melon/

 

Pre-2014 Girl Groups:

 

https://onehallyu.com/topic/522994-the-highest-rated-albums-from-2nd-generation-girl-groups-on-melon/

[jeong jaehyuns boyfriend]

exodus being given just a 3.7 is a crime.... it was so iconic

[pinkypinkyapink]

You add all nugus but not BTOB? 

[angy]

Tragic taste in those Exo albums

[Ddeona Oneul Bame]

Whoever rated XOXO that high is cancelled~

[Mercurio]

How are EXODUS and EX'ACT lower than MAMA, XOXO and a winter album? What kind of trash taste smh

[Zamo]

[scoopula]

dark and wildsus did that also im cackling at the fact that wings only has 3.6

 

 

edit: ppl are rlly acting surprise that more recent albums have lower stars as if antis dont increase with every comeback

[GirlBye]

You add all nugus but not BTOB? 

Sorry...I don't follow boy groups so I prob missed a few popular ones. I'll add them!

[Kally]

wings - 3.6

 

[Full Moon]

Damn haters are really up in EXO ass lol. Those ratings are far from the truth

Like EXODUS a 3.7? Nope

Happy for BTS average ratings tho but again Wings a 3.6? 

I hate when haters mess up with the ratings and stuff

[Reipaca]

How is Wings and TMBLIL Young Forever (which won a daesang) rated lower than O! RUL8,2? and DARK&WILD

[Vtzu]

 

1. Dark & Wild (Danger) - 4.6

2. O!RUL8,2? (N.O) - 4.6

3. Skool Luv Affair (Boy In Luv) - 4.5

4. TMBMIL Pt. 1 (I Need You) - 4.3

5. TMBMIL Pt. 2 (Run) - 4.2

6. TMBMIL, Young Forever (Fire) - 3.8

7. WINGS (Blood Sweat Tears) - 3.6

 

Average Rating: 4.2

 

BTS discography is perfection   But some of these could be higher 

[Meeks]

Wings?? A 3.6??? Blasphemy!

[co-ups]

here you can clearly see what is a public friendly song

and it's funny because a lot of 3.x did really good internationally

[Ddeona Oneul Bame]

I just realized MID is almost the same as XOXO, LMAOOOOOO~

[TAE AMO]

you can see how the ratings for bts decreased as they got more popular lmao. that's no coincidence 

[xxxxxxxxxxx]

A lot of these ratings don't mean anything/aren't 'accurate' though, especially for popular groups who have a lot of antis, you can see this especially for BTS and EXO, but the more they grew popular, the more antis rate their albums with low scores.

[Seulgi's jams]

exodus being given just a 3.7 is a crime.... it was so iconic

exo would be higher rating imo if they didn't go around downvoting/1star everybody, people caught on to their schemes...

[diminie]

Dark&Wild deserves it. 

[Rxlcrab]

Well Romeo is legendary in its quality, but I would have thought Odd and the Misconception series would score higher. If it was just up to me then 1of1 would have scored 5/5.

[GirlBye]

dark and wildsus did that also im cackling at the fact that wings only has 3.6

 

 

edit: ppl are rlly acting surprise that more recent albums have lower stars as if antis dont increase with every comeback

Most likely since Wings has the most ratings, 55k...this number is much higher compared to their previous albums

 

Damn haters are really up in EXO ass lol. Those ratings are far from the truth

Like EXODUS a 3.7? Nope

Happy for BTS average ratings tho but again Wings a 3.6? 

I hate when haters mess up with the ratings and stuff

Yeah pretty much all of Exo's album had ratings above 30k, with most near 50k...even the most popular ggs (whose albums are more popular with the public didn't have that many ratings)

[SAUCY]

unpopular opinion but personally, mama is my favourite album from exo  

[otter.]

I love all albums from Got7 but for me Flight Log Series >

 

Edit: Got It and Just Right below 4.0????? Mine, Before the full moon rises, Like oh and Playground do not deserve this slander...

[ASS]

wINGS, now that rating is disrespectful blegh lol