Which Produce 101 season did better the girl group/boy group renditions?

[snsdJM]

All the renditions from season 2 are over but which season overall slayed more paying homage to other groups?

 

Season 1- Girls

 

 

Season 2- Boys

 

Seeing all the performance, i think the girls overall did so much better and there were a lot more stand out performances from them. The boys did good too but i feel there were no WOW moments as ITNW, god sejeong, or shirt lifting from 4minute

 

So which season did it better?

 

Also this is just a discussion thread, no hating both seasons are good.

[miseol]

hands down the girls

[CantabileCross]

overall - girls, hands down

 

however, with "standout" performances what's usually most eye-catching to me tends to be subtle charisma as opposed to overt actions, so with that I prefer the boys (e.g. Yoo Seunho, Baekho)

[Love Drought]

def the girls

[lyanna]

The girls are so so good at singing compared to the boys

[Thot7]

The girls and its not even close. 

[KUMA-MON]

the girls 

[Caroline^^]

Do you need to ask

[EXPstan45]

Girls. That Hot Issue performance was legendary and underrated in the long run, they felt like a real group that could debut right then and there

they had the charisma and charm, had a fierce center while balancing with the queen of Aegyo Han Hyeri, they had something for everyone 

[Gondry]

the girls tbh, but PWF cover was AWESOOOOOOME

mnet's editing isn't helping at all this season, they're making amazing performances seem just okay

[Daybreak]

Do you need to ask

 

+1 LOL. She killed it in Hot Issue.

 

Anyways, the girls were overall better. There were some good moments - like Dongho's little solo part in BIL, or Woodam's high notes, but the stage presence the girls had was better. 

[shugwi]

hands down the girls

 

 

[Ash-Pikachu]

The girls by far.

 

And OP, why you no include this masterpiece:

 

[snsdJM]

 

The girls by far.

 

And OP, why you no include this masterpiece:

cause thats round 2 the vocal-rap-dance round

 

this was just for the renditions of other group past hits/debuts

[Ash-Pikachu]

cause thats round 2 the vocal-rap-dance round

 

this was just for the renditions of other group past hits/debuts

Ohhh, my bad. 

[sillysone]

lmao that screechy kid in the be mine performance   'let's goo' my poor ears 

[holahuz]

the girls

[Katoe]

I was re-watching/skimming through the PD101 eps the other day (girls).

Honestly didn't realize how much I loved a lot of the renditions.

 

So for me the girls >

[gd4eva]

I feel like the first season had waayyyy better performances and general talent. But the second season is more fun to watch episode wise because there is lots of spotlight on lots of cute people and alot of drama.

Overall the first season tops imo but we still got episodes left for this season so

[Re Quest]

the girls by far

[SeeYaWithYou]

The were much better overall

[YEO]

I love both seasons but the girls >>

[oddflower]

The girls 

[magritte]

i'm rooting for so many boys but the girls are really so much more talented haha

[theonlyexception]

The girls by miles

 

Overall the boys are not as talented as the girls.

But i watch it anyway cause i am so fuckinh shallow