The Big three recent comebacks, which was better?

[mnt21]

SM- Gave us SNSD IGAB, SHINee Dream girl and why so serious and upcoming Exo's Wolf. In my opinion SM did not really produce good title tracks, IGAB was a mess, Dream girl was bland and WYSS was not good and Exo's wolf just sounded pain bad, just from the teaser naega olf, it will be bad.

 

JYP- 2PM and 15& not that bad, but not blow out of my mind, it was decent but my only problem is that they had the traditional JYP feel to it.

 

YG- Probably gave us the most dissapointing comebacks, the only good comebacks this yeatr was rose. From Cl's BDF to Michigo i just get this I wanna be black feeling and lets's not forget Gentleman, A song that was so hyped up but was kinda dissapointing.

 

 

Share your opinion on which company had the better releases, and yes i know its not the end of the year.just for opinions

[sofi]

I like the Misconception of Me's album the most, also enjoyed Break Down a lot

 

comeback =/= title track

[Dragonseu]

i think CUBE should be in this too.

 

tbh i dont want to choose but if i have to i would probably say YG.

[Skibop!!]

Out of all of those, I only liked ADTOY and Somebody, super disappointed with SHINee 

[edr49890]

hays sorry but i can't move on to CL lyrics English ..but for me ,SHINNEE only the one who release better 

[DHenchanted]

nothing outstanding from any imo

 

i did like suju m's breakdown, gummy's japanese mini, and shinee's album, not title tracks 

[LonelyBoy17]

None tbh

[Nanallena]

EXO's full album sans wolf>>>>>>

Black Pearl/Baby Don't cry/My Lady are the best 3 songs of 2013 so far. No1Kara bout wolf tho

 

CBs from both Yg and Jyp were basic & underwhelming.

CL's single is the worst material released out of the 3, alongside wolf tbh

[Nyokou]

SM is the worst this year.

[munyuna]

I would add Cube and their 4minute comeback. Close to some songs you listed, What's Your Name is actually pretty nice

Dream Girl was nice but WSS is crap

 

15& was lovely

[Sarah ☆]

SM for me.

IGAB was perfection imo, Misconceptions of Me was more than perfection, and I'm really looking forward to hearing all of EXO's album. It's not all about the title tracks and SM has managed to give me some solid albums this year. They also gave us SuJu M's Breakdown which you didn't mention in the OP and that song was fantastic. 

 

JYP would be second tho because I did really love 15&'s comeback and 2PM's A.D.T.O.Y

[Mehr03]

I love Break down and I like Shinee's albums. 

[CALICO CAT]

Sm for me

 

The second part of shinee's comeback was great (the whole album) + Break down

[mnt21]

I like the Misconception of Me's album the most, also enjoyed Break Down a lot

 

comeback =/= title track

 Only the title track 'cos its obvious not everyone listens to the albums, Just wanted pinion on title track

[Sarah ☆]

 Only the title track 'cos its obvious not everyone listens to the albums, Just wanted pinion on title track

 

You should state that in the OP then. Comeback =/= title track. 

[Sun☼Shine]

SM won for me because as whole they did a good job with their artists promotion. Even though all of their title tracks were questionable, the full albums, mv and everything else was great.

[desu]

JYP u slut

 

give miss slAy a comeback

 

[TiramiQ]

title tracks? my fav title track from the big3 was SJ-M's Breakdown but i dont know if you wanna count non korean stuff

Eunhae's jpn single is up there too, eventho i have yet to listen to the full version, the short pv is good enough so far

[sofi]

 Only the title track 'cos its obvious not everyone listens to the albums, Just wanted pinion on title track

 

If it's only title tracks, i'd go with JYP then

I liked 2pm's ADOTY, even if it's not entirely my cup of tea

[mnt21]

 

You should state that in the OP then. Comeback =/= title track. 

 

 I was rushing my bad,and I'm in class too

[Shinee Spazzer]

Sm did a better comeback as a whole. Like most people said Comeback =/= title track only.

 

They give splash with IGAB even the title track is a mess.

Dream girl make quite a stir in Korea. Most successful SHINee song digitally maybe? if not Ring Ding Dong.

XOXO already create so much hype. They will sell so much. 

 

These 3 albums is a pure gold.

 

 

YG did so great with Gummy, that her comeback is aJapanese one so that hardly count. Lee Hi album is good but Rose and It's Over is not her best song. CL , PSY and GD is mehhh honestly.

 

 

​JYP is good, but ofcourse forgettable.   Low digital and low physical.

[danny.]

If we're talking about releases as a whole and not just title tracks then its easily SM. I didn't like most of their artists' title tracks but the albums are pretty solid for the most part. People say that they come out with shit music, but I just don't see it. :/

 

 

JYP also had great comebacks, but I just liked SM's a bit more.

[YIXINGISM]

Shinee's The Misconception of Us era is awesome, so I'm gonna go w/ SM.

 

 

oh and Suju M's Break Down too.

[김민주]

I liked Dream girl and IGaB title track wise and definitely like SM albums more as a whole.

[Lolita]

i just noticed the only korean album YG put out this year is lee hi's so far, slacking, hated both cl and gd's singles 

 

and i'd give it to SM for the best comeback, even though title tracks were questionable for the most part, comebacks were good

 

i think 15& and 2pm's comebacks were ok, forgettable though