OFFICIAL CRIME SCENE 3 THREAD

[cthchy]

Please give Eunji unnie chance this is her 1st time I think all cast have a same problem when joined this show for the 1st time not all cast is perfect..you make like just only Eunji unnie and yang seyoung its bit serious I think even hani and ns yoonji is also like Eunji unnie..beside of course she didn't want overboard bcoz she's naknae and still new if she's overboard ppl will said she's rude..

I think that Eunji was good in acting out her character realistically, probably because she's done quite a bit of acting herself? I think the main part that she was lacking in was the entertainment which must be there for variety shows. Probably because she's not too used to being on them? She definitely did try I guess (her and Jiyoon bickering) but other than that she seems fine

 

My own opinion :D

 

 

p.s. It's Yang Sehyung

 

Edited May 9, 2017 by cthchy

[PinkPandaForever]

I think that Eunji was good in acting out her character realistically, probably because she's done quite a bit of acting herself? I think the main part that she was lacking in was the entertainment which must be there for variety shows. Probably because she's not too used to being on them? She definitely did try I guess (her and Jiyoon bickering) but other than that she seems fine

My own opinion :D

 

p.s. It's Yang Sehyung

 

That why I said we need to give her chance beside in 2 ep she's not really well she's just good from her back pain and bad flu..and also when she's shooting the 2 ep she's still in her solo promoting..but she's still do the best,she still try to light up the situation like bickering with park ji yoon..until part when park ji yoon called "you're not pretty" became article..she's still success choose the right criminal with right deduction maybe she didn't want overboard bcoz she she still suit herself and she want respect her senior cast beside her character as naive Jung waitress of course she need to be naive..how can naive girl became over board..we need to see their character before we judge them..I said this not bcoz she's my bias but if we see from other side she's just bring her character as naive girl..

[orangescent]

I'm a new fan of crime scene. I finished watching the 2nd season this March, so I'm happy that I only have to wait 2 months for the 3rd season. I'm totally hooked on this show and it's so hard to conceal the excitement every time a new episode goes on air.

 

About the cast, as much as I'm impressed with jinho, dongmin and hani's performance, I'm fine with the changes. They might have scheduling conflicts or the PD just simply think new cast members will bring freshness to the show. From the first two episodes, jiyoon showed us how much of a veteran she is. She's great at portraying her characters and her deduction is always on point. Jang jin is very creative at connecting evidences and I think he's more open to different possibilities as last season there were times when he's too obsessed with his own theories that he failed to catch the criminal in the end.

 

 

Meanwhile, jihoon hasn't quite reach worker kim and sakarin-chan level, though maybe that's due to the role he was playing so far. He did try his best to drive the accusation towards jaerim but in the end the evidences against him were too strong. I believe he'll get better.

I love eunji so much and I'm overjoyed when she was announced as a permanent member. She was ill during the first episode and not very active but still managed to correctly deduce who the culprit was and how the victim was killed. She got a lot better in the second episode, both in her portrayal and reasoning. However, I think she still lack confidence to express her opinion. When the casts were debating about how the culprit would unlock the phone, she was the only one that realize about the use of the victim's fingerprint and even said that the password isn't important. I watched several variety show which she guested and I know she has a confident and straightforward personality, so I'm surprised to see her backed down so easily and not pushing her opinion forward. I sincerely hope hani would be on episode four so eunji could appear alongside her. I think it would help eunji to have someone around her age on the show.

Sehyung is smart but I'm curious about people's opinion on his casting. Did a lot of viewers in south korea oppose it? He seemed to be burdened a lot to give a good performance. Like he's worried people will give him bad comments on the internet. Being the only comedian, the expectation on him is to be witty, funny but clever at the same time. He do needs to loosened up a bit. Hopefully he'll do that in the coming episodes.

 

[cthchy]

 

 

I'm a new fan of crime scene. I finished watching the 2nd season this March, so I'm happy that I only have to wait 2 months for the 3rd season. I'm totally hooked on this show and it's so hard to conceal the excitement every time a new episode goes on air.

 

About the cast, as much as I'm impressed with jinho, dongmin and hani's performance, I'm fine with the changes. They might have scheduling conflicts or the PD just simply think new cast members will bring freshness to the show. From the first two episodes, jiyoon showed us how much of a veteran she is. She's great at portraying her characters and her deduction is always on point. Jang jin is very creative at connecting evidences and I think he's more open to different possibilities as last season there were times when he's too obsessed with his own theories that he failed to catch the criminal in the end.

 

 

Meanwhile, jihoon hasn't quite reach worker kim and sakarin-chan level, though maybe that's due to the role he was playing so far. He did try his best to drive the accusation towards jaerim but in the end the evidences against him were too strong. I believe he'll get better.

 

I love eunji so much and I'm overjoyed when she was announced as a permanent member. She was ill during the first episode and not very active but still managed to correctly deduce who the culprit was and how the victim was killed. She got a lot better in the second episode, both in her portrayal and reasoning. However, I think she still lack confidence to express her opinion. When the casts were debating about how the culprit would unlock the phone, she was the only one that realize about the use of the victim's fingerprint and even said that the password isn't important. I watched several variety show which she guested and I know she has a confident and straightforward personality, so I'm surprised to see her backed down so easily and not pushing her opinion forward. I sincerely hope hani would be on episode four so eunji could appear alongside her. I think it would help eunji to have someone around her age on the show.

 

Sehyung is smart but I'm curious about people's opinion on his casting. Did a lot of viewers in south korea oppose it? He seemed to be burdened a lot to give a good performance. Like he's worried people will give him bad comments on the internet. Being the only comedian, the expectation on him is to be witty, funny but clever at the same time. He do needs to loosened up a bit. Hopefully he'll do that in the coming episodes.

 

I finished both seasons in December so I didn't have to wait too long either but it made the lack of my favourite members more obvious :(

 

 

Maybe the characters/cases are the main problem? Both cases seemed to be quite easy and more straightforward than the cases in the second season (e.g Park Kangnam) and the characters don't seem to be that much more interesting either, just typical wife + mistress, conflict with partner kind of story so maybe they didn't have much to expand on.

 

I also agree with you on the fact that Eunji doesn't seem to be trying to push her stand much. Probably because she's the maknae and thus she's less outspoken here.

 

Sehyung does seem to be quite burdened, possibly because of viewers, since he was quite pressured when he failed to catch the culprit as a detective in ep 2. I personally enjoy watching him on shows such as Infinity Challenge so I was looking forward to him on the show but I think that this show is a different type compared to those he's normally on, leading to the lack of comedy on his side

 

[pretty_angel92]

I think that Eunji was good in acting out her character realistically, probably because she's done quite a bit of acting herself? I think the main part that she was lacking in was the entertainment which must be there for variety shows. Probably because she's not too used to being on them? She definitely did try I guess (her and Jiyoon bickering) but other than that she seems fine

 

My own opinion :D

 

 

p.s. It's Yang Sehyung

 

actually she appears in a lot of variety shows (the most in apink too)

she's pretty funny and entertaining. but for this show, i don't think it's 100% needed. i think the most important part is to stay in the character and solve the crimes, which is exactly what she's doing (and very well, i might say. cause we all know she's a good actress).

 

btw, the part where she said "please don't say such things, you'll scare the baby", was pretty clever and funny to me  

[snowdjinn]

i dont think the 2 new cases are easy to solve. They are the same difficulty as S2. Its just that JangJin tells us his thoughts and gives us the right hints. JiYoon adds her great sense and finds some of the most crucial hints. Obviously the players talk with each other before the voting...to unite their votes on 1 criminal.

 

JangJin and JiYoon are true master detectives now. They just make the cases look very easy.

Edited May 11, 2017 by snowdjinn

[wooupzi]

Honestly, I really didn't know who would be the criminal because I actually felt like the clues were not as decisive of course except the one that Jiyoon found but other than that nothing really was as decisive as the clues in the first episode. Another would be the motive, i guess since everyone was too focused on Jaerim, the other motives seemed to be weak for them and hence made me more confused. 

 

I just really got pissed off like at this one moment at Sehyung because he was just too focused on the person he thought was the actual criminal. I guess he needs to be more open-minded. I guess the other people in the thread already had the same sentiments as me and they already had them voiced out so I won't repeat it.

[abcxyzomg]

 

 

New promotional clip with NS Yoonji and Hani!

[noiha92]

 

 

New promotional clip with NS Yoonji and Hani!

hani looks prettier with long hair indeed <3

[Moon Gin]

Anticipating Yoonji and Hani next episode! 

[sly fox]

Ep 2 was much better than ep 1, I'm glad it's getting better. I really like Eunji but I'm really not feeling her in this show but it's only ep 2 so she still has room for improvement

YES NS YOONJI IS BACK

[abcxyzomg]

 

 

Role card choosing for next case. There is a little spoiler (not really criminal spoiler) about today's case so beware people!

Next guest is actor Kim Byungwook.

 

About today's ep:

 

 

Hani's hella entertaining lol. You do feel that the shooting is 1000x times livelier and funnier when Hani's there.

Today's case is kinda good. Many possible scenarios. There are a lot of evidences throwing here and there and target all the suspects. Only 1 person gets 0 votes today.

Jokes were throwing everywhere and they all did well in terms of acting.

 

 

Edited May 12, 2017 by abcxyzomg

[passerby]

off topic but.....

 

 

 

Isn't that sound like crime scene narrator?

[abcxyzomg]

Ep 3 engsub on kshowonline:

 

http://kshowonline.com/kshow/6809-[engsub]-crime-scene-3-ep.3

[Ager]

Ep 3 engsub on kshowonline:

 

http://kshowonline.com/kshow/6809-[engsub]-crime-scene-3-ep.3

The best ep. so far, laughed a lot, Sehyung was very good with Jiyoon. And yep, failed to guess the criminal

[wiaraewiwiarae]

[friendlyoldperson]

Please give Eunji unnie chance this is her 1st time I think all cast have a same problem when joined this show for the 1st time not all cast is perfect..you make like just only Eunji unnie and yang seyoung its bit serious I think even hani and ns yoonji is also like Eunji unnie..beside of course she didn't want overboard bcoz she's naknae and still new if she's overboard ppl will said she's rude.. This just 2ep and this is Eunji unnie and seyong 2nd appearances..but u make like both of them joined this show more than 2 times..of course original casted look better bcoz this is not their 1st time and they have more experience but for 2 ep Eunji unnie also success guess the right criminal..she also success to captured jang jin hidden camera when other cast didn't noticed it..

 

I'm sorry I didn't mean it that way. If I looked back, Hani is just hyperactive, but Eunji is like Yoonji back then. I mean, I'm talking about the screentime they both had. We know the PD edited so all of those hours footages can be summed into that 1.5 hours, so of course he/she chose the best footage that was really interesting to watch or relevant to the case. And as far as I watched, cmiiw, the screentime Eunji had wasn't that much compared to others.

 

We know that we watched a lot of Jang Jin / Jiyoon scenes because either when Jiyoon acted or Jang Jin deduced, that's what make them gain quite screentime. Maybe I'm also wrong to say that Eunji is quite passive, maybe that's not the way it was in the stage, but all we know is what we watch, what the PD edited. Her acting and deducing are great, no doubt. But in the process, interaction between the casts or while inspecting the crime scene, she should go all out, so she can get a lot of screentime. 

 

I'm saying this because I really love her, I want her to shine and appear more. 

 

==

 

Btw, here's my review, spoiler alert.

 

 

 

Damn, this case was really hard to tell. Not that much could be told from the crime scene. Also everyone had solid motives to kill. The staffs of the show really gave their best so it's not that easy to deduce. I really missed that fine from the bank book, didn't expect it. All of that time, the casts focus on people beside the actual culprit, meanwhile those people had very certain motives to kill. 

 

I wonder why they focused on motive too much instead of really investigating the actual crime scene. They just talked about the victim's tie just in the late time and that tie is the crucial and concrete evidence of the culprit. Jihoon really did a great job for noticing the size of the tie, eventhough in his last inspection chance. Sehyung too for noticing the bank book and concluding the case. 

 

Yoonji did a great job at hiding it. It's really advantageous of her that people beside her also have strong motive to kill. Also, the way Hani acted on the stage maybe made Yoonji quite relaxed. Not to forget that she's really experienced at acting as culprit. Too bad she wasn't really suspected, maybe we can see her crying acting again. 

 

Jangjin and Jiyoon failed at guessing the culprit, meanwhile Jihoon and Sehyung did guess with the concrete evidences. I really love the lovey-dovey scenes between Sehyung and Jiyoon. Dat DOTS ost tho. Also, the scenes where Jihoon frustated when Hani gave some hints to Jang Jin were really ridiculous. Hani, what can I describe, was like a wild dog. She's just hillarious and hyperactive as always. Overall, this is the best episode. We got a difficult case, and humour. Basically It's a really funny episode, indeed. 

 

Maybe the fact that because Yoonji and Hani had casted before also affected the show, since they're familiar with the setting and the casts. I just wish they, the staffs and casts, can keep it up. Also I hope Eunji can blend in more with the casts and the setting, so she doesn't need to be compared to Yoonji or Hani since they share the same background. There're still more cases to go, I'm sure she will do great. 

 

Oh my.. Detective Jung in the next episode..   It's funny that after she became a culprit (if she didn't have schedule), she becomes a detective after that  .

 

Also,

 

ODK should translate what's on the book or email or messages or else. Don't they know that's really crucial? Geez I miss Bumdy.

 

 

[Waves in the sand~~]

This episode was so complicated but it was better. I will say that it's the best. About the case:

 

I'm so mad, because I was going to watch the episode but before I was reading Twitter and I saw a allkpop's tweet about Crime Scene. I didn't read it but I have eyes. They put in the tweet a pic of NS Yoon-G with the fucking tie. Lsnskdkdkdnkwkskdkkeks

Click here to view the Tweet

 

I enjoyed the episode but knowing the criminal... :( Probably I would have said that the criminal was Park Recruit, but I already knew it.

Sehyung was funny and not so serious like the last time. I'm glad.

Hani funny as always.

 

[youngwonstarz]

i'm glad that sehyung loosen up today ep and i cringed at him & jiyoon lol *cover eyes*

oooh next week guest is known for being villian, that would be interesting

[snowdjinn]

EPISODE 3

 

Probably one of the best episodes of Crime Scene.

 

Its an interesting case and the players were very funny and entertaining. I laughed so much.

 

 

The Case / The Suspects / The murderer (my investigation while watching)

 

 

 

 

Very early, its superobvious that the 2002 murder case is very important for this case. Many hints point to it. Every player is somehow connected to it.

 

Recruit Park: took the photo (by pure luck) that will 15 yrs later proof that the wrong person was arrested. Yes, she had problems with the victim (sexual harassement, F) but there is no reason why she should murder him. The detective votes for her, because he thinks that its impossible for her to just make this photo by random luck. Why not JangJin ?   Obviously she is not the murderer.

 

Chief Yang: was a suspect in the old case. It was him, who names the person, who is then falsely arrested and put into prison. Once again, i see no reason why he should murder the victim. He was let go and someone else went to prison. There is no hint that he could have been the real murderer in 2002. That would have been the only reason for him to kill Prof Jung. i dont think he is the murderer.

 

Instructor Ha: is the sister of the man who was falsely arrested and send to prison for the 2002 murder. She freely admits that she tortured the victim and wanted information from him about the old case. If she is the murderer, she would have stayed to kill him. it doesnt make much sense, if she wanted to kill him, she could have done so immediately without going through all the trouble with the tazer and tape. Why should she get angry and suddenly kill him with the fire estinguisher ? No hints for this. Obviously not the murderer.

 

That only leaves the 2 prime suspects.

 

Principal Kim, Prof. Yoon and Prof. Jung are a corrupt trio !!! They all got promotion and success from the old case. Its clear that something shady and bad happened back then, when they did the investigation. They arrested the wrong person. (the spelling of the confession proofs it.) Why ?

 

Principal Kim: corrupt, he also admitted that he was in the room with the dead body to get the paper. Kind of suspicious. The first half of the episode, Principal Kim was my number 1 pick for the murderer. 66 minutes into the episode,  they find the paper and i am almost certain its Principal Kim. Everything points at him.

 

Prof. Yoon: when Yoon explains herself at the 71.minute of the episode, she says: "Principal Kim pressured us to find the murderer." (So he was just supervisor but not really involved in detail work!! That means he DID NOT mess up the 2002 case !!) And then Yoon continues: "Both Prof Jung and I were under huge stress because we could lose our jobs." She also admits that she knew the wrong person got arrested. From that moment on, i realized that the victim and Prof Yoon are the only 2 that are involved in the evil-doing in 2002 ..... If anyone had to silence Jung because of what happened during the 2002 investigation, it was the other evil-doer Prof Yoon. So  from that moment on, Prof Yoon was my pick for criminal. i had no idea about the details. i did NOT expect that Prof Yoon was also the murderer from 2002. I just picked her to be the murderer of her partner-in-crime Prof Jung.

 

So i didnt solve it, some of my deduction was messy..... but at least i found the right criminal.

 

 

 

 

The Players / Entertainment

 

 

 

 

Chief Yang is finally ACTING and doing some comedy. It still feels a little bit awkward and misplaced but its A LOT BETTER than before. Detective JangJin overanalyzed the case and goes after the wrong person. Sometimes he gets stucked with little details that he doesnt believe to be random (it also happened in S2 when he didnt believe that Teacher and Student dont know each other, the 2nd Cruise Ship Episode)   Jihoon improved a lot. Thats the Jihoon i know from S2 and that does a good work on Crime Scene. More of this please ! JiYoon is doing fine. Once again, her acting is perfect. NS-Yoon G doesnt shed any tears and seems very relaxed, even though she is the criminal. She did a great job in keeping a pokerface. She seems so innocent from how she acts and from her reactions. Well Done ! Hani is easily the best player in this episode. She steals the show and is talking a lot, screaming a lot, very outgoing and fun. i hope the new members learn from watching Hani in this episode. Thats how you do Crime Scene !

 

 

Edited May 14, 2017 by snowdjinn

[pan2cute]

well I really enjoyed episode 3 and I love how quirky and funny hani on yesterday episode
I hope she will be guest for another episode
 

and finally sehyung loosening... he's getting funny although still kinda awkward...

I'm quite happy with the case because its more complicated..

 

and hani yesterday reminds me gui gui (emma wu) on crime scene chinese a lot

she's loud, fun and being a police dog!!!

 

[Singsdoto]

I actually predicted that in ep 3 the criminal will be woman if it's not in ep 2. And there will be 1 more episode where the criminal will be woman.

[RoNNieTP]

Phew...barely (and surprisingly) guessing it right in this episode. Tough case, many little and distracting evidences but still 3 for 3 for me.

 

 

 

I form the story like what Jang Jin (and Snow) does. I imagine the motive of the culprit first and it's definitely about the 2002 case.

 

So the victim is the one who request the reinvestigation of the case, which means that the culprit is the one who will get a disadvantage by this. Who? Of course, it would be the real murderer!!! Which cuts Hani out from the list.

 

Also, Park Ji Yoon was only a witness of the case, she could be a murderer and fabricated the scene but she was the one who gave the evidence (2002 CD and the key) to the victim herself. It doesn't make sense if she is the muderer. So I also cuts Ji Yoon out.

 

Lastly Yang Se Hyung, a victim's boyfriend, could also be a murderer as well. But he also got tortured from the investigation too. If he is the real culprit, there is no way the police would let him escape from the crime and went as far as fabricated the DNA result for him, considering the police will get awarded for solving the case. And why would the victim reinvestigated the case again now if the culprit is Se Hyung. He has nothing to gain from it. This also cuts Se Hyung from suspect list which leaves...

 

2 police officers who also take charge of the case together with the victim; Chief Kim and Professor Yoon.

 

Kim Ji Hoon: He takes bribes, he corrupts, he could lose a job if the reinvestigation happens but he isn't a culprit. He just gave the order for the investigation in that case and wanted to end the case quickly and not more. He doesn't even know about fabricated DNA result at all. The murderer also left the key behind. If he was a murderer, he wouldn't sit down comfortably and gave the order from behind. He would do at any causes to find the key as soon as possible. So I don't think he is the murderer.

 

And now...

NS YoonG: She took charge and investigated the case with the victim which means she has the ability to fabricate the innocent. She and the victim are the only ones who know about it. The evidence about wrong information of the crime scene like the wrong address also makes me think that Professor Yoon must have something more to do with it. Then I started to think if it's possible that she is the real murderer? She has the motive to go back to the scene after dropping her key to find it, fabricate the DNA result. So even there aren't many conclusive evidence, I choose Professor Yoon in the end. The story is 95% accurate from what I think. The neck-tie clue is the one I miss. In the end, the god of deduction is still on my side. Cheers!!!

 

 

Yang Se Hyung is a lot better this episode, thanks to Park Ji Yoon who support him and I think he know that he need to loosen up and enjoy the case more. Still awkward but going in the right direction. Hani and Yoon G are the fresh air that we miss a lot. Sadly, Eunji isn't there. Hope she also loosen up more next week too.

 

Edit

 

Correct answer:

 

Jang Jin: 2/3

Park Ji Yoon: 2/3

Eun Ji: 2/2

Kim Ji Hoon: 2/2

Yang Se Hyung: 2/3

 

Money:

Guest: 4000

Jang Jin: 2000

Park Ji Yoon: 2000

Eun Ji: 2000

Kim Ji Hoon 1000

Yang Se Hyung 1000

Edited May 15, 2017 by RoNNieTP

[yeoto]

This episode was so good though!! Like I thought I knew who the culprit was and then I didn't and then I did and then I still guessed wrong because there was just so much kldjaghkajsdg I think this was one of my faves, it took off a little slow but once they started investigating I was actually so into it

 

 

I missed Hani on Crime Scene a lot and this episode just made me realize how much

[Zilihan]

Spoiler for season 2 and Episode 3

 

Did anyone realized that Jang Jin never get money whenever he become the detective? He has become detective 4 times. He choose the wrong suspects 3 times, and choose the right suspect 1 times (but the majority votes goes to the wrong suspect)

 

Lol. I don't know if it was a jinx or just some coincidence

 

Edited May 17, 2017 by Hiroid