Miniskirt(AOA) vs You Dont Love Me(Spica)

[snsdJM]

 

[Get The Job Done]

MINISKIRT>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[t-errorist]

AOA>>>>

 

i liked Spica's debut song better than this comeback tbh

[المروة]

miniskirt for all even though I thought the mv was a bit much, it was much better than YDLM

[snsdJM]

for me:

Song: Miniskirt this song has been my jam for weeks now

MV: I enjoy watching AOA's video more maybe because of the dance plus they all look really hot in the MV but I think Spica's video has better quality so I voted for spica in this

Choreography: MINISKIRT by far I love the dance on this

Group: AOA because of yuna

[Junkrat]

 

[kimchi]

YDLM

YDLM

MS

Spica

[Chunface]

you dont love me was the worst spica release compared to the past one like painkiller and tonight 

so its AoA miniskirt for me 

[Knee]

Miniskirt for all but I like SPICA more. Praying they come back again this year with a song I actually like. I wanna support them and I want them to do well so bad.

[Darling]

Ms

[A Boy Like Troy]

Definitely Miniskirt. I find myself jamming to that song every day. I am also in love with the dance routine. It starts on the floor, then standard dancing, and finally chairs. They really amaze me. I love it~

[Guitargeekette]

You Don't Love Me all around.

 

Musically, it was thought through. I can hear the influence of 60s girl groups,the concept, choreo and MV all are cohesive with that influence, plus the girls sang it well live and in studio. I need nothing more.

 

Miniskirt is good but I don't think it was as strategically thought out or inspired as You Don't Love Me was...plus the vocals aren't as strong.

[snsdJM]

lol at someone minusing about every single post in this thread, pluses people

[denizen mars]

I love AOA man, but You Don't Love Me >>>>>>>

[Ludark]

Song: Miniskirt

MV: Miniskirt, but not by much

Choreo: Miniskirt

Group: AOA

 

Honestly although I have always liked AOA better than Spica, I did really like their music in their debut year but I have been kinda disappointed with their releases since.

YDLM is no exception to this and honestly the good points of this comeback are spica's always good vocals, a better choreo than their previous releases(which is stil not that great), that silly butt pad gimmick and the chorus of their song.

But overall I just don't really like the song that much aside from the chorus and the vocals and it has failed to impress me. 

 

AOA's miniskirt might just be their best release since debut though, the song, the line distribution, the choreo, the mv, the lives all of it works

It's a great comeback in my opinion and the only thing I dislike about it is that it's a rather generic sexy concept rather than the stuff they did prior to 'Confused'.

[Buns]

Miniskirt

You Don't Love Me 

Miniskirt

AOA ARE THE QUEENS OF NUGU 

[RiCardenasZ]

Song: Miniskirt

MV: You Don't Love Me

Choreo: Miniskirt

Group: SPICA

 

Although You Don't Love Me is amazing, I just can't get Miniskirt out of my head   Am I the only one who loves the blonde short-haired girl? The one who sings the first high note and is in the front during a part of the chorus and then goes back... when I watched their lives and saw her walking back to her position I could only say YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS WERK THAT YASS because... damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn she be getting it   

 

I like SPICA better in general, they always showcase their powerful vocals on and offstage   Therefore, I voted for them

[A Boy Like Troy]

Song: Miniskirt

MV: You Don't Love Me

Choreo: Miniskirt

Group: SPICA

 

Although You Don't Love Me is amazing, I just can't get Miniskirt out of my head   Am I the only one who loves the blonde short-haired girl? The one who sings the first high note and is in the front during a part of the chorus and then goes back... when I watched their lives and saw her walking back to her position I could only say YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS WERK THAT YASS because... damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn she be getting it   

 

I like SPICA better in general, they always showcase their powerful vocals on and offstage   Therefore, I voted for them

 

Short blonde hair= Main Vocalist Choa

[Chunface]

lol at someone minusing about every single post in this thread, pluses people

someone is bitter 

[SunnyHill's Comeback]

Spica for everything except choreo

[catmincer]

Spica for all 4.

 

I like AOA's video though ;)

 

I can't do AOA as I hate their rapper, she ruins their songs.

[~ PD Hercule Poirot ~]

Miniskirt for all

 

Since I'm new to this two groups, I'm going to vote for AOA since I like all - song, MV and choreo

 

Spica have great vocalists though...just need a better song / cb

[CaraSiorai]

I like both songs pretty equally.

You Don't Love Me MV is better.

Neither choreo is good but maybe MS is a little less meh?

I like Spica more in general.

[pretty_angel92]

AOA for all

but i love Spica too

[anh.]

Miniskirt

You Don't Love Me

You Don't Love Me

SPICA