Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing ~ Read Only Starting Dec. 20th ~ Shutdown Dec. 25th ×
OneHallyu

♥ Right Now, Tomorrow, Forever, 소녀시대 ♥ The Official Girls' Generation (SNSD) Thread

Yuri

By Yuri
in Groups

 Share

Please choose.  

4,108 members have voted

  1. 1. Favorite SNSD Member

    • Seohyun
      724
    • Yoona
      860
    • Sooyoung
      639
    • Yuri
      621
    • Hyoyeon
      610
    • Tiffany
      738
    • Sunny
      566
    • Jessica
      958
    • Taeyeon
      1240

Recommended Posts

Messica Global Superstar

Messica

5,468
Posted
Posted

No is not wrong to criticized her, what's wrong she is the only one who gets nitpicked for everything.

BS if anyone read the comments in the youtube video of call me maybe , she got many good comments but

you come here and the only comments are: she "was pitchy"  "why did she choose to sing that song?" and many

other comments that were about her personal taste in music and not about her singing.

 

"that being said, we criticize Tiffany for doing things above her ability, but we praise her for her effort and ambition and will for such difficulty."

 

In what part of what you wrote you praise Tiffany for her effort:

 

"her voice colour yes, but the song was butchering her vocal chords. She couldn't get all the high belts and had to switch to

falsetto often, and I could tell she was having quite difficulty in actually most of the high notes, except for in the beginning she

did fine. This is going to damage her voice. I actually feel worried for Tiffany.

 

should have went to Jessica or Taeyeon."

 

Yeah right, Let's give all the songs to Jessica and Taeyeon we don't want poor Tiffany to get sick again, your transparency is

not even funny, you only added the "praise" after I told you that the majority in here neither enjoys or support her efforts. 

 

And let's not forget "sones" comments about the Fashion King cast. I am sure IF when Hyoyeon

was given the Topshop endorsement I would have said:

Hyoyeon for Topshop, in China, why? when I think for a model for a fashion line , I think Jessica or Yoona,

especially in China where they are more popular.

IF I had written this kind comment not only Hyoyeon would have been defended but nobody else would have

been so fast to agree with my comment.

But you know what it is OK but don't complain later when I begin to give "constructive criticism" to your faves.

its not about that Tiffany should never sing. She should just not sing songs that are way above her comfort range. The thing about Jessica and Taeyeon is that they usually sing within their comfort range. I would not have said the same if Tiffany sang a song within her comfort range or at least within that relative area. I don't care if you criticize my bias. If you've been in the fandom long enough, Jessica was actually the punching bag within the fandom. There's nothing wrong with criticizing the members of your Stan group. No one is hating or bashing Tiffany, NO ONE HERE HATES TIFFANY.

 

IM BEING SERIOUS HERE, I WAS NOT BEING TRANSPARENT AT ALL. You got to see the logical reasons behind that post than just putting on your defend my bias mode. As for hyoyeon, you can't decide on the difficulty of a visual career, where as in a vocal career it is much the other way. Also, no one would join you because hyoyeon barely gets promoted, and its a nice change that all sones would like to see.

  • Like 9
  • Dislike 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 179.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • pretty_angel92

    5255

  • Lenalee

    5109

  • VedaSONE

    4795

  • black_pearl

    3198

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

Yuri
Yuri

DYSEQTA
DYSEQTA

Can't say I agree. The version with Jessica just reinforced for me that SNSD without Jesssica's unique vocal timbre just isn't right. Jessica may not have been the main vocal but her voice is key in d

MoshiMoshi
MoshiMoshi

This.   Gonna rant for a second so feel free to skip.   The most frustrating thing to me is that SM never seems to learn. Either that or they just don't care. The fact that SNSD has been able to s

Messica Global Superstar

Messica

5,468
Posted
Posted (edited)

Really ? O_o but it's the truth, everytime she's doing something, some OH sone say other SNSD members should do it instead of her ,like for fashion king

"Though Jessica would have suited the show more..."

"no offense to tiffany but...if we're talking about fashion, they should have had jessica in this show instead of her."

"I mean Tiffany does have a good fashion sense (at times), but Jessica would've been a better choice"

"Should've been casted queen Jessica/Sooyoung "

 

You don't see coms like "Yoona should do the drama instead of Seohyun"but for Tiff...yeah

 

+ if she did something "wrong" she always get bashed (remember SNSD Jakarta concert) etc...

 

Anyway, I'm glad that for once Tiffany fans said something about that

 

BXnOMg1CcAAVU5e.png:largeBXnPJLZCEAAtz4y.png:large

I'm actually happy she got that. I live watching her on tv. Jessica and Taeyeon gets bashed for their dancing as well, I think people just saw that it got tired and just called it cute. I don't think people were really bashing her. She was lazy and that was the truth =/= bashing. Her being lazy is nothing to be upset about really. Tbh, out of all the main vocals, Jessica gets criticized the most for her nasality. I don't think its jealousy, but sometimes in the vocal career, Jessica is not used to her potential as of late, where as Tiffany as been comparably daring, and sometimes beyond her potential. I mean really Tiffany? Pulling F#5s and above, like a freakin G#5? Jessica and taeyeon are still strain galore on the E5s, let alone Jessica on her D5s. Tbh, even Jessica should never sing above an E5 until further notice

 

maybe people just overreact because Tiffany is one of the most hardworking people in snsd. That is why she is my biggest role model.

 

actually if you've been in the fandom long enough. Jessica was the punching bag of the fandom.

 

 

but yeah, I don't really know why people hate on Tiffany. There's no reason to hate her at all.

Edited by Bringthesnacksout
  • Like 2
  • Dislike 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites
exists Star

exists

1,497
Posted
Posted (edited)

actually if you've been in the fandom long enough. Jessica was the punching bag of the fandom.

 

 

but yeah, I don't really know why people hate on Tiffany. There's no reason to hate her at all.

I've been in the fandom since 2009 and no Jessica isn't the fandom's punching bag. It used to be Yoona even if she hasn't made any slip ups. Nowadays it's Tiffany and Taeyeon, because of their Taeny fans, because Taeyeon is mean to Jessica, and other shallow reasons. When Jessica's lazy people defend her for it, when she pulls a bitchy face people say she's not like that, when she's blunt fans will defend her for just saying that's her 'queen' personality. I know her personality isn't like her stoic face and I'm glad that many fans including those who aren't just Jessica fans defend her because from fanaccounts etc she is a sweet nice girl. But damn, one occasion of Tiffany not giving her best resulted into pages and pages of insults and how she's not passionate enough. Her personality is loud and outgoing and yet people seem to condemn her for that. She's one of the members with many fanaccounts saying how nice and approachable she is in real life yet fans still say she's a bitch and attention whore for being all smiles. 

 

Also fashion is something visual yet many seems to think Tiffany isn't cut out for it, when in fact if anyone watched Factory Girl she's one of the most hardworking member in those episodes. So no the visual isn't something technical excuse didn't stop from people taking a jab at Tiffany.  

 

And yes I agree with Lenalee I'm glad some Tiffany fans are starting to be vocal about this. Who knows how much longer this unnecessary 'should have been' type of comments will last even after we've voiced out our dislike. I'll end my rant here.

Edited by exists
  • Like 19
  • Dislike 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Messica Global Superstar

Messica

5,468
Posted
Posted (edited)

I've been in the fandom since 2009 and no Jessica isn't the fandom's punching bag. It used to be Yoona even if she hasn't made any slip ups. Nowadays it's Tiffany and Taeyeon, because of their Taeny fans, because Taeyeon is mean to Jessica, and other shallow reasons. When Jessica's lazy people defend her for it, when she pulls a bitchy face people say she's not like that, when she's blunt fans will defend her for just saying that's her 'queen' personality. I know her personality isn't like her stoic face and I'm glad that many fans including those who aren't just Jessica fans defend her because from fanaccounts etc she is a sweet nice girl. But damn, one occasion of Tiffany not giving her best resulted into pages and pages of insults and how she's not passionate enough. Her personality is loud and outgoing and yet people seem to condemn her for that. She's one of the members with many fanaccounts saying how nice and approachable she is in real life yet fans still say she's a bitch and attention whore for being all smiles.

 

Also fashion is something visual yet many seems to think Tiffany isn't cut out for it, when in fact if anyone watched Factory Girl she's one of the most hardworking member in those episodes. So no the visual isn't something technical excuse didn't stop from people taking a jab at Tiffany.

 

And yes I agree with Lenalee I'm glad some Tiffany fans are starting to be vocal about this. Who knows how much longer this unnecessary 'should have been' type of comments will last even after we've voiced out our dislike. I'll end my rant here.

Jessica stopped being the punching bag until genie actually. But in all honesty, has anyone said that Tiffany's performance sucked rather than just outlining her difficulty in execution?

I mean despite that, I don't think she sucked. In fact I still enjoyed it.

 

I know about the visual thing. Its just that documentary was saying that about hyoyeon in response to who would do it better. But wait? Tiffany was bashed for her factory girl work in NY? That's horrible.

Edited by Bringthesnacksout
Link to comment
Share on other sites
soshi.mp3 Superstar

soshi.mp3

1,621
Posted
Posted

I prefer you singled me out than all maomaos. I was criticizing Tiffany not as a pressed Jessica Stan jsuk. I'm also a Tiffany Stan.

I was not referring to you btw (Seriously i'm being honest)

 

I was referring to some of the Jessica stans in this forum only, and i'm not saying they are bad i'm just saying they often have a "bad behaviour" when it comes to defending Jessica.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Messica Global Superstar

Messica

5,468
Posted
Posted

I was not referring to you btw (Seriously i'm being honest)

 

I was referring to some of the Jessica stans in this forum only, and i'm not saying they are bad i'm just saying they often have a "bad behaviour" when it comes to defending Jessica.

ohk thanks then. Honestly I thought you were referring to me lol. :)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

 Accept Cookies  Reject Cookies
Back to Top