Should the members who can't sing get less lines?

[Pinkstar]

The line distribution in kpop is a very hot topic, there is an endless arguing within fandoms

on who should be getting more lines. A lot of fans seem to believe that everyone should

get equal lines meaning 'fair' line distribution. Some fans believe that 'fair' line distribution

should mean that those who sing/rap better should rightfully get more lines.

 

What do you think?

[peppermint]

Definitely the first option. If not, what's the use of having a main vocal 

[kw_]

It doesn't really make sense to me to add a member and then barely let them sing. I say, just make the song have lines that those members can carry

[StepOnMeJas]

It depends on the song, imo.

[sickwithsin]

All I know is that Ahn Jaehyo deserves more.

[pretty_angel92]

well, obviously

 

that's why we have main and lead vocals

[Posy‪ℓuv]

Of course lead and main vocals should have more lines (+rappers)!That's why they're the main and lead singers!

 

Members who are stronger at dancing normally get more time in the centre/at the front instead

 

All members should get their time to shine in a song depending on their strengths!

[PurachinaDisuko]

Let them sing. They will get better with practice. While they aren't getting lines, they can work harder on their singing voice and their dancing ability.

[Ichigo]

Definitely the first option. If not, what's the use of having a main vocal 

[Ginger91]

What's the point of even having a member that can't sing? But then again my own ult bias couldn't sing at debut. Idk

[smOOch]

I can't believe there are some who voted for the 2nd option.  

[vasco da gama]

It doesn't really make sense to me to add a member and then barely let them sing. I say, just make the song have lines that those members can carry

^^^^

[í™©ì œë‹˜ 팬]

i don't believe in "fair distribution" tbh.. 

[RACIE]

It should always be equal. One may not be as good as the other. But I think those who are weak singers tend to balance the strength of the voices of the group as a whole. Too strong or too weak type of music can get boring or irritating. It should always be balanced and the lines should be equally distributed.

[GRISHA - A Yoonbin Stan]

Screw equal line distribution. The song I want to listen to should be the best version possible they can release which means the better singers and rappers getting more lines.

[tkc123]

yes! I care about the quality of the song

 

when people complain about their favs getting very little lines...but your fav can't sing...

 

they're probably happy they don't get that many lines

 

line distributions aren't meant to be equal since there'd be no point of having a main vocal/lead vocal/rapper

 

just give them more MV screentime instead

[Ddeona Oneul Bame]

Who are you to decide that someone can't sing and shouldn't lines? 

[lunakitten]

Everyone should sing but those better at singing or rapping should get more lines and those better at dancing should get the main dance parts and visuals should be near the centre / be the centre during the main focal parts of the songs. That's how it should work.

[heyheyheyheyhey]

main vocals should sing the most. I'm tired of hearing so much of xiumin and kais voices

[Pinkstar]

Who are you to decide that someone can't sing and shouldn't lines? 

 

But I didn't? It's just a question 

[bbh]

Main vocals should get most of the lines.

Now we got Kai out here ruining EXO songs because fans complain about line distribution. There is a reason some members don't get a lot of lines..

[feel it yum]

Songs especially title tracks should show the best of what the group can offer to non fans.

Main vocals/rappers should show their potential in singing/rapping through the songs.

Main dancers through performance.

Visuals usually go into acting so they also have to be in the centre position more than main vocal/rapper/dancer to let people notice their visuals.

 

People debut in idol groups because it is harder to start off in the industry as a solo. Normally companies will make sure all the members gets to shine through the thing they are strongest in.

[coreofsoul]

I think that they should get less lines tbh. 

 

The best singers getting the most lines is no different from the best dancer getting the most time front and center in the dances.

[seraph]

i guess it depends on the song

when there's a part the member who cant sing can sing it easily, i doesn't really make sense when the company gives that line to the main vocal or vice versa when they already have like 50 seconds of the song 

[deobizone]

its better than them ruining songs