Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

This SM Station single and this particular K-pop girl group's last comeback EDM tracks are the type of music the world needs!

Ash-Pikachu

By Ash-Pikachu
in Music

Recommended Posts

Ash-Pikachu Legend

Ash-Pikachu

51,270
Posted
Posted

"All Mine"'s a total jam, ya'll.


 


f(x) has bloomed musically over time.


 



 


Let's bow our heads before the soon-to-be a full-fledged director Amber, A.K.A f(x)'s rapper.


For directing and editing the M/V masterpiece.


 


It sounds and look simple but certainly wasn't a breeze to accomplish the task, I tell you.


 


 


Leaving that aside, I also listen to "4 Walls" sometimes if not often, the title track f(x) presented to their MeUs (the fandom that had to wait years to get themselves a name by SM but who cares, patience is a virtue) after a long hiatus, the sound of which is rather similar to "All Mine".


 



 


Seeing the success "4 Walls" brought.....


Wonder if its musical style is the concrete base used for "All Mine" production?


 


I would not be surprised if it's true.


 


 


|★| Note: God bless the Queen of China, Victoria, and princess Krystal whose beauty has no boundaries!


 


Link to comment
Share on other sites
Seulgibear♥ Star

Seulgibear♥

2,716
Posted
Posted

All Mine is currently #68 melon  :donthinkso: and 4 Walls wasnt successful 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ｔ�ｅ�Ｓｅｕｌ Superstar

Ｔ�ｅ�Ｓｅｕｌ

2,342
Posted
Posted

4 walls SAVED kpop

I wouldnt say saved kpop because that term is overly used. It was a really nice song though, nice to see them doing different concepts every time they comeback! Love your sig by the way, Nana is beautiful! 4 walls has the same vibe as View by SHINee. I sort of like the direction of music that SM producers are going towards but I feel at the same time they are using EDM too much xD Not that I mind but people would start complaining.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Llamaber Global Superstar

Llamaber

3,052
Posted
Posted

 

4Walls is 2nd highest 1st week sales of Girl Groups w/ 66k while the single went #2 on Gaon. :donthinkso:

This ^

 

Also, the OP was talking about music, not numbers. Why are antis talking about numbers lmao. I guess they can't nitpick on the songs, because they're actually good. Stay pressed that f(x) has so many great bops.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
oddisland Debutee

oddisland

141
Posted
Posted

All Mine is currently #68 melon  :donthinkso: and 4 Walls wasnt successful 

we are not talking about charts here, honey. :derp:

 

 

4 Walls is a song i won't get tired of listening to tbh. one of the best k-pop songs i've heard in years. and All Mine is really a summer bop. really refreshing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
krysbian Superstar

krysbian

3,846
Posted
Posted

KOR: 619,022

 

??? That's good? Average at best, but really low for a top-tier group.

 

 

There, I did the research for you

 

"The release peaked atop South Korea's Gaon Album Chart and has sold over 76,000 physical copies in the country as of January 2016 (released in october); in addition, 4 Walls topped the Billboard World Albums Chart and charted at number thirty-nine on the Japanese Oricon Albums Chart. The single "4 Walls", meanwhile, peaked at numbers two on the Gaon Digital Chart and the Billboard World Digital Songs.

It also received favorable reviews from music critics like Jeff Benjamin from Billboard and Jakob Dorof on behalf of Pitchfork Media who described it as "sophisticated and innovative" and an album that could "signal a surprise second life for the world's greatest living pop group"

 
And that was their first combeback after Sulli's departure, everyone was saying they'll fail miserably and won't sell their albums or might even disband, but they proved them all wrong. So no, that's not what you call a flop, but hey, whatever helps you sleep at night.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Llamaber Global Superstar

Llamaber

3,052
Posted
Posted

There, I did the research for you

 

"The release peaked atop South Korea's Gaon Album Chart and has sold over 76,000 physical copies in the country as of January 2016 (released in october); in addition, 4 Walls topped the Billboard World Albums Chart and charted at number thirty-nine on the Japanese Oricon Albums Chart. The single "4 Walls", meanwhile, peaked at numbers two on the Gaon Digital Chart and the Billboard World Digital Songs.

It also received favorable reviews from music critics like Jeff Benjamin from Billboard and Jakob Dorof on behalf of Pitchfork Media who described it as "sophisticated and innovative" and an album that could "signal a surprise second life for the world's greatest living pop group"

 

And that was their first combeback after Sulli's departure, everyone was saying they'll fail miserably and won't sell their albums or might even disband, but they proved them all wrong. So no, that's not what you call a flop, but hey, whatever helps you sleep at night.

Sis, you should know by now that haters will not do their research and talk bs straight from their ignorant mouth. And once they're exposed, they will find another excuse, absolutely petty lmao.

 

Anyway, because we're talking about music, thank you for including the music critics' review. That's what really matters for this thread. That f(x) has been coming out with bops and albums that are critically acclaimed by actual professionals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Seulgibear♥ Star

Seulgibear♥

2,716
Posted
Posted

4 walls was a flop. MeU have to accept the truth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

 Accept Cookies  Reject Cookies
Back to Top