Do you trust Kpop Mr Removed Videos???

[👑A.M👑]

Some of the videos sounds the same...

[ethereal]

no. it's just a way to tell who's actually singing live imo. not a way of truly seeing how well they sing. most are too distorted anyway.

[SGT]

no.

[Danee]

Only when my bias slay.

[TYYB1988]

Most of them are too distorted to tell how good the singing actually is, but it's a good way to tell who's lipsyncing. 

[Tee]

no. it's just a way to tell who's actually singing live imo. not a way of truly seeing how well they sing. most are too distorted anyway.

 

Vocals may also be prerecorded as well, although when I'm suspicious of that, I probably wouldn't bother watching an MR removed video anyways... Actually Idk. I'ma have to pay attention to that in the future.

[Aearom]

I trust them when my bias sounds good, not when he sounds bad.

[pelusa]

No

[puellarum generatio]

no, i just trust what i hear

[Solfa]

No, there is a technical reason why they don't work the way they are supposed to work (INB4 the tone of the article hurt my feewings therefore I refuse to use logic). This is the most important (non-technical) element that makes MR Removed videos so popular

 

MR removed videos have just become a tool for either praising your bias to the skies or bashing whoever it is you don’t like...and reveal basically nothing of insight.

[酒�]

trust on what? they show me who's singing even in the chorus. the quality is questionable so idt they can be used for evaluating one's singing

[11:11]

Not really...

[nedenben]

I don't trust them but I love watching them too... Anyways watch this Mr Removed juseyo

 

 

[Shhhhh]

Sometimes.

But I've seen videos where they made my favs sound terrible on purpose. Like not even slightly similar to the original vid. They usually do that to Sehun just to 'prove' he 'cant sing'.

 

ALL of EXO can sing. Watch this:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXxcxziDgi4

[Clay]

MR removed videos exist because of that sickness fans have of 'my bias sings live' and because others try to hate on idols by saying they 'cant sing live' so this whole MR removed mess emerged. The problem is that it really isn't reliable, it's too distorted and, when it doesn't sound distorted, it mainly is because there's a recording that isn't fully removed or not even removed lol, not that 'my bias swallowed the CD wow slay', because you can't perfectly separate human live vocals than all the jeez audio/sonor effect going around in a stage performance.

Other than that it proves nothing, legit nothing about how nice a vocalist is, it just tells you if they're lipsychronising or not, which is futile to an extent because it's not even hard to distiguinsh if someone is lipsyncing or not just by the actual video, and the fact that they're singing live has NOTHING TO DO WITH AN IDOL'S VOCAL SKILL.

 

MR removed videos should disappear, that trend should die ngl.

[baiichi]

I used to but now, no. 

 

I'd rather my biases to go on singing shows that don't edit their voice too much. It'd be fairer. 

[flowerfenika]

Only when my bias slay.

[Counting Pulses]

Sometimes they're edited to make the voices sound better.

But I completely trust my faves. Their studio versions and live versions sound exactly the same, so I got nothing to worry about.