This was when (K)B2uties speculated that Hyunseung is leaving BEAST

[mistressnicey]

As you all know there has been some obvious distance between him and the rest of the group for the past couple years after his dad passed. His SNS barely mentions anything about any member of Beast, the only ones I can think of was a birthday greeting for Doojoon and maybe Dongwoon iirc.

 

The biggest speculation is that it is Junhyung and Hyunseung who seem to have a bad relationship with each other and you barely see them interact or even look at each other but on Hyunseung's birthday last year, Junhyung was the first one to greet him on Instagram and that was the first member's birthday in a while where ALL members greeted the birthday celebrant on SNS. (For the record, Junhyung rarely if not never greeted anyone on SNS since 2012 iirc so when he did, everyone was surprised especially since it's Hyunseung.)

 

(I'm lazy to post all their birthday posts.)

 

The most unexpected of all was Hyunseung's birthday post.

 

 

#비스트 #BEAST #윤ë‘준 #장현승 #용준형 #양요섭 #ì´ê¸°ê´‘ #ì†ë™ìš´ #그리고여러분 #ë·°í‹° #행복한ìƒì¼ #ê°ì‚¬í•©ë‹ˆë‹¤

 

#Biseuteu #BEAST #Yoondoojoon #Janghyunseung #Yongjunhyung #Yangyoseob #LeeKikwang #SonDongwoon

#Everyone #B2uty #HappyBirthday #Thankyou

 

This was the very first post of his that mentioned Beast like that.

 

K-b2uties speculated that this was a farewell party or something like that. This was a couple days before his absence in the fanmeeting btw.

 

On top of that, the aura during their last Seoul concert was sort of sad... Let's watch their You performance that time.

 

[The_Vixen]

Oohh so he left or he just leave because the was (by himself or not) kinda outcast

[tkc123]

I used to follow trouble maker's promotions a lot and I always heard how he was a bit distant from the rest of beast? I didn't find it that believable at the time since he seemed really happy in TM...but it seems like I was wrong. I heard plenty of other rumours too...

 

I hope things get better for him.

[mistressnicey]

Oohh so he left or he just leave because the was (by himself or not) kinda outcast

 

Cube did say differences in music opinions and personality. The other members are quite the outgoing type and sociable whereas he is an introvert for the most part I guess.

[Ace2GK]

 

As you all know there has been some obvious distance between him and the rest of the group for the past couple years after his dad passed. His SNS barely mentions anything about any member of Beast, the only ones I can think of was a birthday greeting for Doojoon and maybe Dongwoon iirc.

 

The biggest speculation is that it is Junhyung and Hyunseung who seem to have a bad relationship with each other and you barely see them interact or even look at each other but on Hyunseung's birthday last year, Junhyung was the first one to greet him on Instagram and that was the first member's birthday in a while where ALL members greeted the birthday celebrant on SNS. (For the record, Junhyung rarely if not never greeted anyone on SNS since 2012 iirc so when he did, everyone was surprised especially since it's Hyunseung.)

 

(I'm lazy to post all their birthday posts.)

 

The most unexpected of all was Hyunseung's birthday post.

 

 

#비스트 #BEAST #윤ë‘준 #장현승 #용준형 #양요섭 #ì´ê¸°ê´‘ #ì†ë™ìš´ #그리고여러분 #ë·°í‹° #행복한ìƒì¼ #ê°ì‚¬í•©ë‹ˆë‹¤

 

#Biseuteu #BEAST #Yoondoojoon #Janghyunseung #Yongjunhyung #Yangyoseob #LeeKikwang #SonDongwoon

#Everyone #B2uty #HappyBirthday #Thankyou

 

This was the very first post of his that mentioned Beast like that.

 

K-b2uties speculated that this was a farewell party or something like that. This was a couple days before his absence in the fanmeeting btw.

 

On top of that, the aura during their last Seoul concert was sort of sad... Let's watch their You performance that time.

 

 

 

 

 

Do you have the video of yoseob crying at this concert?

 

nvm, I found it

 

[Belle.]

I am just crying while watching their last BS

I am out of words

 

The relation between him and other members? I doubt it is the reason

Maybe he just decided to leave so he won't hurt them anymore

 

It's really unfair ........

[Vogue]

I hope everything gets better for him and his former group.

[mistressnicey]

Do you have the video of yoseob crying at this concert?

 

nvm, I found it

 

 

I was actually looking for that too but just settled with the group perf...

[mistressnicey]

I am just crying while watching their last BS

I am out of words

 

The relation between him and other members? I doubt it is the reason

Maybe he just decided to leave so he won't hurt them anymore

 

It's really unfair ........

 

It's up to each of us to think what we want. I have my own speculations and so are you. As someone who has closely followed them for a couple years, I thought their relationship was deteriorating. As a big JunSeung shipper, there was obviously a difference from when they used to be close and when they weren't... at least to me.

 

I've gone through it in 2013 and I was just holding on hoping they'd last another day, another month, another comeback as 6 since then coz I always had that gut feeling inside me that it was coming. This is why I cherished every time they came back as 6 after Shadow. I never bashed Yey nor Ordinary era coz I remembered telling my B2uty friends that you'll never know what will happen and that it may have been their last OT6 comeback...

 

When that IG post happened and everything else that came with it... I already had a bad feeling about it. It was like a fanservice from them in some sort of way and their last display of that OT6 bond, whatever was left of it. If knetz and akgae fans just left Hyunseung alone since then, their separation could have been delayed until their contracts expire and we might have gotten a last OT6 comeback and a better way to release such news without hurting Hyunseung and the group but ofc they had to witch hunt him.

[SJK]

When that IG post happened and everything else that came with it... I already had a bad feeling about it. It was like a fanservice from them in some sort of way and their last display of that OT6 bond, whatever was left of it.

 

Wow. That's both beautiful and heartbreaking. 

[monologue]

People who aren't fans, this is the kind of stuff we were talking about when we said that fans have been holding it in for a while now (like 2013 or even 2012 for some people). I guess now it's ok to talk about it

[mistressnicey]

People who aren't fans, this is the kind of stuff we were talking about when we said that fans have been holding it in for a while now (like 2013 or even 2012 for some people). I guess now it's ok to talk about it

 

Pretty much. I avoided talking about it in public coz it feels like if I did, the chances of it becoming true will increase...

[Belle.]

It's up to each of us to think what we want. I have my own speculations and so are you. As someone who has closely followed them for a couple years, I thought their relationship was deteriorating. As a big JunSeung shipper, there was obviously a difference from when they used to be close and when they weren't... at least to me.

 

I've gone through it in 2013 and I was just holding on hoping they'd last another day, another month, another comeback as 6 since then coz I always had that gut feeling inside me that it was coming. This is why I cherished every time they came back as 6 after Shadow. I never bashed Yey nor Ordinary era coz I remembered telling my B2uty friends that you'll never know what will happen and that it may have been their last OT6 comeback...

 

When that IG post happened and everything else that came with it... I already had a bad feeling about it. It was like a fanservice from them in some sort of way and their last display of that OT6 bond, whatever was left of it. If knetz and akgae fans just left Hyunseung alone since then, their separation could have been delayed until their contracts expire and we might have gotten a last OT6 comeback and a better way to release such news without hurting Hyunseung and the group but ofc they had to witch hunt him.

Of course, we will never know, and I guess it's better....

 

Maybe I wasn't there in that time, since I am following them since 2012, but I think I know enough, I know their relationship isn't the same I was aware all this time, and while knowing that I still defeded them everytime until the last minute, cuz I know and you know their relationship isn't that weak or just a group members relationship, they cried together and they laughed together, and Hyunseung as well as Junhyung aren't thoughtless,

Hyunseung wasn't the same and things became more obvious by time I totally saw it, I was looking after all little details to have hope, in the interviews, in their performances and I felt so down when his solo album wasn't produced by JH,

I was aware of everything happened, still I was taking hope from the little things

I wouldn't imagine and I still can't believe it

Or understand why

But the only thing I want to believe, the reason I first became A b2uty at first, nothing can change their hearts toward eachother

Whether it's right or wrong, I just want to believe so

 

Looking back, I don't know who to blame

I used to blame cube, nitezins, fans and antifans

But now I don't know anymore

[mistressnicey]

Of course, we will never know, and I guess it's better....

 

Maybe I wasn't there in that time, since I am following them since 2012, but I think I know enough, I know their relationship isn't the same I was aware all this time, and while knowing that I still defeded them everytime until the last minute, cuz I know and you know their relationship isn't that weak or just a group members relationship, they cried together and they laughed together, and Hyunseung as well as Junhyung aren't thoughtless,

Hyunseung wasn't the same and things became more obvious by time I totally saw it, I was looking after all little details to have hope, in the interviews, in their performances and I felt so down when his solo album wasn't produced by JH,

I was aware of everything happened, still I was taking hope from the little things

I wouldn't imagine and I still can't believe it

Or understand why

But the only thing I want to believe, the reason I first became A b2uty at first, nothing can change their hearts toward eachother

Whether it's right or wrong, I just want to believe so

 

Looking back, I don't know who to blame

I used to blame cube, nitezins, fans and antifans

But now I don't know anymore

 

You don't have to blame anyone.

 

I think we should all just accept that people grow, people change and it's inevitable. I would like to believe Cube, Beast and Hyunseung did try to save the group since 2013 (that was the year I was actually expecting disbandment after all Yoseob and Doojoon talking about how Beast only exist because of B2uties and somehow those words seemed really genuine and not just fanservice) until it can't be saved (as 6) anymore. Regarding the controversies, Cube prob didn't think much of it when it was just going around on Pann since I remembered CLC's attitude controversies, Cube really didn't do anything about that. It was only when an article was released that it got out of hand but, to me, I can't really blame Cube 100% on how it ended up that way.

[TenSixteen]

Completely agree on the aura surrounding the last Beautiful Show. I think they knew by then that it could be their last large-scale solo concert as six. Yoseob being the most emotionally shaken is a huge pointer. I'm fairly sure he cherishes and values the 'group' more than anyone else in Beast. It's even more understandable when we consider it was Yoseob who helped Hyunseung get into Cube Ent./Beast 

[WanGon]

You don't have to blame anyone.

 

I think we should all just accept that people grow, people change and it's inevitable. I would like to believe Cube, Beast and Hyunseung did try to save the group since 2013 (that was the year I was actually expecting disbandment after all Yoseob and Doojoon talking about how Beast only exist because of B2uties and somehow those words seemed really genuine and not just fanservice) until it can't be saved (as 6) anymore. Regarding the controversies, Cube prob didn't think much of it when it was just going around on Pann since I remembered CLC's attitude controversies, Cube really didn't do anything about that. It was only when an article was released that it got out of hand but, to me, I can't really blame Cube 100% on how it ended up that way.

IA. This is just life and things are always changing. It was always inevitable IMO and I believe that Hyunseung wanted to leave. No one is to blame.

 

You could tell even from his solo that his style of music is really different to the groups'. Sorta like a Zayn and 1D situation.

[mendoan]

be strong beast fans.

and do well for both

[Belle.]

You don't have to blame anyone.

 

I think we should all just accept that people grow, people change and it's inevitable. I would like to believe Cube, Beast and Hyunseung did try to save the group since 2013 (that was the year I was actually expecting disbandment after all Yoseob and Doojoon talking about how Beast only exist because of B2uties and somehow those words seemed really genuine and not just fanservice) until it can't be saved (as 6) anymore. Regarding the controversies, Cube prob didn't think much of it when it was just going around on Pann since I remembered CLC's attitude controversies, Cube really didn't do anything about that. It was only when an article was released that it got out of hand but, to me, I can't really blame Cube 100% on how it ended up that way.

Though Cube didn't act professionally as a company responsible about their artists still we cant say they're not 100% responsible

There's no use in blaming anyone , at last what we were afraid of actually happened, nothing gonna change this sad trut

[93_JiHyun]

 

As you all know there has been some obvious distance between him and the rest of the group for the past couple years after his dad passed. His SNS barely mentions anything about any member of Beast, the only ones I can think of was a birthday greeting for Doojoon and maybe Dongwoon iirc.

 

The biggest speculation is that it is Junhyung and Hyunseung who seem to have a bad relationship with each other and you barely see them interact or even look at each other but on Hyunseung's birthday last year, Junhyung was the first one to greet him on Instagram and that was the first member's birthday in a while where ALL members greeted the birthday celebrant on SNS. (For the record, Junhyung rarely if not never greeted anyone on SNS since 2012 iirc so when he did, everyone was surprised especially since it's Hyunseung.)

 

(I'm lazy to post all their birthday posts.)

 

The most unexpected of all was Hyunseung's birthday post.

 

 

#비스트 #BEAST #윤ë‘준 #장현승 #용준형 #양요섭 #ì´ê¸°ê´‘ #ì†ë™ìš´ #그리고여러분 #ë·°í‹° #행복한ìƒì¼ #ê°ì‚¬í•©ë‹ˆë‹¤

 

#Biseuteu #BEAST #Yoondoojoon #Janghyunseung #Yongjunhyung #Yangyoseob #LeeKikwang #SonDongwoon

#Everyone #B2uty #HappyBirthday #Thankyou

 

This was the very first post of his that mentioned Beast like that.

 

K-b2uties speculated that this was a farewell party or something like that. This was a couple days before his absence in the fanmeeting btw.

 

On top of that, the aura during their last Seoul concert was sort of sad... Let's watch their You performance that time.

 

 

He greeted both DJ and DW on instagram. He even had a video, who knows if it's still there, he deletes like crazy.

[93_JiHyun]

I've been a fan since jan 2012...I knew this was coming. I just wished it was oct so we could of at least proven these akgaes and anti's for the liars they are...Hyunseung's music taste is very different anymore to Beast. At least he liked guess who...they're last OT6 song.

[pinkpanda_spirit]

Why, just why?? He was my bias since I knew BEAST so.. since 2010-2011.  I don't wanna believe he quitted BEAST   his 4D personnamity was gold during beast's variety shows.. I can't see him solo without te 5 members. Ugh I wanna cry.

[Nyai]

Pretty much. I avoided talking about it in public coz it feels like if I did, the chances of it becoming true will increase...

I'm not a beauty but I'm an A+, so I feel you... it's like you don't want to think about it with the hope that it all will change and become good again. Be strong! 

[Only 1 U Need Connoisseur]

I am so sad..all they did was witch hunt him for the past year..

[Sailor Mars]

Yo this thread is deep af

It sucks he left but it is what it is. It sucks that fans and antis pushed him out

[mistressnicey]

I'm not a beauty but I'm an A+, so I feel you... it's like you don't want to think about it with the hope that it all will change and become good again. Be strong! 

 

Thank you. All this time I was hoping for the best but was prepared for the worst and the worst finally happened. Hopefully both him and the group will move on and have no regrets.