Disturbing Video of Teacher Ripping Up Homework Berating First Grader

[My Everything]

 

A teacher at a charter school in Harlem was caught on camera yelling at a first graders. The teacher rips up the student’s assignment and continues to yell at the student in front of the class.

 

Do you think the teacher was out of line? 

 

Read more here: http://bit.ly/1TXTzKu

 

“Administrators at the Success Academy—a network of high-performing charter schools in the New York area—are standing behind what they call a model teacher, who was caught on camera ripping up homework and berating a first grade student for answering a math problem incorrectly.

 

The video of Charlotte Dial’s first grade class, first published by the New York Times, was surreptitiously filmed by an assistant teacher who tells the paper she was “concerned by what she described as Ms. Dial’s daily harsh treatment of the children.â€

[WHEELCHAIR JIMMY]

she's unsuitable to be teaching a classroom, especially a 1st grade one with children who need to be taught and treated with care!

[Kim Hyolyn]

Thats not disciplining, thats humiliating a defenseless child in front of all of her classmates.

If her work wasnt up to the teachers standard or was incorrect then she could of easily told her what she needs to improve and how to do it better next time.

This sort of thing can scar a child, the girl will probably now be too scared to hand in her work to the teacher or present work in front of the class in fear of being humiliated and shouted at again.

 

She should be fired.

[Junhoes_hoe]

Fire that bitch! Jfc i feel so sorry for that kid. The little girl must be so embarrassed rn, she's fucking 6 years old.  

[Wasta]

I went to a charter school for part of the time I was in elementary school and while it's a little more intense, this is outrageous. What a toxic environment to learn in. 

[nancy mcflurry]

What a bitch

[Somnia]

Fire her!

[̶p̶̶m̶̶o̶]

reminds me of my teacher in forth class..... he screamed at me for not doing my homework (others didnt as well) and then ripped my notebook because he thought my writing was shitty .. i was so shocked i couldnt get a word out

they should make unannounced test to see if teachers are still capable of teaching appropriately

[SeeYaWithYou]

Why the fuck was she so angry

[Knock Chu Out]

Sigh, teachers are suppose to be helpful, not crush the children

[Sailor Mars]

poor kid :( hope that teacher is fired

[My Everything]

poor kid :( hope that teacher is fired

 

Video was filmed in 2014

 

she got a suspension but is still a teacher in that school

[Ddeona Oneul Bame]

This reminds me of when my teacher balled up my drawing in Pre-K~ I hope this kid is ok, tho~ 

[Pseudo]

Reminds me of Vietnamese kindergarten where shame-based discipline is encouraged for teachers. I don't wish it on a single child out there - children are meant to be led by example, and shouting and humiliating does more harm than good. 

[♩ ♪ ♫ ♬]

it's not that bad..

[jooyoungsbae]

oh jeez..

[My Everything]

it's not that bad..

 

lmfao are you serious

[suzya]

What the hell is wrong with that woman? 

[♩ ♪ ♫ ♬]

lmfao are you serious

 

yeah.. i grew up like that 

[jaehyunnies]

Fire her

[KaniPi]

Reminds me of a time, when my teacher started saying stuff about how my family is a failure, because I got a few questions wrong in my homework. I wasn't that superb at maths when I was younger...but still pretty harsh though. I was too young to understand what she did was wrong...and sadly there were no smartphones/youtube back then.

[darkishreality]

i remember i was 9 in a class and this student didn't do his work or something that made the teacher so pissed that he emptied his bag and threw his bag out of the class. he threw him out of the class as well.

[Big Stupid Jellyfish]

This is a bit much. Especially for a 1st grader...

[SugaJam]

it's not that bad..

 

same

it wasnt as bad as i thought

the teacher was intense, but nothing i havent seen before

plenty of teachers get that intense in grade school

[Bom]

Teachers like this just fail their students. She was completely out of order.