Best Music Show and why?

[Hero]

Which among the music shows are your favourite and why?

 

Obviously the 4 big 'main' music shows of each broadcaster (all have ratings at around 2% viewership):

1. KBS's Music Bank

2. MBC's Show! Music Core

3. SBS's Inkigayo

4. Mnet's M!Countdown (0.5% viewership //cable)

 

The other smaller shows that give exposure to lesser known idols:

1. MBC Music's Show Champion

2. SBS MTV's The Show

 

And the more exclusive music talk show:

1. KBS Yoo Hee Yeol's Sketchbook

 

Each have their pros/cons, but which is your favourite in terms of camera work, direction, stages, sound quality, MR backing track etc.?

[Asphyxia]

YHY sketchbook for me. I really enjoy the small talk and the camera work doesn't makes me dizzy

[Mogwai]

for camerawork, i tend to like inkigayo and sketchbook

 

for the sound quality, sketchbook (even though they apparently do pitch correction) and i do kinda like inkigayo

 

but i like mcountdown's individual fancams, especially for groups i casually like and only like one or two members

 

music core is good for guaranteed live singing i guess but their sound system sucks balls most of the time...

 

so overall sketchbook  is my favourite, followed by inkigayo

[elitin]

I like M countdown the most, because they release a lot of backstage videos, the MPD fancams and individual member fancams... I also like their camera work and stages.

In terms of sound Music Core is the best for me.

Inkigayo camera work makes me dizzy.

[TAE ZONE]

yhy sketchbook

* groups sometimes re-arrange songs or perform songs they wouldn't do on other music shows

ex: 

* sound system is good

* talk section

* feels more intimate 

* nice camerawork

 

mcountdown

* mpd's member-focused cams + rehearsal cams

* mpd!!! i like that guy 

inkigayo's camerawork is my favorite (after yhy sketchbook).

the show and show champion are good b/c they give smaller groups a chance to win.

in my personal experience, mucore is my real favorite b/c i got into pre-recordings for it lol but that's irrelevant to your question

[Haunted]

Sketchbook>>

[Clay]

YHY then

[alex crossing]

Show Champion! I like their backstage doozies, their camerawork's usually fair and level, and the sound's alright to boot.

Next, Sketchbook and M Countdown are tied for a second favorite. I like Sketchbook's sound and interviews and the attitude performers bring to the show, for M Countdown I enjoy the extras they give à la rehearsal videos and individualized fancams. I'm greedy and I'll appreciate and take everything ^^

The others are all okay, save for Inkigayo whose cameras look like they're being controlled by either elephant trunks or dogs being lured around with a stick.

[bucopandan]

Sketchbook >>> wall >> other music shows

 

some of my fave performances were performed there :">

[infntz]

YHY because of gyu singing 

time went through memorise there 

[Top Box]

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kv7NWh5zlxQ

 

Sketchbook obviously

[juicy milky thighs]

Sketchbook

 

I feel like all the other shows are too similar.

[Pyo Hyemi]

any because 9muses are not the winners of any