Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Was leaving Kara a mistake for Nicole?


ethereal

Recommended Posts

Jiyoung is off in Japan getting acting roles and stuff and is moderately successful at the moment. But Nicole's solo endeavors kind of flopped. I don't know all the download numbers and crap, but her solo debut didn't make much of an impact, like, at all.

 

 

and her hairstyle really doesn't suit her. she looks better with bangs tbh.

 

 

I also heard her Japanese debut flopped  a bit. Though I don't personally know much about it.

 

 

Now, it's not like Kara is at their prime anymore either, but as a respected group in the industry they at least have a decent income and a loyal following. I honestly don't get why Nicole left. I get that she was having problems with the agency or something, but if she wanted to continue as an idol, she should have stuck it out a bit longer, imo.

 

 

So here's a question for Kamila's that are more knowledgeable about this. Was leaving Kara a mistake career wise?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

According to K-netz, the reason she chose to leave was for money, and that her mom encouraged her to? (I don't know the legitimacy of this, I just remember reading something along these lines when I used to read NB so don't axe murder me pls) But yeah, Nicole was popular for being a member of KARA, unlike Goo Hara and Jiyoung who had their own form of popularity. Nicole should've stayed, she would be making more money than she is now (KARA still has a semi-successful career in Japan and the members are known for making a ton of money, i.e. Seungyeon and Hara both buying buildings worth over a million dollars).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Personally speaking, her solo didn't do very well in Korea or Japan as far as I know. I think she would've been better off staying in KARA. Nowadays, I don't even hear about Nicole :/

 

BUT, if she's happier now than when she was in KARA for that last year or two, then I guess it was worth it in a way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Totally irrelevant but i noticed that when ever anyone says an idols looks better with bangs that idol has a big forehead. I have a big forehead and I've always been self conscious about it and those comments unintentionally make my insecurities reality

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That depends on what her intention was by leaving. If she wanted to be more free, she made a great choice b/c Kara is going nowhere. If she wanted to be popular she fucked up by leaving.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Money? She is actually rich af with all the concerts, CF and discs that KARA sold while she was a member, not counting her mom's business, the reason she decided to leave is about solo activities, DSP CEO (the wife of the former CEO now in coma) doesn't give anything to her

 

Btw Something Special wasn't a flop (Japan), but Mama (Korea) probably, we actually know, on Korea, KARA members as individual are not popular enough than the entire group, tha'ts probably bad for a few people, thinking every member needs to be recognized and have a long fanbase (that's happens on only on Japan, where she wasn't a flop), but I don't think so, that shows how KARA really fits on the concept of a group, every member has her own charm and no one is better than no one

 

But DSP is making moves to get rid off about that concept, giving camera and focus to the members on individual, I don't think is a bad move either, just saying to anyone who want to talk cr*p because KARA members are not much famous as individual  :smile:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the real reason for her leaving KARA remaining unknown, because we all know KARA bond is real.. but one thing for sure that I know, nicole actually never want to leave KARA! she just want to leave DSP (remember when she ask DSP to have a contract like what ga in and Brown Eyed Girls did with NEGA but DSP refuse her wish) she almost don't get any solo promotion except solo single which every one included, and solo drama which including all KARA member too. beside that?? NO! No solo, No duet, no TV show, not even one photoshoot (not including when all member take their part) she need something to make her grow up as an artist, but I know DSP try to seal her in DSP dungeon, that's why she choose to leave..

 

 

ps: sorry for my super bad english

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nicole is still super rich as hell. The amount of money she made in KARA is unreal amd I doubt she used it all up.

 

And her solo debut didn't do well digitally because it wasn't a public friendly song. She is still new with solo activities.

 

And you said it had 0 impact, but it outsold Hyuna, Sunmi, And Hara's last comebacks physically. Not bad for a debut.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nicole sold about 9-10k in korea....that's not bad, considering female soloist hardly sell.

She is rich and had a long career, whatever she does now is fine as long as she is free like a bird.

Nicole is making a comeback so please anticipate it.

 

Totally irrelevant but i noticed that when ever anyone says an idols looks better with bangs that idol has a big forehead. I have a big forehead and I've always been self conscious about it and those comments unintentionally make my insecurities reality

 

Take a look at Tyra Banks or Rihanna or the likes they look amazing without fringes. I think Nicole looks the best with side swiped fringes. Just think positively of yourself and the beauty standards of others won't matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For Nicole leaving I think so, although she might be more happy now I miss her interactions with her band mates.  Also its more difficult getting content on Nicole as she is less active these days.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I heard rumors that the chance for individual opportunity and money was not right.

Also, things changed a lot after the old CEO of DSP died and his wife took over.

In addition, some have said that Nicole's mom is very assertive and was a driving force during

negotiations or in raising dissatisfactions.

 

I just hope she is happy and invest her money well like some of her former bandmates have.

 

Edit:  I actually remember when this happened. The group was in the middle of contract renegotiations.

Not many expected this...it was a big shock to many bc they were still making money in Japan. They were in the middle of their Japanese Tour - I remember.. ...and Damaged Lady was a bop.

I was an Allkpop regular at the time.

It seemed as though negotiations sort of fell apart, because it was a very abrupt announcement at the time.

The DSP CEO was sort of like "screw it".  Both the parents and the CEO were sort of playing hard ball.

So sometimes when you play hard ball you got to walk. 

It seemed as though Nicole and Jiyoung were the most dissatisfied.

But don't get it twisted because Goo Hara AND Hammie were both on the fence too. Those girls actually do get along rather well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think leaving Kara was a mistake but going to B2M might have been. They absolutely suck at promotion and I'm speaking as a SPICA fan. On the plus side they don't micromanage their artist's lives so she probably has a lot more freedom than she did at DSP.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top