ShiBeaIn: Best comeback?

[Zenny]

Shinee, Beast and Infinite have been labeled the three most stable of kpop groups: few scandals, good image, great music. Let's look at their 2015 comeback!

 

SHINee:

 

 

Beast:

 

 

Infinite:

 

 

I would've put best live but Beast hasn't performed yet.

 

I thought about asking who had the worst out of the three but....

[93605]

i don't care about the other two so shinee >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Universe]

Infinite, easily

[dvang]

beast was just bad overall

infinite was pretty good

but shinee slayed everyone with view and the odd album in general

view is easily my fav boy group song of the year so far 

[MILJYU]

Id say shinee for most things except album and choreo, odd as an album was overrated af and the view choreo was basic. I guess ill give those two to infinite

[Johnny Suh]

Inpiniteu   

[RIPHaldir]

This was hard so I liked all 3 comebacks and I stan all the groups :(

Title song: infinite, if you had done gotta go to work then beast would have won for me

mv: shinee

Album: shinee, although I have only listened to half of beasts album so far

Side track: shinee, Alive/trigger are amazing imo

Dance: infinite

Overall: shinee

[SAUCY]

infinite was pretty good but

 

shinee

 

 

 

view's perfect 

[Shinee Spazzer]

Everything for SHINee except the title track. I actually liking Bad more than View.

[Pocket Hyung]

I never really liked Shinee's song and this is no exception sadly

 

 

I really liked Bad

 

And I prefer gotta go to work than YeY tbh

[Oliver]

Shinee definitely... the other 2 were forgettable for me tbh....

[shutupihateyou]

shinee for all 

[Lee Seojun]

KIngfinite slayed

[badgalriri]

SHINee for all

[SLY]

Kingfinite for all~

 

Up To You is the best side track.

[INFINITE SHOWTIME]

i don't care about the other two so shinee >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

the question wasn't "who's your bias?" even though everyone here seems to read it that way 

[EXOSNSD]

infi?nugu? beast???

SHINEEEEE slay ur faves with ODDDDDDDDD      

Remember Odd picked Best album of first half byMelon criticssssss & Fuse, Only idol album nominated Älbums of glory" by ARENA    When will ur favesssssss???????????    

[ezzie96]

Well I'm based af so I decided to listen to both infinite and beast lol...and i will still say SHINee for everything. Though infinite's title song and album was pretty good. I really like bad. Maybe just as much as view..hmm

[Nadjell]

Title song honestly goes to SHINee, View is flawless

MV I think Bad was better

Overall album Reality

Side tracks I give this to Ifnt too

Choreo Infinite

And overall comeback I couldnt vote on this one

[sunggyuluver]

infi?nugu? beast???

SHINEEEEE slay ur faves with ODDDDDDDDD      

Remember Odd picked Best album of first half byMelon criticssssss & Fuse, Only idol album nominated Älbums of glory" by ARENA    When will ur favesssssss???????????    

NUGU group Infinite's song is 2012 Kpop song of the year according to billboard.

 

http://netizenbuzz.blogspot.com/2012/12/billboard-chooses-infinites-chaser-as.html?m=1

[Takamina]

Always with my "NUGU" group INFINITE I mean KINGFINITE because of Between Me & You and Moonlight and Love Letter and maybe Betting.

 

I like View too and I haven't listen to Yey I hope it doesn't disappoint me.

[♡LINUS]

infinite, iam not even biased

[JJChastity]

Chosing for best side track from Infinite - Reality is a hard task for me because I like all the songs from Infinite Reality album equally.

Tracklist:

1. Betting
2. Bad

3. Moonlight

4. Footsteps

5. Between Me&You

6. Love Letter
7. Up To You

[25%Cotton]

is this a question?

 

view is a basic track that hides behind SM production values.

beast's track is... dull. kinda reminds me of shadow which was also forgettable.

 

infinite's reality turned a new corner for the group while maintaining their best qualities as a group. everything is great about it.

[cassie-shawol<3]

Best Title Song

View -> Bad -> Yey

 

Best Music Video

SHINee -> Infinite -> Beast

 

Best Overall Album

Odd = Reality -> Ordinary

 

Best Side Track

1. SHINee - Trigger, Alive, Farewell My Love, An Ode To You, An Encore, Love Sick, Odd Eye, Woof Woof, Black Hole (ALL), except Romance

2. Infinite - Moon Light, Up To You, Love Letter, Footsteps

3. Beast

 

Best Dance

Infinite -> Beast -> SHINee

 

Best Comeback Overall

SHINee