Let's list some reasons why SHY(Y) sub-unit will never happen...

[kxjay]

-They are the least popular members of SNSD (if Yoona isn't included and even if she were, it won't help much)

-Another very obvious one but I'll omit saying it as it's too obvious.

 

Now it's your turn! Be very truthful and honest with your choices

[page6lovers]

Their vocals don't suffice? But idk, kara can survive.

[SulIi]

I'll try my best

 

SM don't want make a group with full of dating members because it'll affect the sales. Last year Holler < Twinkle

[Supercell]

Please support Superfly

[LeeTheBee]

 

Please support Superfly

 

 

You know, spamming just makes me avoid these altogether.

[Kpopiscool_101]

Vocals

[Besmug]

I think that now, SNSD has to maintain their image as a whole. A bit like "we are one" you know". TTS is enough for SM, they will play on the girls unity now.

[Supercell]

You know, spamming just makes me avoid these altogether.

Do you know, this is a bait thread?

Don't need to take OP seriously.

[ToujoursSistar]

No hate but who's going to sing

[Little Eight]

Cos it is just fan delusion?

[bbangjyjbapshineelove]

S.M. crappy promotions.

Other side projects.

You can have a hit song without good vocals.

(examples too numerous to count...)

[Deea]

Thank god it wont happen

[camelliabloom]

Well you never know tbh, SM gave Zhoumi a solo and Key & Woohyun a subunit.

SM's main goal is to satisfy their fans, not the general public so I could see why fans believe in it.

[Seulo]

It'll never happen because SM doesn't think the investment is worth it, but we already know this so the thread is completely unnecessary 
 

[kxjay]

Do you know, this is a bait thread?

Don't need to take OP seriously.

Its purpose is also to conceive discussions from your everyday boring mundane kumbaya peace loving topics.

While your spamming serves no other purpose than being disruptive. If you hate it, don't post. It's really that simple.

[kxjay]

I think that now, SNSD has to maintain their image as a whole. A bit like "we are one" you know". TTS is enough for SM, they will play on the girls unity now.

Huh, I never thought of it that way but you're right. Seperating the girls even if it were temporary, even further will disrupt thwir fanbase and isolate them.

It'll obviously be a very bad move on SM's to do so as well.

[nikitablank]

1. sm is an ass

[Besmug]

Huh, I never thought of it that way but you're right. Seperating the girls even if it were temporary, even further will disrupt thwir fanbase and isolate them.

It'll obviously be a very bad move on SM's to do so as well.

Yeah I think so. All that I hear since the girls comeback is the "we are friends, we love each other like sisters, we are united", which I didn't hear since debut days... Seems to be SM strategy !

[Serenee]

Honestly, I was really skeptical if I would like a SHY sub-unit or not, but after seeing dance line slaying that CMIYC choreo, I think I warmed up to the idea.

The song would be pretty hard to digest if EDM and average vocals, but if you give me something like CMIYC, I would like it.

 

The chances are really low tho. Yoona and Sooyoung are already fine with their acting roles. And SM isn't willing to invest in something that might not make big money. Plus, they are going to focus on SNSD8 for a while.

[elohim]

I still think fans would buy albums to listen to their...dancing.

[sillysone]

It's not going to happen. First of all, Sooyoung and Yuri would rather focus on acting at this point, Hyoyeon's the only out of the three who said she's interested in unit activities.

 

Also, SM thinks it's not worth the investment. And yeah, as someone noted above, they want to keep the image of SNSD as a whole.

[tsuki2]

SM needs to promote OT8 bond & improve their image with the public after last year. Any side projects are probably put on hold for awhile.

 

Also waste of money, TTS is the ultimate combo of SNSD members & rakes in cash, why create a new unit that would not even make half of what TTS does.

[pretty_angel92]

-They are the least popular members of SNSD (if Yoona isn't included and even if she were, it won't help much)

-Another very obvious one but I'll omit saying it as it's too obvious.

 

Now it's your turn! Be very truthful and honest with your choices

Sooyoung and Yuri are more popular than Sunny though

[freeask?]

I admit they lack vocal quality, its not like they cant sing, they CAN but none of them are particularly good at it. And if they make it to hip hop/rap it maybe works but idk... if their subunit really cant happen then atleast i want them to a stage together covering songs in special show/concert

[hyotmess]

lack of public support and thats it

 

let's not drop the "they cant sing" card when Hara is about to have a solo debut