Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

[Naver:KRN] Selcas & Netizens Roundup: Taeyeon, G-Dragon, Nana, Yubin, Baekhyun, Tiffany


john

Recommended Posts

Why do they hate Nana?

Nana has literally never been liked by the Korean public and has only been popular among I-fans. When she debuted in After School they dug up pictures of her smoking and drinking and she's been known as a delinquent since then. They have never praised her face because she doesn't fit their standard and after Roommate her image has just gotten worse. 

 

She may be one of the more popular members know but that's only because Pledis pushes her despite all of this. With Kahi, Jooyeon and even Bekah gone, they need a new face and I guess that's what they are trying to do with Nana. Uee will always be the preferred choice in After School for Korea. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's a bit of an over exaggeration, Nana has a lot of fans (for coming from a mid-tier group and thanks to OC she is the most popular in both groups) which has only increased over time (she was able to complete solo fansigns in both Korea and Japan). Her company push only gets you so far, she has proven herself to increase sales with the products she endorses enough for her to continue to get more cfs than any Pledis idol ever has. I think basing an entire assessment on netizen comments (and the mostly negative NB ones no less) isn't looking at the whole picture.

 

I never denied the fact that Nana has fans (especially internationally), but the general consensus about her is just like Korea's opinion about Clara obviously not as bad but she's not exactly liked. She's never been ranked as After Schools beauty (besides the TC list) Jooyeon and Uee always outranked her and really is only popular because Pledis has pushed the crap out of her.

 

Regarding her CFs quality over quantity because Uee makes more money per CF than After School as a whole, though this figure could have changed because they stopped promoting her in favour of Nana. Now she is in China but how can you deny the fact that she's popular because of the push? Pledis literally does nothing with some of the other members its no wonder people like Eyoung have to pick up gigs where she can.

 

I look at the big picture but I simply answered a question as to why Nana isn't like by some.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Right... but I think the whole "push" argument only goes so far. Companies back the idol they think with garner the best response, or one that already has attention/looks/popularity that is able to grow further. Ever since OC eclipsed AS Nana has been the jewel in Pledis' crown. Pledis pushed her to the forefront and the response has been good and she has increased sales as an endorsement model. I think saying the company pushed for someone's success discredits someones actual success or popularity and makes it seem completely fabricated or not genuine?

 

I agree that that silly list catapulted her so much, but she was already seen as a model-like beauty before that (despide having *gasp* monolids), its just that the idol world is obsessed with mainstream homogenized k-beauty. Also she has had so so many positive articles online about her body and unedited photoshoot photos that never make it to NB etc. I agree reactions to her are very mixed because of her tv work but this "Korea hates Nana" thing isn't really fair. (also Jooyeon officially handed over the AS visual role to Nana in an interview before she graduated lol)

 

Where does it say Uee makes more per cf than AS as a whole? And from what year? Nana was the face of Skechers, I don't think Uee has ever endorsed a brand that big? The were both faces of diet brands (Uee for BDlab & Nana for Juvis, Juvis being the biggest in Korea). Ever since Nana's rise she has been at the forefront of group cf's as well. It wasn't always this way but Nana has only gotten bigger and better and more lucrative as time goes on.

 

It doesn't discredit her popularity and success but it also doesn't change the fact that it is largely due to the Pledis Push. You said it yourself, she's the Pledis jewel and we are definitely seeing that with all of the work that she's getting. It's not like Jooyeon had to hand anything over to Nana, Jooyeon was on the outs anyways.

 

Honestly if this continues After School will remain stagnant because Nana doesn't have the same likability that Uee had as the face of the group. Uee's addition and her time at the forefront catapulted the group, but now a sub-unit (whose singles are on the decline) has more popularity than After School.   

 

 

 

2AM, CN Blue, Kara, 4Minute, MBLAQ, After School (excluding UEE), and other artists were classified as those earning at least 400 million won per CF. After School member, UEE, as a solo model, earns more than 400 million won, and is being heralded as the next generation CF star. 

This is from 2011/2012, though I don't think this has changed much seeing as a stars value increases over time. This was before Uee began promoting herself as an actress so she is probably worth more now. Although Uee may not have had a brand as big as Skechers (the brand also has Sistar as her main models, which probably cost them more money) it doesn't decrease her worth plus when you aren't SNSD brand exclusivity could work in your favour. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top