Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

Girl Groups Ranking 2011-2015 [Downloads & Physical]


YesIKnowRelax

Recommended Posts

As I often do on my blog I made a ranking of girl groups based on downloads and physical sales but from 2011 to recently rather than 2010 to 2012/2013 which was my last one.

 

I'll post the ranking here and you can check out the article for the full explanation!

 

physicalsales.png

 

Top Tier:
SNSD
2NE1
Sistar
 
National Tier:
APink
Girl's Day
 
Popular Tier:
F(x)
Miss A 
4Minute
Orange Caramel
 
Falling Stars:
Kara
T-ara
Secret
 
Obscurity Awaits:
Nine Muses
After School
Dal Shabet
Rainbow
Hello Venus
 
I honestly don't know...
Brown Eyed Girls
Mamamoo
Ladies Code
 
Groups to look out for:
AOA
EXID
Red Velvet
GFriend
Lovelyz
Orange Caramel
 
girlchart.png
 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This looks confusing

girlchart.png

 

idk how to read these, pls just give me a list with numbers next to them. 

 

nvm I can't read the bar one but not the one with all the lines 

It's the position of the groups' biggest digtal hit that year.

For instance T-ara had the #1 song of 2011 and #2 of 2012 but in 2013 Number Nine was @160 so their line plummeted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You forgot to post a link to the article

 

I'm a genius LOL

sorry

 

This looks confusing

girlchart.png

 

I duno why only 2011 is show up but its 2011   2012   2013    2014 on the chart

its the highest charting song on GAON's yearly download chart for each group

its supposed to show a trend: rising, falling or maintaining.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sistar is national tier not top 

 

you dont really take into account digitals it seems where they have fallen 

actually i discuss that in my article

they haven't really fallen

not significantly and it was only last year

SNSD and 2NE1 both had bigger dips in their, albeit longer, careers

whats important is that even when they fall a bit 2NE1 and SNSD still come out stronger overall than Sistar because of their fan size

and for 2NE1 also their ability to sell entire albums digitally not just title tracks

 

however Sistar has been consistent and their collabs and OST success show they have strong public recognition

 

Their next 2 comeback will either cement them as top tier or they'll fall to national

Link to comment
Share on other sites

actually i discuss that in my article

they haven't really fallen

not significantly and it was only last year

SNSD and 2NE1 both had bigger dips in their, albeit longer, careers

whats important is that even when they fall a bit 2NE1 and SNSD still come out stronger overall than Sistar because of their fan size

and for 2NE1 also their ability to sell entire albums digitally not just title tracks

 

however Sistar has been consistent and their collabs and OST success show they have strong public recognition

 

Their next 2 comeback will either cement them as top tier or they'll fall to national

 

collabs and ost should not really count when there album together sold 2.5 million while 2ne1s 5 million even with a 2+ year break 

 

2ne1 did not fall digitally 

 

and bigger dips while being massively ahead is not really the same as having little dips when behind them

 

they are on the same level as apink if not lower 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

collabs and ost should not really count when there album together sold 2.5 million while 2ne1s 5 million even with a 2+ year break 

 

2ne1 did not fall digitally 

 

and bigger dips while being massively ahead is not really the same as having little dips when behind them

 

they are on the same level as apink if not lower 

 

Well Sistar's was a mini album versus a full album

Give It To Me did well digitally as a full album with 3 other songs charting in the top 200 other than the title track

2ne1 had a bad 2013 although they bounced back

Sistar still made the top 20 with touch my body

 

no OSTs and collabs dont count but it shows the members have public recognition

APink hasn't sold non title tracks like Sistar has managed too

Sistar does need a bigger fanbase tho

 

What Sistar has though is individual member public recognition

while in APink only Eunji and I think Naeun are known (she was the one on WGM married right?)

 

Sistar has successful solos (Hyorin) and Subunits (Sistar19) and OSTs 

but APink has no successful solo or unit promos and only Eunji has OSTs that sell well

 

Sistars OST and collab sales are WAYYY higher than APink's

Some >>>>>>>>>>> Short Hair

 

Sistar is still ahead for the time being

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well Sistar's was a mini album versus a full album

Give It To Me did well digitally as a full album with 3 other songs charting in the top 200 other than the title track

2ne1 had a bad 2013 although they bounced back

Sistar still made the top 20 with touch my body

 

no OSTs and collabs dont count but it shows the members have public recognition

APink hasn't sold non title tracks like Sistar has managed too

Sistar does need a bigger fanbase tho

 

What Sistar has though is individual member public recognition

while in APink only Eunji and I think Naeun are known (she was the one on WGM married right?)

 

Sistar has successful solos (Hyorin) and Subunits (Sistar19) and OSTs 

but APink has no successful solo or unit promos and only Eunji has OSTs that sell well

 

Sistars OST and collab sales are WAYYY higher than APink's

Some >>>>>>>>>>> Short Hair

 

Sistar is still ahead for the time being

 

they had 2 albums in 2014 and barely sold 2.5 million thats way down on what sistar used to do

 

maybe sistar is ahead but not on same level as 2ne1 , snsd  , that bad 2013 still sold 2.5 million digitals 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well Sistar's was a mini album versus a full album

Give It To Me did well digitally as a full album with 3 other songs charting in the top 200 other than the title track

2ne1 had a bad 2013 although they bounced back

Sistar still made the top 20 with touch my body

 

no OSTs and collabs dont count but it shows the members have public recognition

APink hasn't sold non title tracks like Sistar has managed too

Sistar does need a bigger fanbase tho

 

What Sistar has though is individual member public recognition

while in APink only Eunji and I think Naeun are known (she was the one on WGM married right?)

 

Sistar has successful solos (Hyorin) and Subunits (Sistar19) and OSTs 

but APink has no successful solo or unit promos and only Eunji has OSTs that sell well

 

Sistars OST and collab sales are WAYYY higher than APink's

Some >>>>>>>>>>> Short Hair

 

Sistar is still ahead for the time being

I think you did mean Mr. Chu and I wouldn't discuss any Sistar related things with fanboi, he is just a Sistar hater in general.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

they had 2 albums in 2014 and barely sold 2.5 million thats way down on what sistar used to do

 

maybe sistar is ahead but not on same level as 2ne1 , snsd  , that bad 2013 still sold 2.5 million digitals 

they did not have two albums

they had a remix album with basically two new songs

so not really

 

but it is true their 2014 promos were not up to their 2012 and 2013 promos

but not so much that you can say they are on a downward trend

a trend need two years in a row

 

I think you did mean Mr. Chu and I wouldn't discuss any Sistar related things with fanboi, he is just a Sistar hater in general.

 

No i meant short hair...

I was talking about collabs Some was Soyu with Junggigo

short hair was Eunji and Heo Gak

 

I was comparing how well Sistar's solo collabs did compared to APink's

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top