The Unpopular Opinions Thread (Read OP)

[flower.]

Line distribution should be fair and not equal.

I'm saying all member should have lines according to their official position, not saying some should get like 1-3 sec lines. Like it wouldn't make sense if a lead gets less than a sub?

But yes, there will be some instances where the line distribution is equal.

Edited June 21, 2021 by MinaSanatozaki

[flower.]

 

TWICE > ITZY vocally and I am not being delusional

I am aware my rep is at risk but let me explain myself:

According to some sources, Lia was a former SM Ent. trainee (I know she didn't actually receive training but she was accepted(?)) but still one of the weakest main vocalists in the industry. 3mix is probably average.

Many fans will use the excuse "they are more stable live", but stability does not equal better techniques, (I do not know the terminologies) and many stans tend to jump to the conclusion that this is true. TWICE is often given more songs out of their range while ITZY is often in their comfortable range.

I do believe ITZY are a very dance - focused group tho.

I can't say much myself since am not a professional and I know nothing about techniques, but I have done my research and this is what some professionals online have said.

 

I found this on reddit in the UKO subreddit. It was voted almost half popular and unpopular so I do not know how popular this is:

 

 

 

r.i.p. my reputation...

 

edit: who really negged me

Edited July 2, 2021 by MinaSanatozaki

[flower.]

TWICE can pull off their new matured concept well. It really shows their diversity and more GC side of them. I am not sure how unpopular this is , but I am just very sick of people saying they can't pull off their new concept.

There are several stages that show the darker, more matured side of them:

etc.

A major part of the reason for their "decline" is because fans are more attracted to their old, cuter concept from 2016-2019 (plus there are so many new ggs with the GC concept), NOT because they can't pull off their new one. In other words, TWICE's trademark was definitely their bright bubbly concept; which was marketed towards their fan boys / girls. Now that their trademark has shifted, their types of fans will change along with it. Now I am not asking you to change your opinion on Twice, I am just stating that I believe TWICE are truly comfortable in their new concept.

Edited July 8, 2021 by MinaSanatozaki

[flower.]

TWICE's line distributions have not gotten any better.

 

Fair line distribution =/= equal

 

I see a lot of people saying their line distributions have gotten better and I understand the other girls have gotten their time to shine but then they forget their main vocalist barely gets 20 seconds in each song. (No hate to Nayeon I love her) They are called official positions for a reason.

Edited July 16, 2021 by MinaSanatozaki

[flower.]

I don't know how unpopular this really is but not all ggs need to be super "versatile" or able to pull of every single concept well. While I do agree they should have the versatility to branch out into their career and show different sides, the public shouldn't try to push or petition them to something out of their range. For example, I see some of you guys hating on bp for not changing their concept or twice for being "the cute concept group." Red Velvet is an exception, as they are known for being able to embody nearly every concept well, they have their red and velvet sides, but not every group needs to be that way? In 2016-2019(?) Twice specialized in their colourpop genre while BlackPink remains famous for their GC concept. Not that they can't pull of other concepts but I don't see the need for a major concept change as I feel most kpop ggs would get "boring" and "unoriginal" if they all had the same or similar concepts, unless they have a unique charm to attract stans. That being said, I feel that all ggs need versatility to some extent, showcased especially in their debut, but should stick to their own style, not to jump a sexy concept or sumn completely out of their range, especially when there are underage members. Take twices debut for example, not really a cutesy concept but still fits their colorpop genre, allowing them to branch out into their later career.

 

(dont judge I am just giving examples)

 

 

 

 

 

 

[flower.]

The word "underrated" is overused.

[flower.]

I am sick of onces using the excuse "stability" as to why Jeongyeon should be the main vocalist. Sure she is the most stable in the group, but that is often mistaken for better techniques. While I do believe JYPE should give her more lines, I do not think she suit the main vocalist position. Plus their main vocalist nowadays barely gets 10 seconds.

Edited July 20, 2021 by MinaSanatozaki