Jump to content
OneHallyu Will Be Closing End Of 2023 ×
OneHallyu

If BEAST and Miss A came back at the same time.....


If BEAST and Miss A came back at the same time...  

53 members have voted

  1. 1. Who would win more awards?

    • BEAST is the B2ST
      33
    • MISS SLAY
      20


Recommended Posts

 

  • Flashback to 2011, BEAST came back with their first full album Fiction and Fact and went on to hit it big with On Rainy Days and Fiction. It put them in the spotlight and they gained public recognition.
  • That same year, Miss A also put out their first full album A Class, and Goodbye Baby swept the charts and went on to win many awards.
  • Both groups went on to win Best Dance Performance at the 2011 MAMA

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u0jcLvGPg1g

    (fun fact, neither have attended MAMA since)

 

Originally Miss A was supposed to comeback at the same time as BEAST in May 2011. But they got pushed back to July.

So my question is, do you think that both groups would have achieved that same level of impact if they had came back at the same time? How would they have fared on the charts? Would BEAST still slay and break out of nugudom? Or would Miss A have blocked their success? Would they both have won the same awards at MAMA 2011 if they had came back during the same month? 

 

Ya'll know I love both groups, so thinking about it made me curious. I really want to see those two comeback at the same time just to see how it would play out and of course I would support them both. I just wonder who would top Melon because they both have public recognition now and who would win on shows lol. BEAST slays by default, but Miss A has the massive digital appeal that's on another level. I'd love to see them be a wall on Melon at 1 and 2, it would be so exciting lol And then I'd get interactions  :ahmagah: I hope that it happens in 2016. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

  • Flashback to 2011, BEAST came back with their first full album Fiction and Fact and went on to hit it big with On Rainy Days and Fiction. It put them in the spotlight and they gained public recognition.
  • That same year, Miss A also put out their first full album A Class, and Goodbye Baby swept the charts and went on to win many awards.
  • Both groups went on to win Best Dance Performance at the 2011 MAMA

     

     

    (fun fact, neither have attended MAMA since)

 

Originally Miss A was supposed to comeback at the same time as BEAST in May 2011. But they got pushed back to September.

So my question is, do you think that both groups would have achieved that same level of impact if they had came back at the same time? How would they have fared on the charts? Would BEAST still slay and break out of nugudom? Or would Miss A have blocked their success? Would they both have won the same awards at MAMA 2011 if they had came back during the same month? 

 

Ya'll know I love both groups, so thinking about it made me curious. I really want to see those two comeback at the same time just to see how it would play out and of course I would support them both. I just wonder who would top Melon because they both have public recognition now and who would win on shows lol. BEAST slays by default, but Miss A has the massive digital appeal that's on another level. I'd love to see them be a wall on Melon at 1 and 2, it would be so exciting lol And then I'd get interactions  :ahmagah: I hope that it happens in 2016. 

 

except beast wasn't a nugu before ORD & Fiction happened. They were a semi-relevant group.

Shock was #38 in 2010 melon yearly top100 & #55 in 2010 gaon 2010 yearly top 100. They had 2 members with a decent public recognition, Kikwang & Doojoon. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

except beast wasn't a nugu before ORD & Fiction happened. They were a semi-relevant group.

Shock was #38 in 2010 melon yearly top100 & #55 in 2010 gaon 2010 yearly top 100. They had 2 members with a decent public recognition, Kikwang & Doojoon. 

Well I didn't mean nugu like totally irrelevant, but nugu as in, public didn't really care about the group. like there are groups that sell a lot, but the public doesn't know who they are

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Miss A might have the upper hand is digitals,but their physicals are so low...... and their fanvotes are really weak(lovelyz had more votes than them in one of the shows lol)

 

while beast have good enough digitals and amazing fan support and physical album sales....

 

Beast would win most,but miss a would have a chance if their digital was really high and their views as well(especially on inkigayo).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hmmmm Beast coz biased but Miss A might achieve better longevity in the charts and they will do better digitally but Beast will have more than decent digital sales and they don't lack in other categories in winning music shows so there's that.

 

^^

 

idk if Miss A would have blocked ORD-Fiction combo when it comes to success tho. Not sure...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Back to Top