[NB] Netizens blame SM for choosing crappy title tracks

[Jeffrey Jung]

Article: SHINee, Jonghyun's composed 'Selene 6.23' takes #1 on the digital charts

Source: OSEN via Naver

1. [+894, -12] Journalist, he didn't compose the song, he penned it

2. [+666, -55] Gotta trust SHINee when it comes to music. They've never disappointed me with their voices. The fact that their title songs are stupid is SM's fault. Listen to the other songs in their albums, listen to them twice. They're worth it.

3. [+629, -41] Vocals are goose bump inducing

4. [+568, -33] I've been listening to them for a while and noticed how much Taemin has improved. Key's voice is on the unique side but he's a good singer and Minho is trying his best. SHINee's probably the male idol group with the most members who can sing. Their songs have a high quality to them now with great lyrics. I think SM is finally recognizing SHINee's true worth and giving them great songs to work with.

5. [+515, -32] Love SHINee's song ã…‹ã…‹ã…‹

[Seditary]

Minho is trying his best.

 

[youchewflop]

3. [+629, -41] Vocals are goose bump inducing

 

 

 

not really..

[kinjiki]

Both songs are boring and typical Kpop ballad snooze material.

[Meth Krystal]

o shawols

[amber oppa]

 [+629, -41] Vocals are goose bump inducing

 

let's not.

[Baby Choux ☆]

Dream Girl >>>

[~ PD Hercule Poirot ~]

Only Onew and Jonghyun are great singers. Taemin improved a lot and Key's voice is indeed unique. Minho's voice improved too and he sings more now. Still, I think they aren't exactly 'goose bump inducing' lol.

[AdzPower]

Yes I totally agree! SHINee are always the best when it comes to their music and lyrics, other basic bitches be pressed that their faves aren't loved by netizens....    

[Rinne]

Seriously guys

[Meth Krystal]

Yes I totally agree! SHINee are always the best when it comes to their music and lyrics, other basic bitches be pressed that their faves aren't loved by netizens....    

 

netizens = fans/antifans

 

thats all there is to it. 

[minjoy]

I'm really proud how their song hit digital sales with tweets. But I have to admit that I don't like this kind of ballad, it makes me more emotional lol. I still prefer WSS noisy song better

[xsleepyhead]

Only Onew and Jonghyun are great singers. Taemin improved a lot and Key's voice is indeed unique. Minho's voice improved too and he sings more now. Still, I think they aren't exactly 'goose bump inducing' lol.

 

Taemin is on the same level as Onew and Jonghyun if not even better. 

[ruppi]

Netizens have been really loving Shinee lately :D

 

Is the song really doing so well digitally? On what place is it right now?

[minjoy]

Taemin is on the same level as Onew and Jonghyun if not even better. 

 

Before I thought he already did take same level with Jonghyun but Taemin's vocal seems easily tired so I think the ranking now goes like this:

 

1. Jonghyun

2. Onew=Taemin

3. Key

4. Minho

[minionmonstar0309]

just can lol-ing with knetz.. they maturity on the level of childish     

[kinjiki]

If Onew was a woman people here would be dissing him all the time about his voice. I guess it's okay for men to have a "quirky voice".

[shaysonic]

Netizens have been really loving Shinee lately :D

 

Is the song really doing so well digitally? On what place is it right now?

 

 

It's not doing particularly great tbh - 22 on Melon

 

Before I thought he already did take same level with Jonghyun but Taemin's vocal seems easily tired so I think the ranking now goes like this:

 

1. Jonghyun

2. Onew=Taemin

3. Key

4. Minho

 

Actually according to the vocals thread its Taemin, then Jjong, then Onew, Key and then Minho.

[minjoy]

It's not doing particularly great tbh - 22 on Melon

 

 

Actually according to the vocals thread its Taemin, then Jjong, then Onew, Key and then Minho.

 

I don't believe that much as vocal professionals and trainers have different perception on that. Let's say in the case of Park Bom  There are some critics saying she is the best while others say worst so on behalf of general views, I go with the previous ranking. Experience wise, Jonghyun still ahead of Taemin.

[verticalh@riz0n]

netizens = fans/antifans

 

thats all there is to it. 

THIS!

[CALICO CAT]

how funny, knetz's response is actually more positive than the response here

and then we say they are always hating on idols

 

 

it's a good ballad with nice lyrics and yes, 4/5 of shinee are decent singers. Stop nitpicking

[Janny]

/sitting here/

 

/eating popcorn/

 

You know people, I find it quite funny how netizens are "only fans/antifans" when they praise another group or put your own faves down, but when they praise your group, their opinions are suddenly relevant again cause there's no way they're fans or smth, noooooo. 

 

You're amusing me tbh, and some of you do seem pressed (for whatever reason, maybe cause your fave group gets their shade all the time (well they shade almost every idol-group) and SHINee doesn't or smth.)

 

Anyways, if you want to put down SHINee's vocal talent then I'm done with you cause if there's one thing I know they're good at it's singing (well and dancing but that's another story). At least considering they're an idol group. 

 

Oh and yeah, just like the person above me said, stop nitpicking. They're good, and they would be even if netizens didn't say so, deal with it.

 

/continues to eat popcorn/

 

/waits for downvotes/

 

   

[ruppi]

It's not doing particularly great tbh - 22 on Melon

 

 

Actually according to the vocals thread its Taemin, then Jjong, then Onew, Key and then Minho.

Oh I see thanks ..still nice to read the compliments

[Red_knight]

Yes I totally agree! SHINee are always the best when it comes to their music and lyrics, other basic bitches be pressed that their faves aren't loved by netizens....    

^^ this

[Good People]

They are so starved of decent vocalists that they think SHINee's vocals are revolutionary or something. SHINee sings well but their voices are super soft. Well I noticed most Korean singers in general can't sing very loudly...